QUiPP应用:对先兆早产采用全员治疗策略的安全替代方案
本研究基于EQUIPP和PETRA研究的前瞻性数据,回顾性评估QUiPP应用(结合早产史、孕龄和胎儿纤连蛋白定量)对24-34周先兆早产孕妇进行分诊的效果。以7天内分娩风险5%为干预阈值,<34周就诊者敏感性100%(单侧97.5%CI 66.4%),阴性预测值100%(97.5%CI 98.9-100%);24+0至29+6周就诊者中89.4%(n=168)入院可被安全避免,而全员治疗策略为0%。
要点
- QUiPP应用以5%风险为阈值分诊先兆早产,<34周就诊者敏感性100%,阴性预测值100%。
- 24+0至29+6周就诊者中89.4%(n=168)入院可被安全避免,全员治疗策略为0%。
- 风险<10%者无一在7天内分娩,未漏诊真性早产。
核心结论
- 对于先兆早产孕妇,QUiPP应用可在1%、5%和10%的sPTB风险阈值下准确指导管理,使绝大多数病例可门诊管理。
- 全员治疗策略不会避免任何孕妇入院,并使188名母亲及其婴儿暴露于不必要的住院和类固醇给药,还因不必要的宫内转运增加网络和转运服务负担。
- sPTB预测应在30周前进行以确定管理,直至有证据表明全员治疗策略所提示的高水平不必要干预比罕见假阴性的发生危害更小。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性收集EQUIPP和PETRA研究中24-34周孕龄、出现早产症状(腹痛或腹部发紧)的孕妇数据进行子分析。
- 每次先兆早产发作均回顾性使用QUiPP应用评估7天内sPTB风险,主要结局为7天内分娩,用于模拟QUiPP应用与全员治疗策略的性能准确性。
主要发现
- 以QUiPP应用7天内分娩风险5%为干预阈值,<34周就诊的9/9名先兆早产孕妇会被正确治疗,敏感性100%(单侧97.5%CI 66.4%),阴性预测值100%(97.5%CI 98.9-100%)。
- 7天内分娩的阳性预测值在<30周就诊者为30.0%(95%CI 11.9-54.3%),在30+0至34+0周就诊者为20.0%(95%CI 12.7-30.1%)。
- 若以5%阈值分诊24+0至29+6周就诊者,89.4%(n=168)的入院可被安全避免,而全员治疗策略为0%。
- 无真性早产病例被漏诊,因为风险<10%者无一在7天内分娩。
关键数值与推荐
- QUiPP应用7天内分娩风险5%作为干预阈值,<34周就诊者敏感性100%(单侧97.5%CI 66.4%),阴性预测值100%(97.5%CI 98.9-100%)。
- 7天内分娩阳性预测值:<30周就诊者30.0%(95%CI 11.9-54.3%),30+0至34+0周就诊者20.0%(95%CI 12.7-30.1%)。
- 24+0至29+6周就诊者以5%阈值分诊,89.4%(n=168)入院可被安全避免,全员治疗策略为0%。
- QUiPP应用可在sPTB风险阈值1%、5%和10%下指导管理。
临床怎么用
- 对于先兆早产孕妇,QUiPP应用可在1%、5%和10%的sPTB风险阈值下准确指导管理,使绝大多数病例可门诊管理。
- sPTB预测应在30周前进行以确定管理。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the impact of triaging women at risk of spontaneous preterm birth (sPTB) using the QUiPP App, which incorporates a predictive model combining history of sPTB, gestational age and quantitative measurements of fetal fibronectin, compared with a treat-all policy (advocated by the UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence) among women with threatened preterm labor before 30 weeks' gestation. METHODS: Prospectively collected data of pregnant women presenting with symptoms of preterm labor (abdominal pain or tightening) at 24-34 weeks' gestation were retrieved from the research databases of the EQUIPP and PETRA studies for subanalysis. Each episode of threatened preterm labor was retrospectively assigned a risk for sPTB within 7 days using the QUiPP App. A primary outcome of delivery within 7 days was used to model the performance accuracy of the QUiPP App compared with a treat-all policy. RESULTS: Using a 5% risk of delivery within 7 days according to the QUiPP App as the threshold for intervention, 9/9 women who presented with threatened preterm labor < 34 weeks would have been treated correctly, giving a sensitivity of 100% (one-sided 97.5% CI, 66.4%) and a negative predictive value of 100% (97.5% CI, 98.9-100%). The positive predictive value for delivery within 7 days was 30.0% (95% CI, 11.9-54.3%) for women presenting before 30 weeks and 20.0% (95% CI, 12.7-30.1%) for women presenting between 30 + 0 and 34 + 0 weeks. If this 5% threshold had been used to triage women presenting between 24 + 0 and 29 + 6 weeks, 89.4% (n = 168) of admissions could have been safely avoided, compared with 0% for a treat-all strategy. No true case of preterm labor would have been missed, as no woman who was assigned a risk of < 10% delivered within 7 days. CONCLUSION: For women with threatened preterm labor, the QUiPP App can accurately guide management at risk thresholds for sPTB of 1%, 5% and 10%, allowing outpatient management in the vast majority of cases. A treat-all approach would not have avoided admission for any woman, and would have exposed 188 mothers and their babies to unnecessary hospitalization and steroid administration and increased the burden on network and transport services owing to unnecessary in-utero transfers. Prediction of sPTB should be performed before 30 weeks to determine management until there is evidence that such a high level of unnecessary intervention, as suggested by the treat-all strategy, does less harm than the occurrence of rare false negatives. Copyright © 2017 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Watson HA, Carter J, Seed PT, et al. The QUiPP App: a safe alternative to a treat-all strategy for threatened preterm labor. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28436125. doi:10.1002/uog.17499
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。