子宫内膜癌患者经阴道与机器人子宫切除术的结局与费用比较
回顾性分析2007年1月至2012年11月接受计划性经阴道子宫切除术(VH)或机器人子宫切除术(RH)的子宫内膜癌患者,按机构方案依据冰冻切片客观分诊淋巴结清扫(LND),并按倾向评分1:1匹配比较结局与费用。匹配后无LND组VH与RH并发症、住院时间、再入院及无进展生存无显著差异,但RH中位手术时间延长1.3小时、中位30天费用高3150美元;需LND组RH费用高921美元(p=0.08)。
要点
- 无LND的50对匹配患者中,VH与RH并发症、住院时间、再入院及无进展生存无显著差异。
- 无LND的50对匹配患者中,RH较VH中位手术时间长1.3小时、中位30天费用高3150美元,均p<0.001。
- 需LND的42对匹配患者中,RH较VH中位30天费用高921美元(p=0.08),仅盆腔LND时VH手术时间长12分钟(p=0.03)。
核心结论
- 对于子宫内膜癌患者,采用经阴道子宫切除术与机器人子宫切除术相比,手术和肿瘤学结局相似且费用更低,应考虑用于需要LND风险低的合适患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2007年1月至2012年11月期间计划接受VH(及腹腔镜LND)或RH(及机器人LND)的子宫内膜癌患者。
- 排除IV期疾病、同时性癌、同时性手术或姑息治疗意图的患者。
- 按机构方案基于冰冻切片客观分诊至LND,VH与RH组按倾向评分1:1匹配比较结局。
主要发现
- 计划VH者153例,其中60例(39%)同期行LND,93例(61%)为低风险无需LND;计划RH者398例,其中225例(56%)需同期LND,173例(44%)无需LND。
- 无LND的50对倾向评分匹配患者中,并发症、住院时间、再入院或PFS无显著差异。
- 无LND的50对匹配患者中,RH较VH中位手术时间长1.3小时、中位30天费用高3150美元(均p<0.001)。
- 需LND的42对匹配患者中,行盆腔及腹主动脉旁LND时中位手术时间无差异,仅行盆腔LND时VH组中位手术时间长12分钟(p=0.03)。
- 需LND的42对匹配患者中,RH较VH中位30天费用高921美元(p=0.08)。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为,对于需要LND风险低的合适子宫内膜癌患者,应考虑采用经阴道子宫切除术,因其手术和肿瘤学结局与机器人子宫切除术相似且费用更低。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare outcomes and cost for patients with endometrial cancer undergoing vaginal hysterectomy (VH) or robotic hysterectomy (RH), with or without lymphadenectomy (LND). METHODS: Patients undergoing planned VH (and laparoscopic LND) or RH (and robotic LND) between January 2007 and November 2012 were reviewed. Patients with stage IV disease, synchronous cancer, synchronous surgery, or treated with palliative intent were excluded. Patients were objectively triaged to LND per institutional protocol based on frozen section. Outcomes were compared between VH and RH groups matched 1:1 on propensity scores. RESULTS: VH was planned in 153 patients; 60 (39%) had concurrent LND while 93 (61%) were low risk and did not require LND. RH was planned in 398 patients; 225 (56%) required concurrent LND and 173 (44%) did not. Among 50 PS-matched pairs without LND, there was no significant difference in complications, length of stay, readmission, or progression free survival. However, median operative time was 1.3h longer and median 30-day cost $3150 higher for RH compared to VH (both p<0.001). Among patients requiring LND, 42 PS-matched pairs were identified. Median operative time was not different when pelvic and para-aortic LND was performed, and 12min longer in the VH group for pelvic LND alone (p=0.03). Median 30-day cost was $921 higher for RH compared to VH when LND was required (p=0.08). CONCLUSION: Utilization of vaginal hysterectomy for endometrial cancer results in similar surgical and oncologic outcomes and lower costs compared to RH and should be considered for appropriate patients with a low risk of requiring LND.
引用
- Nitschmann CC, Multinu F, Bakkum-Gamez JN, et al. Vaginal vs. robotic hysterectomy for patients with endometrial cancer: A comparison of outcomes and cost of care. Gynecol Oncol. 2017. PMID: 28392125. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2017.03.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。