绝育术后输卵管吻合术:一项系统综述
本系统综述纳入37项研究、共10689名女性,评估绝育逆转不同手术方式的生育结局并与体外受精(IVF)比较。绝育逆转后汇总妊娠率为42-69%,异位妊娠率为4-8%;唯一影响受孕机会的预后因素为女性年龄。作者认为对绝育后后悔的女性,输卵管再吻合术是有效治疗,尤其年轻女性,但缺乏与IVF直接比较的随机对照试验。
要点
- 绝育逆转后汇总妊娠率42-69%,异位妊娠率4-8%。
- 唯一影响受孕机会的预后因素是女性年龄。
- 手术方式(除已弃用的宏观开腹技术外)对结局无影响。
核心结论
- 对绝育后后悔的女性,手术输卵管再吻合术是有效治疗,尤其对年轻女性。
- 需要开展比较手术逆转与IVF成功率和成本的随机对照试验。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索截至2016年7月的随机与非随机临床研究。
- 纳入37项研究,共10689名女性;未发现随机对照试验,多数为中等质量的回顾性队列研究。
- 排除因其他原因(如感染、子宫内膜异位症、既往手术粘连)导致输卵管性不孕的患者及样本量<10名参与者的研究。
- 评估女性年龄、BMI、绝育方式和绝育时间等可能影响绝育逆转成功的因素。
主要发现
- 绝育逆转后汇总妊娠率为42-69%,不同手术方式间存在异质性。
- 报告的异位妊娠率为4-8%。
- 唯一影响受孕机会的预后因素是女性年龄。
- 手术方式(开腹[显微]、腹腔镜或机器人)对结局无影响,例外是宏观开腹技术结果较差且目前已不使用。
- 对年龄较大的女性,IVF可能是绝育逆转更具成本效益的替代方案,但缺乏直接比较数据,无法给出年龄界值。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为对绝育后后悔的女性,手术输卵管再吻合术是有效治疗,尤其对年轻女性。
- 作者指出对年龄较大的女性,IVF可能是绝育逆转更具成本效益的替代方案。
- 作者提出需要开展比较手术逆转与IVF成功率和成本的随机对照试验。
局限性
- 未发现随机对照试验,多数研究为中等质量的回顾性队列研究。
- 不同手术方式间存在异质性。
- 缺乏手术逆转与IVF直接比较的数据,无法给出年龄界值。
- 需要开展比较手术逆转与IVF成功率和成本的随机对照试验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Female sterilization is one of the most common contraceptive methods. A small number of women, however, opt for reversal of sterilization procedures after they experience regret. Procedures can be performed by laparotomy or laparoscopy, with or without robotic assistance. Another commonly utilized alternative is IVF. The choice between surgery and IVF is often influenced by reimbursement politics for that particular geographic location. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: We evaluated the fertility outcomes of different surgical methods available for the reversal of female sterilization, compared these to IVF and assessed the prognostic factors for success. SEARCH METHODS: Two search strategies were employed. Firstly, we searched for randomized and non-randomized clinical studies presenting fertility outcomes of sterilization reversal up to July 2016. Data on the following outcomes were collected: pregnancy rate, ectopic pregnancy rate, cost of the procedure and operative time. Eligible study designs included prospective or retrospective studies, randomized controlled trials, cohort studies, case-control studies and case series. No age restriction was applied. Exclusion criteria were patients suffering from tubal infertility from any other reason (e.g. infection, endometriosis and adhesions from previous surgery) and studies including <10 participants. The following factors likely to influence the success of sterilization reversal procedures were then evaluated: female age, BMI and duration and method of sterilization. Secondly, we searched for randomized and non-randomized clinical studies that compared reversal of sterilization to IVF and evaluated them for pregnancy outcomes and cost effectiveness. OUTCOMES: We included 37 studies that investigated a total of 10 689 women. No randomized controlled trials were found. Most studies were retrospective cohort studies of a moderate quality. The pooled pregnancy rate after sterilization reversal was 42-69%, with heterogeneity seen from the different methods utilized. The reported ectopic pregnancy rate was 4-8%. The only prognostic factor affecting the chance of conception was female age. The surgical approach (i.e. laparotomy [microscopic], laparoscopy or robotic) had no impact on the outcome, with the exception of the macroscopic laparotomic technique, which had inferior results and is not currently utilized. For older women, IVF could be a more cost-effective alternative for the reversal of sterilization. However, direct comparative data are lacking and a cut-off age cannot be stated. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: In sterilized women who suffer regret, surgical tubal re-anastomosis is an effective treatment, especially in younger women. However, there is a need for randomized controlled trials comparing the success rates and costs of surgical reversal with IVF.
引用
- van Seeters JAH, Chua SJ, Mol BWJ, et al. Tubal anastomosis after previous sterilization: a systematic review. Hum Reprod Update. 2017. PMID: 28333337. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmx003
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。