胎儿生长受限且32周前分娩的妊娠如何监测:TRUFFLE研究的事后分析
对TRUFFLE研究中317例32周前分娩的胎儿生长受限妊娠进行事后敏感性分析,比较基于胎心监护短变异、静脉导管早期变化或晚期变化决定分娩时机的三组。两静脉导管组无神经损伤生存率均为83%,胎心监护组为77%,差异无统计学意义(P=0.21);存活婴儿中无神经损伤比例静脉导管组93% vs 胎心监护组85%(P=0.049)。7例胎死均发生于静脉导管监测组。
要点
- 32周前分娩的胎儿生长受限妊娠中,静脉导管监测组与胎心监护短变异组无神经损伤生存率无显著差异(83% vs 77%,P=0.21)。
- 存活婴儿无神经损伤比例静脉导管组93% vs 胎心监护组85%(P=0.049)。
- 7例胎死均发生在静脉导管监测组,作者认为可能为偶然效应。
核心结论
- 在32周前分娩的胎儿生长受限妊娠中,基于静脉导管波形变化与基于胎心监护短变异降低决定分娩时机,无神经损伤生存比例无显著差异。
- 胎死不均分布于静脉导管组可能为偶然效应,且该组存活儿童神经结局更好。
- 32周前按研究方案延迟分娩至静脉导管搏动指数或短变异异常和/或胎心反复减速出现,可能安全并可能改善长期结局。
研究设计与样本
- TRUFFLE研究的事后敏感性分析,纳入317例32周前分娩的胎儿生长受限妊娠,排除结局数据缺失或不可避免围产期死亡者。
- 孕妇随机分配至三种分娩指征监测策略组:胎心监护短变异降低组、静脉导管波形早期变化组、静脉导管波形晚期变化组。
- 主要结局为2年无神经损伤生存,采用多变量分析评估分娩前最后监测数据与婴儿结局的关联。
主要发现
- 2年无神经损伤生存率静脉导管两组均为83%,胎心监护短变异组为77%,差异无统计学意义(P=0.21)。
- 存活婴儿中无神经损伤比例静脉导管组93% vs 胎心监护短变异组85%(P=0.049)。
- 全部7例胎死均发生在静脉导管监测组,其中仅1例胎死前近期胎心监护异常。
- 多变量回归显示,入组时较晚孕周、较高估计胎儿体重与第50百分位比值及较低脐动脉搏动指数/胎儿大脑中动脉搏动指数比值与正常结局显著相关。
- 分娩前胎儿动脉多普勒异常与胎心监护短变异组不良结局显著相关;静脉导管血流异常是静脉导管组唯一与不良结局相关的监测参数。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,32周前按研究方案延迟分娩至静脉导管搏动指数或短变异异常和/或胎心反复减速出现,可能安全并可能改善长期结局。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: In the recent TRUFFLE study, it appeared that, in pregnancies complicated by fetal growth restriction (FGR) between 26 and 32 weeks' gestation, monitoring of the fetal ductus venosus (DV) waveform combined with computed cardiotocography (CTG) to determine timing of delivery increased the chance of infant survival without neurological impairment. However, concerns with the interpretation were raised, as DV monitoring appeared to be associated with a non-significant increase in fetal death, and some infants were delivered after 32 weeks, at which time the study protocol no longer applied. This secondary sensitivity analysis of the TRUFFLE study focuses on women who delivered before 32 completed weeks' gestation and analyzes in detail the cases of fetal death. METHODS: Monitoring data of 317 pregnancies with FGR that delivered before 32 weeks were analyzed, excluding those with absent outcome data or inevitable perinatal death. Women were allocated randomly to one of three groups of indication for delivery according to the following monitoring strategies: (1) reduced fetal heart rate short-term variation (STV) on CTG; (2) early changes in fetal DV waveform; and (3) late changes in fetal DV waveform. Primary outcome was 2-year survival without neurological impairment. The association of the last monitoring data before delivery and infant outcome was assessed by multivariable analysis. RESULTS: Two-year survival without neurological impairment occurred more often in the two DV groups (both 83%) than in the CTG-STV group (77%), however, the difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.21). Among the surviving infants in the DV groups, 93% were free of neurological impairment vs 85% of surviving infants in the CTG-STV group (P = 0.049). All fetal deaths (n = 7) occurred in the groups with DV monitoring. Of the monitoring parameters obtained shortly before fetal death in these seven cases, an abnormal CTG was observed in only one case. Multivariable regression analysis of factors at study entry demonstrated that a later gestational age, higher estimated fetal weight-to-50th percentile ratio and lower umbilical artery pulsatility index (PI)/fetal middle cerebral artery-PI ratio were significantly associated with normal outcome. Allocation to DV monitoring had a smaller effect on outcome, but remained in the model (P < 0.1). Abnormal fetal arterial Doppler before delivery was significantly associated with adverse outcome in the CTG-STV group. In contrast, abnormal DV flow was the only monitoring parameter associated with adverse outcome in the DV groups, while fetal arterial Doppler, STV below the cut-off used in the CTG-STV group and recurrent decelerations in fetal heart rate were not. CONCLUSIONS: In accordance with the findings of the TRUFFLE study on monitoring and intervention management of very preterm FGR, we found that the proportion of infants surviving without neuroimpairment was not significantly different when the decision for delivery was based on changes in DV waveform vs reduced STV on CTG. The uneven distribution of fetal deaths towards the DV groups was probably a chance effect, and neurological outcome was better among surviving children in these groups. Before 32 weeks, delaying delivery until abnormalities in DV-PI or STV and/or recurrent decelerations in fetal heat rate occur, as defined by the study protocol, is likely to be safe and possibly benefits long-term outcome. Copyright © 2017 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Ganzevoort W, Mensing Van Charante N, Thilaganathan B, et al. How to monitor pregnancies complicated by fetal growth restriction and delivery before 32 weeks: post-hoc analysis of TRUFFLE study. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28182335. doi:10.1002/uog.17433
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。