文献速递产科母胎医学

植入前与产前诊断、不当出生与不当生命:生物伦理与法律争议的全球视角

Preimplantation and prenatal diagnosis, wrongful birth and wrongful life: a global view of bioethical and legal controversies.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod Update · 2017-01-01

本文综述植入前与产前诊断引发的「不当生命」与「不当出生」索赔的生物伦理和法律争议。全球法院普遍不愿承认不当生命索赔,多数国家驳回此类诉讼但支持不当出生索赔;仅荷兰和美国三州允许不当生命诉讼。法国2002年3月法律明确排除不当生命诉讼。

要点

  • 全球法院因伦理和法律影响普遍不愿承认不当生命索赔。
  • 多数国家驳回不当生命诉讼但支持不当出生索赔。
  • 仅荷兰和美国加利福尼亚、华盛顿、新泽西三州允许不当生命诉讼。

核心结论

  • 全球法院因伦理和法律影响普遍不愿承认不当生命索赔,多数国家驳回此类诉讼但支持不当出生索赔。
  • 法国2002年3月通过法律明确排除不当生命诉讼,仅荷兰和美国三州允许不当生命诉讼。

研究设计与样本

  • 在SocINDEX、Econlit、PopLine、Medline、Embase和Current Contents等数据库及相关来源进行文献检索,聚焦植入前与产前诊断、不当出生与不当生命相关的生物伦理和法律争议。
  • 对国际法律现状进行综述,重点调查不当生命这一特殊问题,并通过比较调查探究不同法域对不当生命索赔的解决方案。

主要发现

  • 法院普遍因伦理和法律影响(如存在即伤害、不出生的权利、损害性质、不存在作为残疾生活的替代)不愿承认不当生命索赔。
  • 多数国家驳回不当生命诉讼但支持不当出生索赔;法国2002年3月法律明确排除不当生命诉讼。
  • 仅荷兰和美国加利福尼亚、华盛顿、新泽西三州允许不当生命诉讼;比利时立法不明确,尽管法院首次裁决允许不当生命诉讼,案件仍在审理中。
  • 爱沙尼亚等少数国家完全缺乏关于不当受孕、不当出生和不当生命的判例法。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Prenatal diagnosis based on different technologies is increasingly used in developed countries and has become a common strategy in obstetric practice. The tests are crucial in enabling mothers to make informed decisions about the possibility of terminating pregnancy. They have generated numerous bioethical and legal controversies in the field of 'wrongful life' claims (action brought by or on behalf of a child against the mother or other people, claiming that he or she has to endure a not-worth-living existence) and 'wrongful birth' claims (action brought by the mother or parents against the physician for being burdened with an unwanted, often disabled child, which could have been avoided). OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: The possibility which exists nowadays to intervene actively by programming and deciding the phases linked to procreation and birth has raised several questions worldwide. The mother's right to self-determination could be an end but whether or not this right is absolute is debatable. Freedom could, with time, act as a barrier that obstructs intrusion into other people's lives and their personal choices. Therapeutic choices may be manageable in a liberal sense, and the sanctity of life can be inflected in a secular sense. These sensitive issues and the various points of view to be considered have motivated this review. SEARCH METHODS: Literature searches were conducted on relevant demographic, social science and medical science databases (SocINDEX, Econlit, PopLine, Medline, Embase and Current Contents) and via other sources. Searches focused on subjects related to bioethical and legal controversies in the field of preimplantation and prenatal diagnosis, wrongful birth and wrongful life. A review of the international state of law was carried out, focusing attention on the peculiar issue of wrongful life and investigating the different jurisdictional solutions of wrongful life claims in a comparative survey. OUTCOMES: Courts around the world are generally reluctant to acknowledge wrongful life claims due to their ethical and legal implications, such as existence as an injury, the right not to be born, the nature of the harm suffered and non-existence as an alternative to a disabled life. Most countries have rejected such actions while at the same time approving those for wrongful birth. Some countries, such as France with a law passed in March 2002, have definitively excluded Wrongful Life action. Only in the Netherlands and in three states of the USA (California, Washington and New Jersey) Wrongful Life actions are allowed. In other countries, such as Belgium, legislation is unclear because, despite a first decision of the Court allowing Wrongful Life action, the case is still in progress. There is a complete lack of case law regarding wrongful conception, wrongful birth and wrongful life in a few countries, such as Estonia. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: The themes of 'wrongful birth' and 'wrongful life' are charged with perplexing ethical dilemmas and raise delicate legal questions. These have met, in various countries and on certain occasions, with different solutions and have triggered ethical and juridical debate. The damage case scenarios result from a lack of information or diagnosis prior to the birth, which deprives the mother of the chance to terminate the pregnancy.

来源:Hum Reprod Update,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Frati P, Fineschi V, Di Sanzo M, et al. Preimplantation and prenatal diagnosis, wrongful birth and wrongful life: a global view of bioethical and legal controversies. Hum Reprod Update. 2017. PMID: 28180264. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmx002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。