文献速递妇科生殖医学

二维/三维子宫输卵管泡沫超声造影与空气/生理盐水子宫输卵管超声造影及腹腔镜染色通液的诊断准确性比较

Accuracy of hysterosalpingo-foam sonography in comparison to hysterosalpingo-contrast sonography with air/saline and to laparoscopy with dye.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2017-01-01

前瞻性观察研究纳入132例不孕女性(259条输卵管),比较二维空气/生理盐水子宫输卵管超声造影、二维/三维泡沫超声造影及二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影与腹腔镜染色通液(参考标准)的诊断准确性。二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影诊断准确性最佳,是唯一与参考方法无显著差异的方法;二维/三维泡沫超声造影和高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影准确性均显著高于二维空气/生理盐水超声造影。

要点

  • 二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影的阳性预测值为71%,显著高于二维空气/生理盐水超声造影的30.4%。
  • 二维空气/生理盐水超声造影阴性预测值99.5%,与二维/三维泡沫超声造影99%和二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影99.6%相似(P > 0.05)。
  • 二维/三维泡沫超声造影和高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影的阳性预测值分别为48%和71%,均显著高于二维空气/生理盐水超声造影(P < 0.05和P < 0.01)。

核心结论

  • 二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影诊断准确性最佳,是唯一与参考方法无显著差异的方法。
  • 二维/三维泡沫超声造影和二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影准确性均显著高于二维空气/生理盐水超声造影。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性观察研究,2013年至2015年间连续纳入132例不孕女性(259条输卵管)。
  • 纳入标准为未行输卵管通畅度检查的育龄不孕女性,就诊于本研究所在的大学医院、私立医院和诊所。
  • 二维空气/生理盐水超声造影、二维/三维泡沫超声造影、二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影及腹腔镜均由经验丰富的阅片者独立完成。

主要发现

  • 二维空气/生理盐水超声造影、二维/三维泡沫超声造影和二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影分别提示46条(17.8%)、27条(10.4%)和24条(9.2%)输卵管阻塞,另有8条(3%)、5条(1.9%)和3条(1.2%)结果不确定。
  • 参考方法显示18条(6.9%)输卵管阻塞。
  • 二维空气/生理盐水超声造影阴性预测值99.5%,与二维/三维泡沫超声造影99%和二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影99.6%相似(P > 0.05),但阳性预测值仅30.4%。
  • 二维/三维泡沫超声造影和二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影阳性预测值分别为48%和71%,均显著高于二维空气/生理盐水超声造影(P < 0.05和P < 0.01),假阳性和不确定结果更少。
  • 二维/三维泡沫超声造影、二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影和二维空气/生理盐水超声造影的阴性似然比分别为0.14、0.06和0.08,阳性似然比分别为14.8、32.1和6.9。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,二维空气/生理盐水超声造影阴性预测值高,适合作为初始检查和基本筛查方法。
  • 作者认为,二维/三维高清晰度血流多普勒泡沫超声造影阳性预测值显著更高,可作为验证二维超声造影可疑或阳性结果的标准。
  • 作者认为,该策略可能显著减少对腹腔镜作为参考标准的需求。

局限性

  • 本研究为未选择的不孕人群,输卵管阻塞患病率低,仅适合评估影像学检查作为筛查工具的诊断准确性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: What is the diagnostic accuracy of 2D/3D hysterosalpingo-foam sonography (HyFoSy) and 2D/3D-high-definition flow Doppler (HDF)-HyFoSy in comparison to laparoscopy with dye chromotubation (as the reference method) and 2D air/saline-enhanced hysterosalpingo-contrast sonography (HyCoSy) (as the initial index test)? SUMMARY ANSWER: 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy had the best diagnostic accuracy and was the only method that did not significantly differ from the reference method, while both 2D/3D-HyFoSy and 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy had significantly higher accuracy than 2D-air/saline-HyCoSy. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Previous studies on X-ray hysterosalpingography and laparoscopy and dye as the reference standard have undermined the impact of older commercial contrast agents on the accuracy of ultrasound tubal patency tests. Recently, HyFoSy was reported to have very high accuracy in a small pilot study in comparison to laparoscopy and dye, and had a very high positive predictive value (PPV) for medical tubal occlusion. A new Doppler sonographic technique, known as HDF imaging with better axial resolution, fewer blooming artifacts and higher sensitivity than color and power Doppler imaging, has been introduced. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: A prospective observational study was performed on 132 women (259 Fallopian tubes) consecutively enrolled between 2013 and 2015. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: This study included infertile women of reproductive age who previously had not been examined for tubal patency and who presented for the evaluation to the university hospital, private hospital and clinic at which this study was conducted. 2D-Air/saline-HyCoSy, 2D/3D-HyFoSy and 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy and laparoscopy were performed independently by experienced readers. During HyFoSy, the 3D mode was used for standardization of pelvic scanning and observations of contrast flow without diagnosis after volume acquisition. Sensitivity, specificity, negative and positive predictive value (NPV and PPV), negative and positive-likelihood ratio (LR- and LR+) and 95% CI were calculated. McNemar's test and relative predictive values (a comparison of NPV and PPV) were used to compare all the index tests. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: 2D-Air/saline-HyCoSy, 2D/3D-HyFoSy and 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy indicated that 46 (17.8%), 27 (10.4%) and 24 (9.2%) of the 259 tubes were occluded, respectively; additionally, inconclusive results were obtained for 8 (3%), 5 (1.9%) and 3 (1.2%) tubes, respectively. The reference method revealed 18 (6.9%) occluded Fallopian tubes. 2D-Air/saline-HyCoSy had a high NPV (99.5%) that was similar to that of 2D/3D-HyFoSy (99%) and 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy (99.6%) (P > 0.05), but had a very low PPV (30.4%). The use of 2D/3D-HyFoSy, especially 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy, which had a significantly higher PPV (48% and 71%, P < 0.05 and P < 0.01; respectively), resulted in fewer false positive and inconclusive findings than the use of 2D-air/saline-HyCoSy. The LR- and LR+ was 0.14 and 14.8, respectively, for 2D/3D-HyFoSy, 0.06 and 32.1, respectively, for 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy, and 0.08 and 6.9, respectively, for 2D-air/saline-HyCoSy. The number of inconclusive or positive results per patient was significantly fewer with 2D/3D-HyFoSy (odds ratio, OR = 0.5, CI = 0.3-0.95, P < 0.05) and 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy (OR = 0.4, 95% CI = 0.2-0.8, P < 0.01) than with 2D-air/saline-HyCoSy. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: An unselected infertile population with a low prevalence of tubal occlusion is suitable for estimating the diagnostic accuracy of imaging tests only as a screening tool. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: These findings can be used to establish a diagnostic strategy with high accuracy but minimum invasiveness and limited use of contrast agents and sophisticated technology. 2D-Air/saline-HyCoSy, which has a high NPV, is suitable as an initial test and basic screening method, but 2D/3D-HDF-HyFoSy, which has a significantly higher PPV, can be used as a standard to verify any questionable or positive results obtained with 2D HyCoSy. This strategy may signficantly reduce the need for laparoscopy as a reference standard. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): There was no external funding for this study, and the authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ludwin I, Ludwin A, Wiechec M, et al. Accuracy of hysterosalpingo-foam sonography in comparison to hysterosalpingo-contrast sonography with air/saline and to laparoscopy with dye. Hum Reprod. 2017. PMID: 28184447. doi:10.1093/humrep/dex013

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。