手术培训对盆腔器官脱垂子宫切除术拟议质量指标执行情况的影响
在一家大型健康维护组织中回顾2008年因盆腔器官脱垂行子宫切除术的630例病历,评估4项拟议质量指标按外科培训背景分层的执行率。专科培训的Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery(FPMRS)医师各项指标执行率最高(91.4-98.7%),累积执行率80.8%;grandfathered FPMRS医师为80.6-95.9%、累积65.3%;妇科全科医师为64.3-70%、累积29.1%。
要点
- 专科培训FPMRS医师4项质量指标累积执行率80.8%,高于grandfathered FPMRS的65.3%和妇科全科的29.1%。
- 单项质量指标执行率:专科培训FPMRS 91.4-98.7%,grandfathered FPMRS 80.6-95.9%,妇科全科64.3-70%。
- 按手术量分层后,高手术量医师执行的质量指标多于低手术量医师。
核心结论
- 在大型健康维护组织中,专科培训的FPMRS医师在因盆腔器官脱垂行子宫切除术的女性中执行拟议质量指标的可能性高于未接受该培训的医师。
- Grandfathered FPMRS医师执行质量指标的频率高于妇科全科医师,但低于专科培训FPMRS医师。
- 原文指出需进一步研究将拟议质量指标与临床结局相关联。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病历审查,纳入2008年1月1日至2008年12月31日在一家大型健康维护组织内因盆腔器官脱垂行子宫切除术的患者,通过电子病历诊断和操作编码识别。
- 共630例因盆腔器官脱垂行子宫切除术且病历完整的患者纳入分析。
- 按主要外科医师培训背景分层:妇科全科医师、专科培训的Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery(FPMRS)医师、grandfathered FPMRS医师。
- 采用描述性统计,并以卡方检验比较按培训背景分层的质量指标执行率,P<.05视为有统计学意义。
主要发现
- 专科培训FPMRS医师行302例子宫切除术,grandfathered FPMRS医师行98例,妇科全科医师行230例。
- 专科培训FPMRS医师单项质量指标执行率为91.4-98.7%,全部指标累积执行率为80.8%。
- Grandfathered FPMRS医师单项质量指标执行率为80.6-95.9%,全部指标累积执行率为65.3%,显著低于专科培训FPMRS医师、高于妇科全科医师。
- 妇科全科医师单项质量指标执行率为64.3-70%,全部指标累积执行率为29.1%。
- 外科医师培训背景与因盆腔器官脱垂行子宫切除术的数量相关,专科医师施行更多子宫切除术;按手术量分层后,高手术量医师执行更多质量指标。
关键数值与推荐
- 评估的4项拟议质量指标为:记录是否提供盆腔器官脱垂保守治疗、盆腔器官脱垂的定量评估(Pelvic Organ Prolapse-Quantification或Baden-Walker)、顶端支持手术的执行、子宫切除术时膀胱镜检查的执行。
- 专科培训FPMRS医师全部指标累积执行率80.8%,grandfathered FPMRS医师65.3%,妇科全科医师29.1%。
- 单项指标执行率范围:专科培训FPMRS医师91.4-98.7%,grandfathered FPMRS医师80.6-95.9%,妇科全科医师64.3-70%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
- 原文结论指出专科培训FPMRS医师更可能执行拟议质量指标,grandfathered FPMRS医师执行频率高于妇科全科医师但低于专科培训FPMRS医师。
- 原文指出需进一步研究将拟议质量指标与临床结局相关联。
局限性
- 原文指出需进一步研究将拟议质量指标与临床结局相关联。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recent healthcare reform has led to increased emphasis on standardized provision of quality care. Use of government- and organization-approved quality measures is 1 way to document quality care. Quality measures, to improve care and aid in reimbursement, are being proposed and vetted in many areas of medicine. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to assess performance of proposed quality measures that pertain to hysterectomy for pelvic organ prolapse stratified by surgical training. The 4 quality measures that we assessed were (1) the documentation of offering conservative treatment of pelvic organ prolapse, (2) the quantitative assessment of pelvic organ prolapse (Pelvic Organ Prolapse-Quantification or Baden-Walker), (3) the performance of an apical support procedure, and (4) the performance of cystoscopy at time of hysterectomy. STUDY DESIGN: Patients who underwent hysterectomy for pelvic organ prolapse from January 1 to December 31, 2008, within a large healthcare maintenance organization were identified by diagnostic and procedural codes within the electronic medical record. Medical records were reviewed extensively for demographic and clinical data that included the performance of the 4 proposed quality measures and the training background of the primary surgeon (gynecologic generalist, fellowship-trained surgeon in Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery, and "grandfathered" Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery). Data were analyzed with the use of descriptive statistics. Inferential statistics with chi-squared tests were used to compare performance rates of quality measures that were stratified by surgical training. Probability values <.05 were considered statistically significant. RESULTS: Six hundred thirty patients who underwent hysterectomy for pelvic organ prolapse in 2008 had complete records available for analysis. Fellowship-trained surgeons performed 302 hysterectomies for pelvic organ prolapse; grandfathered Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery surgeons performed 98 hysterectomies, and gynecologic generalist surgeons performed 230 hysterectomies. Fellowship-trained surgeons had the highest performance rates for individual quality measures (91.4-98.7%) and cumulative performance of all measures (80.8% of cases). Grandfathered Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery surgeons performed significantly fewer measures (80.6-95.9% performance rate for individual measures; 65.3% cumulatively for all measures) than fellowship-trained surgeons and more than gynecologic generalists (64.3-70% for individual measures; 29.1% cumulatively for all measures). There was an association between surgeon training background and number of hysterectomies performed for pelvic organ prolapse, with specialist surgeons performing more hysterectomies. When quality measure performance was stratified by surgeon volume, similar significant associations were found, with high-volume surgeons performing more quality measures than low-volume surgeons. CONCLUSION: Within a large healthcare maintenance organization, fellowship-trained Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery surgeons were more likely to perform proposed quality measures in women who underwent hysterectomy for pelvic organ prolapse compared with those surgeons without such training. Grandfathered Female Pelvic Medicine and Reconstructive Surgery surgeons performed measures more frequently than gynecologic generalists but less than fellowship-trained surgeons. Further study is indicated to correlate the proposed quality measures with clinical outcomes.
引用
- Adams-Piper ER, Guaderrama NM, Chen Q, et al. Impact of surgical training on the performance of proposed quality measures for hysterectomy for pelvic organ prolapse. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28189609. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2017.02.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。