文献速递妇科产科

妇产科高影响因子期刊中审稿人亚专科对科学同行评议的影响

Subspecialty Influence on Scientific Peer Review for an Obstetrics and Gynecology Journal With a High Impact Factor.
PubMed 文献 · Obstet Gynecol · 2017-01-01

该回顾性队列研究分析了2010年1月至2014年12月提交给《Obstetrics & Gynecology》的20,027篇审稿意见,涉及1,889名审稿人。研究发现,不同妇产科亚专科审稿人的审稿质量和拒稿推荐存在差异,计划生育亚专科审稿人的审稿质量评分高于其他多个亚专科,而仅妇科、生殖内分泌、女性盆腔医学和重建手术亚专科审稿人推荐拒稿的调整比值比更高。审稿人经验和亚专科背景对稿件拒稿推荐有影响。

要点

  • 计划生育亚专科审稿人审稿质量评分3.61±0.75,高于仅妇科、生殖内分泌、妇科肿瘤和普通妇产科审稿人。
  • 仅妇科亚专科审稿人推荐拒稿率57.7%,高于非妇产科亚专科审稿人的38.7%。
  • 完成同行评议数量最高五分位(大于195篇)的审稿人推荐拒稿的调整OR为2.85(2.60-3.12),高于最低五分位(1至7篇)。

核心结论

  • 同行评议质量因妇产科亚专科不同而异,妇产科亚专科和审稿人经验对稿件拒稿推荐有影响,审稿人分配对维持严格的稿件筛选流程至关重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性队列研究,分析2010年1月至2014年12月提交给《Obstetrics & Gynecology》的审稿意见,共20,027篇审稿意见来自1,889名审稿人;亚专科根据审稿人选择的分类术语确定。

主要发现

  • 计划生育亚专科审稿人审稿质量评分3.61±0.75,高于仅妇科(3.44±0.78)、生殖内分泌与不孕(3.42±0.72)、妇科肿瘤(3.35±0.75)和普通妇产科(3.32±0.81)审稿人,P<.05。
  • 仅妇科亚专科审稿人推荐拒稿率57.7%,高于非妇产科亚专科审稿人的38.7%,P<.05。
  • 编委会成员推荐拒稿率68.0%,高于新审稿人的41.5%,P<.05。
  • 生殖内分泌、女性盆腔医学和重建手术、仅妇科亚专科审稿人推荐拒稿的调整OR分别为1.23(1.07-1.41)、1.21(1.05-1.39)、1.11(1.02-1.20)。
  • 完成同行评议数量最高五分位(大于195篇)的审稿人推荐拒稿的调整OR为2.85(2.60-3.12),高于最低五分位(1至7篇)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 审稿质量由期刊编辑按5点Likert量表评分;拒稿推荐通过χ检验、方差分析和多变量逻辑回归进行比较。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate whether quality of peer review and reviewer recommendation differ based on reviewer subspecialty in obstetrics and gynecology and to determine the role of experience on reviewer recommendation. METHODS: We performed a retrospective cohort study of reviews submitted to Obstetrics & Gynecology between January 2010 and December 2014. Subspecialties were determined based on classification terms selected by each reviewer and included all major obstetrics and gynecology subspecialties, general obstetrics and gynecology, and nonobstetrics and gynecology categories. Review quality (graded on a 5-point Likert scale by the journal's editors) and reviewer recommendation of "reject" were compared across subspecialties using χ, analysis of variance, and multivariate logistic regression. RESULTS: There were 20,027 reviews from 1,889 individual reviewers. Reviewers with family planning subspecialty provided higher-quality peer reviews compared with reviewers with gynecology only, reproductive endocrinology and infertility, gynecologic oncology, and general obstetrics and gynecology specialties (3.61±0.75 compared with 3.44±0.78, 3.42±0.72, 3.35±0.75, and 3.32±0.81, respectively, P<.05). Reviewers with gynecology-only subspecialty recommended rejection more often compared with reviewers with a nonobstetrics and gynecology subspecialty (57.7% compared with 38.7%, P<.05). Editorial Board members recommended rejection more often than new reviewers (68.0% compared with 41.5%, P<.05). Increased adjusted odds of manuscript rejection recommendation were associated with reproductive endocrinology, female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery, and gynecology-only reviewer subspecialty (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 1.23 [1.07-1.41], 1.21 [1.05-1.39], and 1.11 [1.02-1.20]). Manuscript rejection recommendation rate was also increased for reviewers who had completed the highest quintile of peer reviews (greater than 195) compared with the lowest quintile (one to seven) (adjusted OR 2.85 [2.60-3.12]). CONCLUSION: Peer review quality differs based on obstetrics and gynecology subspecialty. Obstetrics and gynecology subspecialty and reviewer experience have implications for manuscript rejection recommendation. Reviewer assignment is pivotal to maintaining a rigorous manuscript selection process.

来源:Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Parikh LI, Benner RS, Riggs TW, et al. Subspecialty Influence on Scientific Peer Review for an Obstetrics and Gynecology Journal With a High Impact Factor. Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 28079780. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000001852

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。