辅助生殖技术后出生青少年的学业表现——一项基于全国登记数据的队列研究
丹麦全国登记队列研究比较1995-1998年出生、15-16岁辅助生殖技术(ART)青少年与自然妊娠(SC)青少年的九年级标准化测试成绩。ART单胎校正后平均成绩显著低于SC单胎,但差异很小,可能无临床意义;ART双胎与SC双胎校正后无差异。
要点
- ART单胎校正后总平均成绩较SC单胎低0.15分(95%CI -0.29至-0.02)。
- ART双胎与SC双胎校正后学业表现无显著差异。
- ART单胎与ART双胎的粗略及校正平均成绩相似。
核心结论
- ART单胎校正后平均测试成绩显著低于SC单胎,但差异很小,可能无临床意义。
- ART双胎与SC双胎校正后学业表现无差异。
- 作者认为父母生育力低下或ART治疗的潜在小幅负面影响可能被ART父母较高的教育水平所抵消。
研究设计与样本
- 丹麦全国登记为基础的队列研究,纳入1995-1998年出生的全部4766名ART青少年(2836名单胎和1930名双胎),并与随机选取的5660名SC单胎及7064名SC双胎比较;随访期间死亡的9名儿童被排除。
主要发现
- 粗略平均测试成绩:ART单胎较SC单胎高0.41分(95%CI 0.30-0.53),ART双胎较SC双胎高0.45分(95%CI 0.28-0.62)。
- 校正后总平均成绩:ART单胎较SC单胎低0.15分(95%CI -0.29至-0.02)。
- 校正后父母最高与最低教育水平间平均成绩差为2.05分(95%CI 1.82-2.28),提示ART效应较传统预测因素弱。
- 校正后ART单胎数学和物理/化学平均成绩显著低于SC单胎。
- 校正后ART双胎与SC双胎学业表现无差异;ART单胎与ART双胎粗略及校正总平均成绩相似。
局限性
- 1995-1997年出生队列中6.6%的15-16岁青少年教育测试成绩缺失,敏感性分析显示各组缺失风险无显著差异,不太可能使结果产生偏倚。
- 无法对体重指数和孕期吸烟进行调整。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Is academic performance in adolescents aged 15-16 years and conceived after ART, measured as test scores in ninth grade, comparable to that for spontaneously conceived (SC) adolescents? SUMMARY ANSWER: ART singletons had a significantly lower mean test score in the adjusted analysis when compared with SC singletons, yet the differences were small and probably not of clinical relevance. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Previous studies have shown similar intelligence quotient (IQ) levels in ART and SC children, but only a few have been on adolescents. Academic performance measured with standardized national tests has not previously been explored in a complete national cohort of adolescents conceived after ART. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: A Danish national registry-based cohort including all 4766 ART adolescents (n = 2836 singletons and n = 1930 twins) born in 1995-1998 were compared with two SC control cohorts: a randomly selected singleton population (n = 5660) and all twins (n = 7064) born from 1995 to 1998 in Denmark. Nine children who died during the follow-up period were excluded from the study. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Mean test scores on a 7-point-marking scale from -3 to 12 were compared, and adjustments were made for relevant reproductive and socio-demographic covariates including occupational and educational level of the parents. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The crude mean test score was higher in both ART singletons and ART twins compared with SC adolescents. The crude mean differences were +0.41 (95% CI 0.30-0.53) and +0.45 (95% CI 0.28-0.62) between ART and SC singletons and between ART and SC twins, respectively. However, the adjusted mean overall test score was significantly lower for ART singletons compared with SC singletons (adjusted mean difference -0.15 (95% CI -0.29-(-0.02))). For comparison, the adjusted mean difference was +2.05 (95% CI 1.82-2.28) between the highest and the lowest parental educational level, suggesting that the effect of ART is weak compared with the conventional predictors. The adjusted analyses showed significantly lower mean test scores in mathematics and physics/chemistry for ART singletons compared with SC singletons. Comparing ART twins with SC twins yielded no difference in academic performance in the adjusted analyses. Similar crude and adjusted overall mean test scores were found when comparing ART singletons and ART twins. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Missing data on educational test scores occurred in 6.6% of adolescents aged 15-16 years for the birth cohorts 1995-1997, where all of the children according to their age should have passed the ninth grade exam at the time of data retrieval. As sensitivity analyses yielded no significant difference in the adjusted risk of having missing test scores between any of the groups, it is unlikely that this should bias our results. Adjustment for body mass index and smoking during pregnancy was not possible. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: As our results are based on national data, our findings can be applied to other populations. The findings of this paper suggest that a possible small negative effect of parental subfertility or ART treatment is counterbalanced by the higher educational level in the ART parents. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS: The Danish Medical Association in Copenhagen (KMS) funded this study with a scholarship grant. None of the authors had any competing interests. TRIAL REGISTRATION NO STATISTICS DENMARK: 704676.
引用
- Spangmose AL, Malchau SS, Schmidt L, et al. Academic performance in adolescents born after ART-a nationwide registry-based cohort study. Hum Reprod. 2017. PMID: 28057876. doi:10.1093/humrep/dew334
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。