文献速递生殖医学

胚胎学家在选择单个第5天胚胎用于移植时的观察者间与观察者内一致性:一项多中心研究

Inter-observer and intra-observer agreement between embryologists during selection of a single Day 5 embryo for transfer: a multicenter study.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2016-12-28

该前瞻性研究纳入同一机构5家IVF诊所的10名胚胎学家,基于100例病例的2D图像评估选择单个第5天胚胎移植的观察者间与观察者内一致性。选择胚胎的观察者间kappa=0.734(95%CI 0.665-0.791),观察者内kappa=0.759(95%CI 0.622-0.833),总体良好但非最优;形态学分级一致性仅为一般至中等。

要点

  • 10名胚胎学家在100例中50例全体一致选择同一胚胎,93例中至少6人一致。
  • 选择第5天胚胎移植的观察者间kappa=0.734,观察者内kappa=0.759。
  • 第5天胚胎形态学分级一致性仅为一般至中等,最高为发育阶段评分kappa=0.513。

核心结论

  • 胚胎学家选择单个第5天胚胎用于移植的观察者间与观察者内一致性总体良好但非最优,即使经验丰富的胚胎学家亦然。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性研究,纳入同一机构5家IVF诊所的10名胚胎学家,于2013年7月至2015年11月进行。
  • 基于年度质量保证项目囊胚评分分数选取前10名胚胎学家,对100例病例的2D图像进行第5天胚胎形态学分级并选择单个移植胚胎,共评估1000次决策。

主要发现

  • 100例中50例所有10名胚胎学家选择同一胚胎,93例中至少6名胚胎学家一致。
  • 选择单个第5天胚胎用于移植的观察者间kappa=0.734(95%CI 0.665-0.791),观察者内kappa=0.759(95%CI 0.622-0.833)。
  • 亚组分析未实质性改变观察者间与观察者内一致性。
  • 第5天胚胎形态学分级观察者间一致性仅为一般至中等,最高为发育阶段评分kappa=0.513(95%CI 0.492-0.538)。

局限性

  • 所有胚胎学家均已完成培训并在同一机构下工作,5家诊所政策相似,故在不同政策或不同培训水平诊所的胚胎学家间观察者间一致性可能不会如此高。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: What is the inter-observer and intra-observer agreement between embryologists when selecting a single Day 5 embryo for transfer? SUMMARY ANSWER: The inter-observer and intra-observer agreement between embryologists when selecting a single Day 5 embryo for transfer was generally good, although not optimal, even among experienced embryologists. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Previous research on the morphological assessment of early stage (two pronuclei to Day 3) embryos has shown varying levels of inter-observer and intra-observer agreement. However, single blastocyst transfer is now becoming increasingly popular and there are no published data that assess inter-observer and intra-observer agreement when selecting a single embryo for Day 5 transfer. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This was a prospective study involving 10 embryologists working at five different IVF clinics within a single organization between July 2013 and November 2015. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: The top 10 embryologists were selected based on their yearly Quality Assurance Program scores for blastocyst grading and were asked to morphologically grade all Day 5 embryos and choose a single embryo for transfer in a survey of 100 cases using 2D images. A total of 1000 decisions were therefore assessed. For each case, Day 5 images were shown, followed by a Day 3 and Day 5 image of the same embryo. Subgroup analyses were also performed based on the following characteristics of embryologists: the level of clinical embryology experience in the laboratory; amount of research experience; number of days per week spent grading embryos. The agreement between these embryologists and the one that scored the embryos on the actual day of transfer was also evaluated. Inter-observer and intra-observer variability was assessed using the kappa coefficient to evaluate the extent of agreement. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: This study showed that all 10 embryologists agreed on the embryo chosen for transfer in 50 out of 100 cases. In 93 out of 100 cases, at least 6 out of the 10 embryologists agreed. The inter-observer and intra-observer agreement among embryologists when selecting a single Day 5 embryo for transfer was generally good as assessed by the kappa scores (kappa = 0.734, 95% CI: 0.665-0.791 and 0.759, 95% CI: 0.622-0.833, respectively). The subgroup analyses did not substantially alter the inter-observer and intra-observer agreement among embryologists. The agreement when Day 3 images were included alongside Day 5 images of the same embryos resulted in a change of mind at least three times by each embryologist (on average for <10% of cases) and resulted in a small decrease in inter-observer and intra-observer agreement between embryologists (kappa = 0.676, 95% CI: 0.617-0.724 and 0.752, 95% CI: 0.656-808, respectively).The assessment of the inter-observer agreement with regard to morphological grading of Day 5 embryos showed only a fair-to-moderate agreement, which was observed across all subgroup analyses. The highest overall kappa coefficient was seen for the grading of the developmental stage of an embryo (0.513; 95% CI: 0.492-0.538). The findings were similar when the individual embryologists were compared with the embryologist who made the morphological assessments of the available embryos on the actual day of transfer. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: All embryologists had already completed their training and were working under one organization with similar policies between the five clinics. Therefore, the inter-observer agreement might not be as high between embryologists working in clinics with different policies or with different levels of training. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The generally good, although not optimal uniformity between participating embryologists when selecting a Day 5 embryo for transfer, as well as, the surprisingly low agreement when morphologically grading Day 5 embryos could be improved, potentially resulting in increased pregnancy rates. Future studies need to be directed toward technologies that can help achieve this. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS: None declared. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: Not applicable.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Storr A, Venetis CA, Cooke S, et al. Inter-observer and intra-observer agreement between embryologists during selection of a single Day 5 embryo for transfer: a multicenter study. Hum Reprod. 2016. PMID: 28031323. doi:10.1093/humrep/dew330

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。