表达性写作干预对不孕夫妇的效果:一项随机对照试验
该随机对照试验于2010年11月至2012年7月纳入295名接受辅助生殖技术(ART)治疗的夫妇,随机分为表达性写作干预(EWI)组或中性写作对照组,比较抑郁、焦虑、不孕相关困扰及妊娠率。结果显示EWI组抑郁症状较对照组显著降低(P=0.049),但焦虑及不孕相关困扰无显著改善,妊娠率无显著差异。
要点
- EWI组抑郁症状较对照组显著降低(P=0.049;Cohen's d=0.27),效应量小。
- EWI对焦虑无显著效果,对伴侣不孕相关困扰的个人子领域反而显著增加(P=0.01;Cohen's d=0.24)。
- 妊娠率EWI组42/83(50.6%)vs对照组40/80(49.4%),无显著差异(RR=0.99;95%CI 0.725, 1.341;P=0.94)。
核心结论
- 与对照组相比,EWI显著降低抑郁症状,但未显著降低焦虑和不孕相关困扰。
- EWI对妊娠率无显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- 2010年11月至2012年7月开展随机对照试验,共295名参与者(女性163名,男性132名)随机分配至EWI组或中性写作对照组。
- 参与者为接受IVF/ICSI治疗的夫妇;排除单身女性、接受植入前遗传学诊断的夫妇以及从人工授精紧急转为IVF的夫妇。
- EWI组进行三次20分钟居家写作练习,聚焦不孕/生育治疗相关的情感表露(两次)和获益发现(一次);对照组进行三次20分钟非情感性日常活动写作。
- 参与者在治疗开始时(t1)、妊娠检测前(t2)及3个月后(t3)完成问卷;失访率26.8%(79/295)。
- 采用混合线性模型比较两组心理结局随时间的变化,采用卡方检验比较妊娠率组间差异。
主要发现
- EWI组153名参与者(女性83名,男性70名),中性写作对照组142名(女性83名,男性62名)。
- EWI组女性和伴侣的抑郁症状较对照组均表现出更大程度的降低(P=0.049;95%CI:-0.04;-0.01;Cohen's d=0.27)。
- EWI对焦虑的效应未达统计学显著。
- EWI组伴侣的总体不孕相关困扰较对照组伴侣边缘性增加(P=0.06;Cohen's d=0.17),个人子领域增加达统计学显著(P=0.01;Cohen's d=0.24)。
- 妊娠率EWI组42/83(50.6%)vs对照组40/80(49.4%),无显著差异(RR=0.99;95%CI:0.725, 1.341;P=0.94)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为EWI是一种可能具有成本效益且易于实施的居家干预,即使效应量小也可能有意义。
- 作者认为面对不孕时,EWI可作为缓解抑郁症状的相关工具,允许表达可能被视为社会不可接受的不孕感受。
- 作者指出该干预的意义似乎不适用于男性,男性随时间表现出不孕相关困扰增加。
局限性
- 抑郁症状的结果对应小效应量,其余结果未达统计学显著。
- 可能因样本特征导致地板效应,因为未排除基线情绪困扰水平低的参与者。
- 男性随时间表现出不孕相关困扰增加。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Is expressive writing intervention (EWI) efficacious in reducing distress and improving pregnancy rates for couples going through ART treatment? SUMMARY ANSWER: Compared to controls, EWI statistically significantly reduced depressive symptoms but not anxiety and infertility-related distress. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: ART treatment is considered stressful. So far, various psychological interventions have been tested for their potential in reducing infertility-related distress and the results are generally positive. It remains unclear whether EWI, a brief and potentially cost-effective intervention, could be advantageous. STUDY DESIGN SIZE, DURATION: Between November 2010 and July 2012, a total of 295 participants (163 women, 132 men) were randomly allocated to EWI or a neutral writing control group. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Participants were couples undergoing IVF/ICSI treatment. Single women and couples with Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis or acute change of procedure from insemination to IVF, were excluded. EWI participants participated in three 20-min home-based writing exercises focusing on emotional disclosure in relation to infertility/fertility treatment (two sessions) and benefit finding (one session). Controls wrote non-emotionally in three 20-min sessions about their daily activities. The participants completed questionnaires at the beginning of treatment (t1), prior to the pregnancy test (t2), and 3 months later (t3). In total, 26.8% (79/295) were lost to follow-up. Mixed linear models were chosen to compare the two groups over time for psychological outcomes (depression, anxiety and infertility-related distress), and a Chi2 test was employed in order to examine group differences in pregnancy rates MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: One hundred and fifty-three participants received EWI (women = 83; men = 70) and 142 participants were allocated to the neutral writing control group (women = 83; men = 62). Both women and partners in the EWI group exhibited greater reductions in depressive symptoms compared with controls (P = 0.049; [CI 95%: -0.04; -0.01] Cohen's d = 0.27). The effect of EWI on anxiety did not reach statistical significance. Overall infertility-related distress increased marginally for the partners in the EWI group compared to the partners in the control group (P = 0.06; Cohen's d = 0.17). However, in relation to the personal subdomain, the increase was statistically significant (P = 0.01; Cohen's d = 0.24). EWI had no statistically significant effect on pregnancy rates with 42/83 (50.6%) achieving pregnancy in the EWI group compared with 40/80 (49.4%) in the control group (RR = 0.99 [CI 95% = 0.725, 1.341]; P = 0.94). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The results for depressive symptoms corresponded to a small effect size and the remaining results failed to reach statistical significance. This could be due to sample characteristics leading to a possible floor-effect, as we did not exclude participants with low levels of emotional distress at baseline. Furthermore, men showed increased infertility-related distress over time. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: EWI is a potentially cost-effective and easy to implement home-based intervention, and even small effects may be relevant. When faced with infertility, EWI could thus be a relevant tool for alleviating depressive symptoms by allowing the expression of feelings about infertility that may be perceived as socially unacceptable. However, the implications do not seem to be applicable for men, who presented with increased infertility-related distress over time. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS: The present study was supported by research grants from Merck Sharpe and Dohme and The Danish Agency for Science Technology and Innovation as part of a publicly funded PhD. The funding bodies had no influence on the data collection, analysis or conclusions of the study. None of the authors have any conflicts of interest to declare. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: Clinicaltrials.gov, trial no. NCT01187095. TRIAL REGISTRATION DATE: 7th September 2010 DATE OF FIRST PATIENT'S ENROLMENT: 23rd November 2010.
引用
- Frederiksen Y, O'Toole MS, Mehlsen MY, et al. The effect of expressive writing intervention for infertile couples: a randomized controlled trial. Hum Reprod. 2016. PMID: 28007790. doi:10.1093/humrep/dew320
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。