确定良性适应证子宫切除术的最佳路径:临床决策树算法
本研究评估引入机器人手术后良性子宫切除术实践的变化,使用基于阴道可及性和子宫大小的决策树算法确定预期手术路径。机器人队列中,算法指定阴道途径时仍有20.7%采用机器人、5.1%采用开腹;与阴道子宫切除术相比,机器人手术时间更长、手术部位感染和尿路感染率更高。遵循算法预计5年内可节省约80万美元医院成本。
要点
- 算法指定阴道子宫切除术时,阴道途径手术时间更短、感染率更低、成本更低。
- 机器人子宫切除术手术时间141分钟 vs 阴道子宫切除术59分钟,P<.001。
- 机器人子宫切除术手术部位感染率4.7% vs 阴道子宫切除术0.2%,P<.001。
核心结论
- 当决策树算法指定阴道子宫切除术为首选路径时,阴道子宫切除术与更短的手术时间、更低的感染率和更低的成本相关。
- 在可行的情况下,阴道子宫切除术应作为首选路径。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性机器人后队列(2009-2013年)纳入良性子宫切除术,通过使用阴道可及性和子宫大小为决策树分支的算法确定预期手术路径,排除腹腔镜子宫切除术路径。
- 机器人前队列(2004-2005年)用于评估加入机器人技术(2007年)后的实践变化,并估算成本。
主要发现
- 机器人前队列(n=473)中,320例(67.7%)经阴道施行,153例(32.3%)经开腹施行;算法指定阴道子宫切除术时,15.1%(46/305)经腹部施行。
- 机器人后队列(n=1,198)中,672例(56.1%)经阴道,390例(32.6%)为机器人辅助,136例(11.4%)经腹部。
- 在743例手术中,预期阴道途径时,38例(5.1%)涉及开腹,154例(20.7%)涉及机器人技术。
- 与阴道子宫切除术相比,机器人子宫切除术手术时间更长(141分钟 vs 59分钟,P<.001),手术部位感染率更高(4.7% vs 0.2%,P<.001),尿路感染率更高(8.1% vs 4.1%,P=.05),但主要并发症(P=.27)或再入院(P=.27)无差异。
- 遵循算法预计5年内可节省约80万美元医院成本。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,当决策树算法指定阴道子宫切除术为首选路径时,阴道子宫切除术与更短的手术时间、更低的感染率和更低的成本相关。
- 作者建议,在可行的情况下,阴道子宫切除术应作为首选路径。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate practice change after initiation of a robotic surgery program using a clinical algorithm to determine the optimal surgical approach to benign hysterectomy. METHODS: A retrospective postrobot cohort of benign hysterectomies (2009-2013) was identified and the expected surgical route was determined from an algorithm using vaginal access and uterine size as decision tree branches. We excluded the laparoscopic hysterectomy route. A prerobot cohort (2004-2005) was used to evaluate a practice change after the addition of robotic technology (2007). Costs were estimated. RESULTS: Cohorts were similar in regard to uterine size, vaginal parity, and prior laparotomy history. In the prerobot cohort (n=473), 320 hysterectomies (67.7%) were performed vaginally and 153 (32.3%) through laparotomy with 15.1% (46/305) performed abdominally when the algorithm specified vaginal hysterectomy. In the postrobot cohort (n=1,198), 672 hysterectomies (56.1%) were vaginal; 390 (32.6%) robot-assisted; and 136 (11.4%) abdominal. Of 743 procedures, 38 (5.1%) involved laparotomy and 154 (20.7%) involved robotic technique when a vaginal approach was expected. Robotic hysterectomies had longer operations (141 compared with 59 minutes, P<.001) and higher rates of surgical site infection (4.7% compared with 0.2%, P<.001) and urinary tract infection (8.1% compared with 4.1%, P=.05) but no difference in major complications (P=.27) or readmissions (P=.27) compared with vaginal hysterectomy. Algorithm conformance would have saved an estimated $800,000 in hospital costs over 5 years. CONCLUSION: When a decision tree algorithm indicated vaginal hysterectomy as the route of choice, vaginal hysterectomy was associated with shorter operative times, lower infection rate, and lower cost. Vaginal hysterectomy should be the route of choice when feasible.
引用
- Schmitt JJ, Carranza Leon DA, Occhino JA, et al. Determining Optimal Route of Hysterectomy for Benign Indications: Clinical Decision Tree Algorithm. Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 27926638. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000001756
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。