TRUFFLE研究中310例32周前分娩的胎儿生长受限婴儿的分娩监测指征与2年结局
本文为TRUFFLE研究的posthoc亚组分析,纳入310例32周前分娩、2岁校正年龄结局已知的胎儿生长受限婴儿,按分配的监测策略与分娩指征分析。仅32%活产儿按指定监测参数分娩,38%因安全网标准分娩;DV组联合的2年完整存活率高于CTG-STV组(活产仅P=0.05,含胎死P=0.21),DV两组间无差异。
要点
- 仅32%活产儿按指定监测参数分娩,38%因安全网标准、15%因其他胎儿原因、15%因母体原因分娩。
- CTG-STV组51%因STV降低分娩,DV-p95组34%因DV异常分娩,DV-no-A组仅10%因相应指征分娩。
- DV两组联合的2年完整存活率高于CTG-STV组(活产仅P=0.05,含胎死P=0.21),DV两组间无差异。
核心结论
- 本亚组分析中多数32周前分娩婴儿的分娩原因并非分配的监测策略指征。
- 作者推测CTG-STV组结局稍差可能因缺乏DV数据,因DV组以CTG-STV为安全网而CTG-STV组无DV安全网标准。
- 作者认为早期宫内生长受限胎儿的最佳分娩时机可能最好通过纵向联合DV与CTG监测来确定。
研究设计与样本
- TRUFFLE研究的posthoc亚组分析,纳入310例2岁校正年龄结局已知的病例及7例胎死,排除7例不可避免的围产期死亡。
- 按分配的胎儿监测策略结合分娩指征分析数据。
- TRUFFLE研究将孕妇分配至三种分娩指征监测策略组:CTG胎心率短变异降低组、DV波形早期变化(DV-p95)组、DV波形晚期变化(DV-no-A)组。
主要发现
- 总体仅32%活产儿按指定监测参数分娩,38%因安全网标准分娩,15%因其他胎儿原因分娩,15%因母体原因分娩。
- CTG-STV组51%婴儿因STV降低分娩,DV-p95组34%因DV异常分娩,DV-no-A组仅10%因相应指征分娩。
- DV组多数婴儿因胎心率自发减速这一安全网标准分娩。
- DV两组联合的2年完整存活率高于CTG-STV组(活产仅P=0.05,含胎死P=0.21),DV两组间无差异。
- CTG-STV组结局较差仅限于安全网亚组中因胎心率减速分娩的婴儿;因母体原因分娩的婴儿出生体重最高,完整存活率无显著升高。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为早期宫内生长受限胎儿的最佳分娩时机可能最好通过纵向联合DV与CTG监测来确定。
局限性
- 本文为TRUFFLE研究的posthoc亚组分析。
- 作者推测CTG-STV组结局稍差可能因缺乏DV数据,该解释为推测性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: In the TRUFFLE (Trial of Randomized Umbilical and Fetal Flow in Europe) study on the outcome of early fetal growth restriction, women were allocated to one of three groups of indication for delivery according to the following monitoring strategies: (1) reduced fetal heart rate (FHR) short-term variation (STV) on cardiotocography (CTG); (2) early changes in fetal ductus venosus (DV) waveform (DV-p95); and (3) late changes in fetal DV waveform (DV-no-A). However, many infants per monitoring protocol were delivered because of safety-net criteria, for maternal or other fetal indications, or after 32 weeks of gestation when the protocol was no longer applied. The objective of the present posthoc subanalysis was to investigate the indications for delivery in relation to 2-year outcome in infants delivered before 32 weeks to further refine management proposals. METHODS: We included all 310 cases of the TRUFFLE study with known outcome at 2 years' corrected age and seven fetal deaths, excluding seven cases with inevitable perinatal death. Data were analyzed according to the allocated fetal monitoring strategy in combination with the indication for delivery. RESULTS: Overall, only 32% of liveborn infants were delivered according to the specified monitoring parameter for indication for delivery; 38% were delivered because of safety-net criteria, 15% for other fetal reasons and 15% for maternal reasons. In the CTG-STV group, 51% of infants were delivered because of reduced STV. In the DV-p95 group, 34% of infants were delivered because of abnormal DV and, in the DV-no-A group, only 10% of infants were delivered accordingly. The majority of infants in the DV groups were delivered for the safety-net criterion of spontaneous decelerations in FHR. Two-year intact survival was highest in the DV groups combined compared with the CTG-STV group (P = 0.05 for live births only, P = 0.21 including fetal death), with no difference between DV groups. A poorer outcome in the CTG-STV group was restricted to infants delivered because of FHR decelerations in the safety-net subgroup. Infants delivered because of maternal reasons had the highest birth weight and a non-significantly higher intact survival. CONCLUSIONS: In this subanalysis of infants delivered before 32 weeks, the majority were delivered for reasons other than the allocated monitoring strategy indication. Since, in the DV group, CTG-STV criteria were used as a safety net but in the CTG-STV group, no DV safety-net criteria were applied, we speculate that the slightly poorer outcome in the CTG-STV group might be explained by the absence of DV data. The optimal timing of delivery of fetuses with early intrauterine growth restriction may therefore be best determined by monitoring them longitudinally, with both DV and CTG monitoring. Copyright © 2016 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Visser GHA, Bilardo CM, Derks JB, et al. Fetal monitoring indications for delivery and 2-year outcome in 310 infants with fetal growth restriction delivered before 32 weeks' gestation in the TRUFFLE study. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2017. PMID: 27854382. doi:10.1002/uog.17361
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。