流产诊断时的治疗决策
一项混合方法研究纳入55例早期流产女性及15名产科医生,探讨治疗决策因素。34例(62%)选择手术,19例(35%)选择药物,2例(4%)期待治疗。经产妇较初产妇更少改变初始选择(12% vs 42%,OR 0.18)。手术组月收入更高(调整OR 1.30)且社会支持更多(调整OR 2.45)。满意度与支持性临床团队和快速解决相关。
要点
- 经产妇较初产妇更少在咨询后改变初始治疗选择(12% vs 42%,OR 0.18)。
- 手术组较药物组月收入更高(调整OR 1.30)且社会支持更多(调整OR 2.45)。
- 无论选择何种治疗,满意度均与支持性临床团队和快速解决相关。
核心结论
- 既往妊娠经历、责任和社会人口学因素影响流产管理决策。
- 结构化咨询,尤其对初产妇,可能改善医生和患者的流产照护体验。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,纳入临床稳定的寻求手术、药物或期待治疗的早期流产女性(N=55),完成人口学和社会心理调查。
- 采用目的抽样,45例(82%)完成深度访谈;访谈15名产科医生。
- 采用归纳和演绎编码的整合方法进行内容分析;患者主题按治疗选择分层;分析变量与治疗选择之间的关联。
主要发现
- 34例女性(62%)接受手术治疗,19例(35%)接受药物治疗,2例(4%)接受期待治疗。
- 经产妇较初产妇更少在咨询后改变初始治疗选择(12% vs 42%,OR 0.18,95%CI 0.04-0.81,P=.03)。
- 最终接受手术治疗者较药物组月收入更高(调整OR 1.30,95%CI 1.04-1.63,P=.023)且社会支持更多(调整OR 2.45,95%CI 1.07-5.61,P=.035)。
- 手术组将接受丧失、对手术的良好认知和希望加快流产作为决定性因素;药物组将对流产的控制和时间安排、更私密环境、对手术或麻醉的厌恶以及改善生育力保护的认知作为决定性因素。
- 无论治疗选择如何,治疗满意度与支持性临床团队和快速解决相关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the factors patients and physicians prioritize during first-trimester miscarriage management and assess what drives satisfaction with care. METHODS: We conducted a mixed-methods study of clinically stable women seeking surgical, medical, or expectant miscarriage treatment. Women with first-trimester fetal demise or anembryonic gestation (N=55) completed demographic and psychosocial surveys. Using purposive sampling, 45 (82%) completed in-depth interviews. Fifteen obstetricians were interviewed. Participants described factors that informed their counseling (physicians) or decision-making (patients). Content analysis used an integrated approach with inductively and deductively derived codes. Patient-derived themes were stratified by treatment choice. Associations between variables and treatment choices were analyzed. RESULTS: Thirty-four women (62%) received surgical management, 19 (35%) received medical, and two (4%) received expectant. Physicians expected that women with prior pregnancies have strong management preferences, and indeed, multigravid patients were less likely to change their initial treatment choice after counseling than primigravid patients (12% compared with 42%, odds ratio [OR] 0.18, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.04-0.81, P=.03). Physicians favored patient-centered decisions and patients chose the treatment that they thought would least affect other responsibilities. Those ultimately receiving surgical management had a higher monthly income (adjusted OR 1.30, 95% CI 1.04-1.63, P=.023) and more social support (adjusted OR 2.45, 95% CI 1.07-5.61, P=.035) than the medical group. The surgical group cited loss acceptance, a favorable perception of surgery, and a desire to expedite the miscarriage as decisive factors. The medical group endorsed control over, and timed completion of, the miscarriage in a more intimate setting, an aversion to surgery or anesthesia, and a perception of improved fertility preservation as decisive factors. Regardless of treatment choice, satisfaction with treatment was linked to a supportive clinical team and expeditious resolution. CONCLUSION: Prior pregnancy experiences, obligations, and sociodemographic factors influence miscarriage management decision-making. Structured counseling, especially for primigravid patients, could improve both the physician and the patient experience with miscarriage care.
引用
- Schreiber CA, Chavez V, Whittaker PG, et al. Treatment Decisions at the Time of Miscarriage Diagnosis. Obstet Gynecol. 2016. PMID: 27824749
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。