全腹腔镜子宫切除术与阴式子宫切除术:系统评价与Meta分析
该系统评价纳入24篇比较全腹腔镜子宫切除术(TLH)与阴式子宫切除术(VH)的随机对照试验和队列研究。两组总体并发症、输尿管及膀胱损伤、术中出血量和住院时间无显著差异,VH手术时间更短、阴道残端裂开和转开腹率更低、费用更低,TLH术后疼痛评分更低且镇痛需求更少。
要点
- 两组总体并发症、输尿管及膀胱损伤、术中出血量和住院时间无显著差异。
- VH与更短手术时间、更低阴道残端裂开和转开腹率及更低费用相关。
- TLH组术后视觉模拟评分更低且镇痛需求更少,但部分指标差异未达统计学显著。
核心结论
- 尽管TLH与VH结果相似,但当两种手术均可行时,VH目前仍与更大获益相关,如更短手术时间、更低阴道裂开和转开腹率及更低费用。
研究设计与样本
- 系统评价与Meta分析,遵循流行病学观察性研究Meta分析指南,检索PubMed、Embase和Web of Science从2000年1月至2016年2月的相关文献,纳入比较TLH与VH的随机对照试验和队列研究(良性指征或低度恶性肿瘤),共纳入24篇文章。
主要发现
- 主要并发症OR 1.24(95%CI .68, 2.28),次要并发症OR .83(95%CI .53, 1.28),两组无差异。
- 输尿管和膀胱损伤OR .81(95%CI .34, 1.92),术中出血量平均差-30 mL(95%CI -67.34, 7.60),住院时间平均差-.61天(95%CI -1.23, -.01),两组无差异。
- VH与更短手术时间相关(平均差42分钟,95%CI 29.34, 55.91),阴道残端裂开率更低(OR 6.28,95%CI 2.38, 16.57),转开腹率更低(OR 3.89,95%CI 2.18, 6.95)。
- VH费用更低但未达统计学显著(平均差3889.9美元,95%CI 2120.3, 89000)。
- TLH组术后视觉模拟评分更低(平均差-1.08,95%CI -1.74, -.42),且镇痛需求更少、时间更短(平均差-.64天,95%CI -1.06, -.22)。
临床怎么用
- 许多因素影响子宫切除术手术方式的选择,推荐共同决策。
- 确定最佳手术方式是一个动态过程,需要随着技术改进频繁重新评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Hysterectomies performed laparoscopically have greatly increased within the last few decades and even exceed the number of vaginal hysterectomies (VHs). This systematic review, conducted according to the Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology guidelines, compares surgical outcomes of total laparoscopic hysterectomy (TLH) and VH to evaluate which approach offers the most benefits. A literature search was performed in PubMed, Embase, and Web of Science for all relevant publications from January 2000 to February 2016. All randomized controlled trials and cohort studies for benign indication or low-grade malignancy comparing TLH with VH were considered for inclusion. From the literature search, 24 articles were found to be relevant and included in this review. The results of our meta-analysis showed no difference between the 2 groups for overall complications (OR 1.24 [.68, 2.28] for major complications; OR .83 [.53, 1.28] for minor complications), risk of ureter and bladder injuries (OR .81 [.34, 1.92]), intraoperative blood loss (mean difference [MD] -30 mL [-67.34, 7.60]), and length of hospital stay (-.61 days [-1.23, -.01]). VH was associated with a shorter operative time (MD 42 minute [29.34, 55.91]) and a lower rate of vaginal cuff dehiscence (OR 6.28 [2.38, 16.57]) and conversion to laparotomy (OR 3.89 [2.18, 6.95]). Although not significant, the costs of procedure were lower for VH (MD 3889.9 dollars [2120.3, 89 000]). Patients in the TLH group had lower postoperative visual analog scale scores (MD -1.08, [-1.74, -.42]) and required less analgesia during a shorter period of time (MD -.64 days, [-1.06, -.22]). Defining the best surgical approach is a dynamic process that requires frequent re-evaluation as techniques improve. Although TLH and VH result in similar outcomes, our meta-analysis showed that when both procedures are feasible, VH is currently still associated with greater benefits, such as shorter operative time, lower rate of vaginal dehiscence and conversion to laparotomy, and lower costs. Many factors influence the choice for surgical approach to hysterectomy, and shared decision-making is recommended.
引用
- Sandberg EM, Twijnstra ARH, Driessen SRC, et al. Total Laparoscopic Hysterectomy Versus Vaginal Hysterectomy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2016. PMID: 27867051. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2016.10.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。