胎儿脑室增宽的专家共识与持续不确定性:德尔菲研究
国际德尔菲研究邀请56名胎儿医学专家,两轮后45人完成。第一轮39题中20题达共识;第二轮60项陈述中6项正共识、4项负共识、50项未达共识。共识涵盖测量技术、三级分级、神经超声检查、MRI时机、神经外科转诊及分娩管理,未共识领域分为证据缺乏、框架分歧和定义不明三类。
要点
- 共识覆盖标准化测量、三级分级、全面神经超声与病因检查、MRI时机个体化、阶梯式神经外科转诊及分娩管理。
- 未共识领域分类:证据缺乏型30%、框架分歧型32%、定义不明型8%、证据缺乏合并定义不明型30%。
- 脑室不对称是最大未共识集群(12项),其中92%归为证据缺乏合并定义不明。
核心结论
- 德尔菲研究在胎儿脑室增宽产前管理的多个关键决策点形成专家共识,并系统梳理了持续不确定的领域。
- 共识主要适用于专科和转诊中心。
研究设计与样本
- 两轮改良德尔菲研究,国际胎儿医学专家组,专家通过系统综述近十年包含超过50例脑室增宽病例的出版物选出。
- 第一轮39个多选题,共识定义为≥75%专家选择同一选项;未共识项改为9点李克特量表进入第二轮,共60项陈述。
- 第二轮共识需同时满足≥75%有效应答者评分在7–9或1–3区间且四分位距≤2。
- 56名专家完成第一轮,45名(80%)完成第二轮。
主要发现
- 第一轮20/39(51%)问题达共识;第二轮6/60(10%)陈述达正共识,4项(7%)达负共识,50项(83%)未达共识。
- 两轮共识覆盖标准化测量技术、三级分级、全面神经超声与检查、胎儿MRI时机个体化、阶梯式神经外科转诊及分娩管理。
- 未共识领域分类:15/50(30%)为证据缺乏型,16/50(32%)为框架分歧型,4/50(8%)为定义不明型,15/50(30%)为证据缺乏合并定义不明型。
- 脑室不对称集群12项中11项(92%)归为证据缺乏合并定义不明型,反映缺乏前瞻性结局数据和公认操作定义。
关键数值与推荐
- 第一轮共识阈值:≥75%专家选择单一答案选项。
- 第二轮共识阈值:≥75%有效应答者评分在7–9或1–3区间且四分位距≤2。
- 未共识领域分类:1型证据缺乏、2型框架分歧、3型定义不明,可单独或组合出现。
临床怎么用
- 临床可参照共识推荐进行脑室增宽的标准化测量、三级分级、全面神经超声与病因检查、个体化MRI时机、阶梯式神经外科转诊及分娩管理。
- 对于脑室不对称等未共识领域,应认识到缺乏前瞻性结局数据和统一操作定义,决策需个体化并充分沟通不确定性。
局限性
- 共识主要适用于专科和转诊中心,向其他级别医疗机构推广需谨慎。
- 未共识领域比例较高,部分领域缺乏前瞻性证据支持。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
ABSTRACT Objectives Fetal ventriculomegaly (VM) is a common prenatal finding with heterogeneous etiology and unpredictable outcome, yet its management remains among the least standardized in fetal medicine. This study aimed to establish expert consensus on key decision points in the prenatal management of fetal VM, and to systematically map the domains of persistent uncertainty as a structured framework for future research priorities. Methods A two-round modified Delphi study was conducted with an international panel of experts in fetal medicine, selected through a systematic review of publications that included more than 50 cases of VM over the preceding decade. Round 1 comprised 39 multiple-choice questions, with consensus achieved when ≥ 75% of panelists selected a single answer option; items that did not reach consensus were reformulated into Likert-scale statements for Round 2, which comprised 60 statements rated on a 9-point Likert scale. In Round 2, consensus was defined by two simultaneous criteria: ≥ 75% of valid respondents scoring in the agreement (score, 7–9) or disagreement (score, 1–3) zone, with an interquartile range of ≤ 2. Non-consensus domains were classified using a post-hoc taxonomic framework into three categories: absent evidence (Type 1), divergent clinical frameworks (Type 2) and undefined construct (Type 3), which could occur independently or in combination. Results Of 56 experts who completed Round 1, 45 (80%) also completed Round 2. In Round 1, consensus was reached on 20/39 (51%) questions. In Round 2, 6/60 (10%) statements reached positive consensus and four (7%) reached negative consensus; 50 (83%) did not reach consensus. Over the two rounds, consensus was achieved on standardized measurement technique, three-tier grading, comprehensive neurosonographic and investigative work-up, individualization of the timing of fetal magnetic resonance imaging, stepwise neurosurgical referral and delivery management of fetal VM. Classification of non-consensus domains identified 15/50 (30%) items as Type 1, 16/50 (32%) as Type 2, 4/50 (8%) as Type 3 and 15/50 (30%) as Type 1+3. Ventricular asymmetry, the largest non-consensus cluster with 12 items, was classified as Type 1+3 in 11/12 (92%) statements, reflecting the simultaneous absence of prospective outcome data and of a universally accepted operational definition. Conclusions This Delphi study provides structured expert-derived guidance, primarily applicable to specialist and referral
引用
- Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology:Consensus and persistent uncertainty in fetal ventriculomegaly: Delphi study mapping unresolved clinical domains and research priorities
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。