产时超声处理困难分娩:面向普通产科医生的实用解读
本文面向不常规行产时超声的普通产科医生、产科住院医师及住院医师,围绕胎头位置不确定、产程缓慢或停滞、阴道助产前三个临床情境,提出五个可通过超声回答的问题,并指出超声判断胎头位置比阴道检查更准确,但站位与屈伸度的阈值证据有限,尚无试验证实依据这些测量可降低母儿病率。
要点
- 产时超声用凸阵探头,图像少、耐受性好,可辅助阴道检查不确定时决策。
- 超声判断枕位比阴道检查更准确,两项随机试验显示加做超声提高枕位知晓准确率。
- 站位与屈伸度测量可重复且与分娩方式相关,但阈值来自小队列且受多种因素影响。
核心结论
- 产时超声可作为阴道检查不确定或更准确评估可改变处理时的辅助手段,不应替代临床检查。
- 超声判断枕位比阴道检查更准确,但站位与屈伸度阈值证据有限,尚无试验证实可降低母儿病率。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为叙述性综述,面向普通产科医生、产科住院医师及住院医师,围绕三个临床情境和五个临床问题展开。
主要发现
- 比较阴道检查与超声的助产前研究显示,约五分之一至三分之一的检查对枕位判断不一致。
- 阴道检查估计站位同样不精确,尤其存在明显产瘤时。
- 两项随机试验显示加做超声提高枕位知晓准确率,一项随机试验报告真空杯放置更准确。
- 站位与屈伸度测量可重复且与分娩方式相关,但已发表阈值来自小队列,与阴道检查站位相关,并受探头压力、产瘤、塑形、产次及枕位影响。
- 尚无试验显示依据这些测量采取行动可降低母儿病率。
关键数值与推荐
- 胎头位置:经腹部识别中线脑回声、眼眶、小脑及颈椎确定。
- 枕后位是否可能自转:参考胎儿脊柱朝向。
- 屈伸与不均倾:枕前/枕横位用量枕-脊柱角,枕后位用颏-胸角量化。
- 胎头高低及入盆:经会阴测量进展角及胎头-会阴距离。
- 下降:连续测量及胎头方向评估。
临床怎么用
- 在胎头位置不确定、产程缓慢或停滞、阴道助产前可考虑产时超声辅助决策。
- 超声图像少、用凸阵探头、孕妇耐受优于反复阴道检查。
- 应认识到站位与屈伸度阈值证据有限,不能仅凭超声测量替代临床判断。
局限性
- 站位与屈伸度阈值来自小队列,与阴道检查站位相关,受探头压力、产瘤、塑形、产次及枕位影响。
- 尚无随机试验证实依据超声测量采取行动可降低母儿病率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Difficult labor-protracted or arrested dilatation in the first stage, arrest of descent in the second stage, and the decision whether to attempt an assisted vaginal delivery-accounts for a large proportion of intrapartum cesarean deliveries and for most of the maternal and neonatal morbidity attributable to instrumental delivery. The decisions made in these situations rest almost entirely on 3 pieces of information obtained by digital vaginal examination: the position of the fetal occiput, the attitude of the fetal head, and the station of the leading bony point. Digital examination is uncomfortable, must be repeated, and is least reliable when the clinical stakes are highest. Caput succedaneum, molding, deflection of the head, and a high presenting part obscure the sutures and fontanelles on which the examination depends, and the ischial spines are palpated rather than visualized. Studies comparing digital examination with sonography before assisted vaginal delivery have reported discordant assessments of occiput position in approximately one-fifth to one-third of examinations, and digital estimation of station is similarly imprecise, particularly in the presence of substantial caput. Sonography in labor is performed with the curvilinear transducer, which is already available on most labor wards, requires a small number of images, and is better tolerated by women than repeated digital examinations. This article is written for general obstetricians, laborists, and residents who manage labor but who do not routinely scan during labor, rather than for clinicians who are already practicing intrapartum sonography. It is organized around 3 clinical situations in which a scan may change management-an uncertain fetal head position, slow or arrested labor, and the period immediately before an assisted vaginal delivery-and around 5 clinical questions that arise within them. The 5 questions, and the sonographic answer to each, are: what is the position of the fetal head, answered by transabdominal identification of the midline cerebral echo, orbits, cerebellum, and cervical spine; if the occiput is posterior, is spontaneous rotation likely, as suggested by the orientation of the fetal spine; is the head well flexed and is it asynclitic, quantified by the occiput-spine angle in occiput-anterior and occiput-transverse positions and by the chin-to-chest angle in occiput-posterior positions; how low is the head and has it engaged, quantified transperineally by the angle of progression and the head-perineum distance; and is the head descending during pushing, assessed by serial measurements and by the direction of the fetal head. The evidence supporting these measurements is uneven and should be described accurately. Sonographic determination of occiput position is more accurate than digital examination. Of note, 2 randomized trials show that adding a scan improves the accuracy with which the position is known, and 1 randomized trial reported more accurate placement of the vacuum cup. The measurements of station and attitude are reproducible and are consistently associated with the mode of delivery, but their published thresholds are derived from modest cohorts, are correlated with digital station, and are influenced by transducer pressure, caput, molding, parity, and occiput position. No trial has yet shown that acting on these measurements reduces maternal or neonatal morbidity. Sonography should therefore be used as an adjunct when clinical examination is uncertain or when a more accurate assessment could alter management and not as a replacement for it.
引用
- Mappa I, Rizzo G. Intrapartum sonography for difficult labor. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2026. PMID: 42600675. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2026.08.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。