文献速递妇科

超声与MRI术前诊断深部子宫内膜异位症的头对头前瞻性比较:#Enzian分类

Head-to-head prospective comparison of diagnostic accuracy of preoperative ultrasonography and MRI in patients undergoing surgery for deep endometriosis using #Enzian classification.
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol · 2026-08-06

前瞻性纳入463例因临床怀疑子宫内膜异位症行腹腔镜的绝经前女性,对比经阴道及经腹超声(按IDEA方案)与MRI术前诊断效能。超声在#Enzian T区粘连的特异度显著高于MRI,其余各区敏感度与特异度无显著差异;两者对各区深部内异症诊断效能相近。

要点

  • 超声按IDEA方案在#Enzian T区(左侧P=0.0336,右侧P=0.0153)特异度显著高于MRI。
  • 其余#Enzian各区敏感度与特异度在超声与MRI间无统计学显著差异。
  • 超声在附件区病变/粘连严重度分级与手术评估的完全一致率高于MRI。

核心结论

  • 按IDEA方案行超声评估对#Enzian T区盆腔粘连的特异度显著高于MRI,其余相关#Enzian各区超声与MRI诊断深部内异症的敏感度和特异度相近且均较高。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性观察性研究,纳入2021年4月1日至2024年5月31日于三级转诊中心因临床怀疑子宫内膜异位症行腹腔镜的绝经前女性463例。
  • 所有受试者均接受经阴道及经腹超声(按IDEA方案)与MRI评估,超声医师与放射科医师互盲。
  • 以#Enzian分区O、T、A、B、C、FI、FB、FU、FO评估诊断效能,采用McNemar检验比较敏感度与特异度。

主要发现

  • 超声在#Enzian O左、O右、T左、T右、A、B左、B右、C、FI、FU、FB、FO的敏感度分别为97.52%、97.22%、85.15%、85.26%、92.66%、88.81%、86.79%、95.79%、75.00%、76.19%、83.72%、60.00%,特异度分别为96.77%、97.73%、96.63%、94.79%、91.02%、96.66%、96.92%、95.60%、98.77%、97.96%、99.05%、99.56%。
  • MRI对应敏感度分别为95.04%、94.44%、77.23%、74.74%、90.37%、88.06%、90.57%、94.21%、83.93%、71.43%、74.42%、90.00%,特异度分别为95.89%、95.75%、92.70%、89.86%、93.47%、96.05%、94.96%、94.14%、97.05%、99.10%、98.57%、98.90%。
  • 超声在#Enzian T区左侧(P=0.0336)和右侧(P=0.0153)特异度显著高于MRI,其余敏感度或特异度比较均无统计学显著差异。
  • 超声在附件区病变/粘连严重度分级与手术评估的完全一致率高于MRI:O左96.3% vs 94.8%、O右97.2% vs 94.6%、T左93.9% vs 89.0%、T右92.6% vs 86.7%。
  • 对于深部内异症结节,超声在#Enzian C区与腹腔镜的完全一致率较MRI高3.1个百分点(94.0% vs 90.9%)。

临床怎么用

  • 超声按IDEA方案可作为术前评估#Enzian T区盆腔粘连的优选影像方法,其特异度显著高于MRI。
  • 对#Enzian其他相关分区深部内异症的术前评估,超声与MRI诊断效能相近,可结合临床可及性选择。
  • 超声在附件区严重度分级及#Enzian C区结节与手术评估的一致率较高,有助于术前规划。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To perform a head-to-head comparison of the diagnostic performance of ultrasonography (US) vs magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the preoperative detection of endometriosis using the #Enzian classification system. METHODS: This was a prospective observational study of postmenarchal premenopausal women who underwent laparoscopy between 1 April 2021 and 31 May 2024 in a tertiary referral center for clinical suspicion of endometriosis. All women underwent both transvaginal and transabdominal US imaging, according to the International Deep Endometriosis Analysis (IDEA) protocol, as well as MRI evaluation. The sonologist and the radiologist were blinded to each other's results. The diagnostic performance of US and MRI were determined for the following #Enzian compartments: O (ovarian endometriosis), T (adhesions at the level of the tubo-ovarian unit), A (deep endometriosis (DE) in the vagina, rectovaginal septum and torus uterinus), B (DE in the uterosacral ligament, cardinal ligament, parametrium and pelvic sidewall), C (DE in the rectosigmoid bowel), FI (lesions in other intestinal locations), FB (urinary bladder involvement), FU (ureteric involvement) and FO (lesions in other extragenital locations). The sensitivity and specificity were compared between imaging modalities using McNemar's test. Concordance between preoperative imaging and surgical assessment of #Enzian severity grade for endometriotic lesions/adhesions in #Enzian compartments O, T, A, B and C was assessed. RESULTS: In total, 463 women who underwent laposcopy for diagnosis and excisional treatment of endometriosis were enrolled in the study. For the detection of endometriotic lesions/adhesions in #Enzian compartments Oleft, Oright, Tleft, Tright, A, Bleft, Bright, C, FI, FU, FB and FO, US had a sensitivity of 97.52%, 97.22%, 85.15%, 85.26%, 92.66%, 88.81%, 86.79%, 95.79%, 75.00%, 76.19%, 83.72% and 60.00%, respectively, and a specificity of 96.77%, 97.73%, 96.63%, 94.79%, 91.02%, 96.66%, 96.92%, 95.60%, 98.77%, 97.96%, 99.05% and 99.56%, respectively. For MRI, the corresponding values for sensitivity were 95.04%, 94.44%, 77.23%, 74.74%, 90.37%, 88.06%, 90.57%, 94.21%, 83.93%, 71.43%, 74.42% and 90.00%, and those for specificity were 95.89%, 95.75%, 92.70%, 89.86%, 93.47%, 96.05%, 94.96%, 94.14%, 97.05%, 99.10%, 98.57% and 98.90%. US had significantly higher specificity in #Enzian compartment T on both the left (P = 0.0336) and right (P = 0.0153) sides compared with MRI, but no other comparisons of sensitivity or specificity between US and MRI showed statistically significant differences. US showed higher exact concordance with surgical assessment in severity grading for lesions/adhesions in the adnexa than did MRI (Oleft, 96.3% vs 94.8%; Oright, 97.2% vs 94.6%; Tleft, 93.9% vs 89.0%; Tright, 92.6% vs 86.7%). For DE nodules, US showed a 3.1 percentage point higher exact concordance with laparoscopy compared with MRI in #Enzian compartment C (94.0% vs 90.9%). CONCLUSIONS: US evaluation following the IDEA protocol has significantly higher specificity compared with that of MRI for pelvic adhesions in #Enzian compartment T. However, US and MRI have similarly high sensitivity and specificity for diagnosing DE in all relevant #Enzian compartments. © 2026 The Author(s). Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

来源:Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Pete B, Turtóczki K, Bokor A, et al. Head-to-head prospective comparison of diagnostic accuracy of preoperative ultrasonography and MRI in patients undergoing surgery for deep endometriosis using #Enzian classification. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2026. PMID: 42561188. doi:10.1002/uog.70298

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。