腹腔镜子宫肌瘤剔除或子宫切除术中袋内旋切技术的系统综述与网络荟萃分析
该系统综述与网络荟萃分析比较了腹腔内、腹腔外和阴道内三种袋内旋切技术在腹腔镜子宫肌瘤剔除或子宫切除术中的安全性和围手术期结局,共纳入6项研究。结果显示各技术在术中并发症方面无显著差异,阴道内袋内旋切较腹腔内袋内旋切手术时间显著缩短(-36.6分钟),但证据数量与精确度有限,技术选择应个体化。
要点
- 三种袋内旋切技术在术中并发症上无显著差异。
- 阴道内袋内旋切比腹腔内袋内旋切手术时间缩短36.6分钟。
- 证据有限,技术选择应基于患者特征、标本特点、设备及术者经验个体化。
核心结论
- 现有比较数据未显示腹腔镜子宫肌瘤剔除或子宫切除术中可用的袋内旋切技术在围手术期安全性方面存在显著差异。
- 阴道内袋内旋切可能较腹腔内袋内旋切缩短手术时间,但鉴于证据数量与精确度有限,应谨慎解读。
- 在更高质量比较数据出现前,袋内旋切技术的选择应根据患者特征、标本特点、可用设备和术者经验个体化。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与网络荟萃分析,检索Cochrane Library、Embase和PubMed从建库至2024年1月31日的研究。
- 纳入比较2种或以上袋内旋切技术并报告至少1项预设结局的对照研究,最终6项研究纳入网络荟萃分析。
- 采用独立随机效应频率学派网络荟萃分析,估计比值比或均数差及95%置信区间。
主要发现
- 术中并发症:袋内手动 vs 腹腔内袋内 OR=0.46 [0.05; 3.98];袋内手动 vs 阴道内袋内 OR=0.63 [0.11; 3.61];阴道内袋内 vs 腹腔内袋内 OR=0.73 [0.14; 3.84],异质性或不一致性中等(τ²=0.9,I²=36% [0%; 76%])。
- 阴道内袋内技术比腹腔内袋内操作显著更快(-36.6分钟 [-68.5; -4.8])。
- 按手术类型(子宫切除术或肌瘤剔除术)的亚组分析未显示术中并发症的统计学差异;在肌瘤剔除患者中,腹腔内袋内技术的总手术时间显著长于其他两种技术。
- 其他敏感性分析得出相同结论。
临床怎么用
- 临床选择袋内旋切技术时应综合考虑患者特征、标本特征、可用设备和术者经验,实施个体化决策。
- 阴道内袋内旋切可能缩短手术时间,但需结合证据局限性谨慎应用。
局限性
- 纳入比较研究数量有限(6项),证据精确度有限。
- 存在中等异质性或不一致性(τ²=0.9,I²=36% [0%; 76%])。
- 需要未来足够效能的标准化多中心比较研究评估临床相关结局和成本效益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To compare the safety and perioperative outcomes of the 3 currently available in-bag morcellation techniques-intra-abdominal, extra-abdominal, and intra-vaginal-during laparoscopic myomectomy or hysterectomy using a systematic review and network meta-analysis. DATA SOURCES: Searches were conducted in Cochrane Library, Embase, and PubMed, covering studies from inception up to January 31, 2024. METHODS OF STUDY SELECTION: Comparative studies evaluating 2 or more in-bag morcellation techniques during laparoscopic myomectomy and/or hysterectomy and reporting at least 1 predefined outcome were eligible. The co-primary outcomes were endoscopic bag disruption and intraoperative complications, defined as a composite of conversion to laparotomy, bowel injury, or accidental visceral or vascular injury. TABULATION, INTEGRATION AND RESULTS: Independent random-effect frequentist network meta-analyses (NMA) were carried out on each outcome, to estimate odds ratios (OR) or differences in means with corresponding 95% confidence intervals. Overall, 6 out of 1970 published studies were included in the NMAs. No significant impact of morcellation techniques was shown on intraoperative complications (in-bag manual vs intra-abdominal in-bag: OR = 0.46 [0.05; 3.98], in-bag manual vs intra-vaginal in-bag: OR = 0.63 [0.11; 3.61], intra-vaginal in-bag vs intra-abdominal in-bag: OR = 0.73 [0.14; 3.84] with moderate heterogeneity or inconsistency (τ² = 0.9, I² = 36% [0%; 76%]). The intra-vaginal in-bag technique was statistically significantly faster than intra-abdominal in-bag procedure (-36.6 minutes [-68.5; -4.8]). The subgroup analyses on the surgery type (hysterectomy or myomectomy) did not show any statistical difference between morcellation techniques for intraoperative complications; however, among patients undergoing myomectomy, total operative time was significantly longer with the intra-abdominal in-bag technique compared with the other 2 techniques. Other sensitivity analyses led to the same conclusions. CONCLUSIONS: Current comparative data do not demonstrate significant differences in perioperative safety among available in-bag morcellation techniques during laparoscopic myomectomy or hysterectomy. Although intra-vaginal in-bag morcellation may shorten operative time compared with intra-abdominal in-bag morcellation, these findings should be interpreted cautiously given the limited quantity and precision of the available evidence. Until higher-quality comparative data become available, selection of the in-bag morcellation technique should be individualized according to patient characteristics, specimen features, available equipment, and surgeon expertise. Future adequately powered multicenter comparative studies evaluating standardized surgical techniques, different tissue containment systems, clinically relevant outcomes, and cost-effectiveness are warranted.
引用
- Chene G, Nyangoh-Timoh K, Agostini A, et al. Comparison Between the In-Bag Morcellation Techniques During Laparoscopic Myomectomy or Hysterectomy: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2026. PMID: 42537750. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2026.07.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。