羊水过多遗传学检查的国际与跨专业差异调查
一项国际电子问卷调查了154名临床医生,评估羊水过多定义及遗传学检查策略的差异。多数以绝对超声值而非百分位定义;17.8%对所有羊水过多建议有创诊断,41.8%仅在合并其他异常时建议。遗传学检查策略受专业和地域因素影响显著。
要点
- 羊水过多定义多采用绝对超声值而非百分位。
- 仅17.8%对所有羊水过多建议有创诊断。
- 遗传学检查策略因专业和地域而异。
核心结论
- 羊水过多遗传学评估存在显著国际与跨专业差异,受专业和地域因素驱动。
- 缺乏一致证据基础,需研究按临床场景和检测方式定义诊断率以指导循证决策。
研究设计与样本
- 国际电子问卷调查,共154名来自不同地区的临床医生完成。
- 调查内容涵盖羊水过多定义、推荐有创产前诊断的标准及首选遗传检测策略。
- 按地理区域和专业进行分析。
主要发现
- 多数受访者使用绝对超声值而非百分位定义羊水过多。
- 17.8%对所有羊水过多妊娠推荐有创诊断检测。
- 41.8%仅在合并其他异常时推荐有创诊断检测。
- 母胎医学专家对轻度孤立病例较不倾向于推荐有创诊断检测。
- 遗传学家和遗传咨询师更倾向于推荐产前遗传检测。
关键数值与推荐
- 17.8%的受访者对所有羊水过多妊娠推荐有创诊断检测。
- 41.8%的受访者仅在合并其他异常时推荐有创诊断检测。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应认识到羊水过多遗传学检查策略存在专业和地域差异。
- 决策时需结合当地资源和医疗体系特点。
局限性
- 调查结果反映实践模式差异,可能受当地资源和医疗体系影响。
- 缺乏一致证据基础,需进一步研究定义诊断率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate international and interprofessional variability in the definition and genetic evaluation of polyhydramnios, and to identify factors influencing clinical decision-making. METHOD: An international electronic survey was distributed to healthcare professionals, addressing definitions of polyhydramnios, criteria for recommending invasive diagnostic prenatal testing, and preferred genetic testing strategies. Responses were analyzed by geographic region and professional specialty. RESULTS: A total of 154 clinicians from diverse regions completed the survey. Most defined polyhydramnios using absolute ultrasound values rather than percentiles. While 17.8% recommended invasive diagnostic testing for any pregnancy with polyhydramnios, 41.8% did so only when additional anomalies were present. Maternal-fetal medicine specialists were less likely to recommend invasive diagnostic testing (e.g., amniocentesis), particularly for mild isolated cases, whereas geneticists and genetic counselors were more likely to recommend prenatal genetic testing. US-based respondents were more likely to recommend only fetal chromosome analysis, whereas Israeli respondents tended to recommend advanced molecular diagnostics even in isolated cases. CONCLUSION: Substantial variability was noted in the genetic evaluation of polyhydramnios, driven by specialty and geographic factors. These findings highlight the absence of a consistent evidence base and underscore the need for studies defining diagnostic yield by clinical scenario and testing modality to inform evidence-based decision-making, while recognizing that practice patterns also reflect local resources and healthcare systems.
引用
- Zemet R, Yaron Y, Sagi-Dain L, et al. Variation in the Genetic Workup of Polyhydramnios: An International and Inter-Specialty Survey. Prenat Diagn. 2026. PMID: 41806306. doi:10.1002/pd.70110
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。