公众对剩余冷冻卵子捐赠研究之同意流程的态度
该在线实验调查纳入225名英国公众代表,评估信息告知程度与偏好满足对同意流程的评价。结果显示具体与宽泛告知均被视为足以支持知情同意(均分6.49/7与5.79/7),而偏好满足是判断自主性与道德对待的关键。公众支持宽泛同意模式以促进捐赠。
要点
- 公众认为具体和宽泛信息告知均能支持知情同意。
- 偏好满足是判断捐赠者自主性与道德对待的关键因素。
- 建议考虑转向宽泛同意模式以促进剩余冷冻卵子捐赠研究。
核心结论
- 公众支持具体和宽泛两种同意模式的信息告知要求,且认为宽泛模式更能增强自主性并促进对捐赠者的道德对待。
研究设计与样本
- 在线实验调查,纳入225名英国公众代表,采用情境实验设计、自由文本问题及人口学数据收集。
主要发现
- 具体告知的同意判断均值为6.49/7,宽泛告知为5.79/7,均被视为足以支持知情同意。
- 偏好满足时自主性判断均值为5.46/7、道德判断为5.63/7;未满足时分别为3.96/7和4.76/7。
关键数值与推荐
- 具体告知同意判断均值6.49/7,宽泛告知均值5.79/7。
- 偏好满足时自主性判断均值5.46/7、道德判断均值5.63/7;未满足时自主性均值3.96/7、道德均值4.76/7。
临床怎么用
- 提示应审查并可能更新剩余冷冻卵子捐赠研究的同意流程。
- 可考虑转向宽泛同意模式,以帮助更多捐赠者实现处置偏好并缓解研究用卵短缺。
局限性
- 在线调查的生态效度有限,数据可能存在应答偏倚。
- 样本量相对较小。
- 样本基于英国,结果向其他国家推广可能受限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: In the context of donating surplus frozen eggs (SFE) to research, what level of information disclosure, and associated consent model, do the public believe most effectively allows donors to make an informed decision, exercise autonomy, and be treated morally? SUMMARY ANSWER: The public supports the information disclosure requirements of both a specific and broad consent model in this context, with the latter considered to better enhance autonomy and facilitate the moral treatment of SFE donors. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Despite research indicating that many individuals' first preference is to donate their SFEs to research, donation rates remain low. One possible reason for this is the way consent processes for the donation of SFEs to research are currently regulated, specifically that their high information requirements limit opportunities to donate. There is a notable lack of research on how consent processes should operate, and more specifically, how much information a person should be provided before providing consent, in the context of donating SFEs to research. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: An online experimental survey of 225 participants was conducted. The survey assessed the impact of two variables-Information Disclosure and Preference Fulfilment-on participants' views towards whether a consent process allowed for informed, autonomous consent and the moral treatment of donors. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: A nationally representative sample of the UK public was recruited using the online platform Prolific. The survey consisted of a vignette-based experimental design, one free-text question, and demographic data collection. Quantitative data were summarized using descriptive statistics and the relationship between variables was tested using ANOVAs and t-tests, where appropriate. Inductive content analysis through manual coding was performed on the free-text question. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Participants considered both specific and broad information disclosure as sufficient for informed consent (mean Consent Judgements M = 6.49/7 and M = 5.79/7, respectively). The ability to fulfil disposition preferences was critical to the public's assessment of whether a consent process enabled donors to act autonomously and be treated morally. Participants agreed that a potential donor was able to make an autonomous decision if their preference to donate their SFEs to research was fulfilled (mean Autonomy Judgement M = 5.46/7, mean Moral Judgement M = 5.63/7), but not when it was not (mean Autonomy Judgement M = 3.96/7, mean Moral Judgement: M = 4.76/7). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Ecological validity of online surveys is limited, and data may be subject to response biases. Additionally, the sample size was relatively small. Finally, since the sample population was based in the UK, the generalizability of the survey findings to other countries may be limited. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Our findings underscore the need to review and possibly update consent processes for the donation of SFEs to research. We encourage policy discussion in light of our findings, specifically the consideration of a shift towards a broad consent model. Doing so may allow more donors to fulfil their disposition preference, facilitate the movement of SFEs out of storage, and respond to the shortage of eggs currently available for research. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This research was supported by The British Academy (grant number KF8\230096). The survey component of this study was funded by the Uehiro Oxford Institute. M.J. has received research funding from Monash IVF and Ferring Pharmaceuticals. She reports honorarium and travel support from Gideon Richter. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.
引用
- Langford J, Demaree-Cotton J, Johnston M, et al. Public attitudes towards consent for the donation of surplus frozen eggs to research. Hum Reprod. 2026. PMID: 41633831. doi:10.1093/humrep/deag007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。