子宫颈癌筛查异常但阴道镜检查正常者的临床结局
回顾性分析2019年1月1日至12月31日北京大学第一医院妇产科1584例阴道镜正常妇女,TCT低危组1419例、高危组165例,低危组CINⅡ+即刻漏检率1.17%,1年累积漏检率3.00%,正常阴道镜阴性预测值92.83%,建议低危者随访观察。
要点
- TCT低危组CINⅡ+即刻漏检率1.17%(14/1201),1年累积漏检率3.00%(36/1201)。
- TCT高危组CINⅡ+漏检率37.58%(62/165)。
- 正常阴道镜对CINⅡ+阴性预测值92.83%,TCT低危组97.00%,特异度仅74.97%。
核心结论
- TCT低危且正常阴道镜所见者漏诊子宫颈CINⅡ+病变风险极低,尤其是HR-HPV检测阴性的患者,建议随访观察,可减少不必要的子宫颈活检。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性收集2019年1月1日至12月31日在北京大学第一医院妇产科行阴道镜检查者,纳入正常阴道镜所见妇女1584例,中位年龄39.0岁。
- 根据TCT结果分为低危组1419例和高危组165例,低危组包括NILM、ASCUS和LSIL,高危组包括HSIL、ASC-H和AGC。
- 部分行阴道镜下子宫颈活检,未活检者随访1年,计算敏感度、特异度、阳性预测值、阴性预测值及总符合率,分析CINⅡ+漏检率及原因。
主要发现
- TCT高危组均行子宫颈活检,CINⅡ+漏检率为37.58%(62/165)。
- TCT低危组133例行子宫颈活检,即刻漏检CINⅡ+ 14例;未活检1068例完成1年随访,第6个月新增检出CINⅡ+ 16例(CINⅡ 12例,其中局灶CINⅡ 1例、多灶性CINⅡ 11例;CINⅢ 4例),1年时新增检出CINⅡ+ 6例(CINⅡ 4例,其中局灶性CINⅡ 2例、多灶性CINⅡ 2例;CINⅢ 2例)。
- TCT低危组CINⅡ+即刻漏检率为1.17%(14/1201),1年累积漏检率为3.00%(36/1201)。
- 正常阴道镜所见对CINⅡ+的阴性预测值为92.83%,TCT低危组为97.00%,特异度仅为74.97%。
- TCT低危组漏检CINⅡ+的36例均为HR-HPV阳性,其中28例为HPV16/18感染,8例为非HPV16/18的其他HR-HPV阳性;TCT结果NILM 20例、ASCUS 9例、LSIL 7例。
关键数值与推荐
- TCT低危组CINⅡ+即刻漏检率1.17%(14/1201),1年累积漏检率3.00%(36/1201)。
- TCT高危组CINⅡ+漏检率37.58%(62/165)。
- 正常阴道镜所见对CINⅡ+的阴性预测值92.83%,TCT低危组97.00%,特异度74.97%。
- 漏检CINⅡ+独立影响因素:HR-HPV阳性、转化区类型、子宫颈管病变部位(P均<0.05)。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议对TCT低危且正常阴道镜所见者随访观察,可减少不必要的子宫颈活检。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To analyze the clinical outcomes of people with abnormal cervical cancer screening results but normal colposcopic findings, and explore the reasons for missed detection high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia Ⅱ and worse (CINⅡ+). Methods: People who underwent colposcopy at the Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Peking University First Hospital from January 1st, 2019 to December 31st, 2019 were selected. Those with normal colposcopic findings were included, some of them underwent biopsy, others were followed up for one year. Data including thinprep cytologic test (TCT) and high-risk human papillomavirus (HR-HPV)screening results, colposcopic image characteristics, and histopathological outcomes were collected for statistical analysis. Based on cytology results, people with normal colposcopic findings were divided into two groups: the low-risk group [negative for intraepithelial lesion and malignancy (NILM), atypical squamous cell of undetermined signification (ASCUS), and low grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (LSIL)] and the high-risk group [high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (HSIL), atypical squamous cells cannot exclude high-grade lesion (ASC-H), and atypical glandular cells (AGC)]. The detection performance of normal colposcopic findings was evaluated by calculating sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and overall accuracy. Furthermore, based on follow-up results, the missed detection rate of CINⅡ+in these people and the reasons for missed detection were analyzed. Results: A total of 1 584 women with normal colposcopic findings were included in this study; the median age was 39.0 years. Among them, 1 419 cases were in low-risk group, and 165 cases were in high-risk group. (1) All of the women in high-risk group underwent cervical biopsy, the CINⅡ+ missed detection rate was 37.58% (62/165). In contrast, 133 cases in low-risk group underwent cervical biopsy, of which 14 cases were immediate missed detection, while 1 068 cases who did not undergo cervical biopsy completed one year of follow-up, 16 and 6 new cases of CINⅡ+ were detected at 6 months and 1 year, respectively. Among the 16 new detected cases at 6 months, 12 of them were CINⅡ (1 was focal CINⅡ and 11 were multifocal CINⅡ) and 4 of them were CINⅢ. Among the 6 new detected cases at 1 year, 4 of them were CINⅡ (2 were focal CINⅡ and 2 were multifocal CINⅡ) and 2 of them were CINⅢ. (2) The immediate missed detection rate of CINⅡ+ in low-risk group was 1.17% (14/1 201), and the cumulative missed detection rate at one year was 3.00% (36/1 021). Normal colposcopic findings demonstrated a high negative predictive value (92.83%) for identifying CINⅡ+, particularly in low-risk group (97.00%). However, the specificity was only 74.97%. (3) The TCT and HR-HPV results of women with missed detection of colposcopy were analyzed. All of the 36 cases in low-risk group had HR-HPV infection, 28 cases had HPV 16/18 infection, and 8 people had non-16/18 HR-HPV infection. In the low-risk group with missed detection, 20 cases had the TCT result of NILM, 9 had ASCUS and 7 had LSIL. Among the 62 cases in the high-risk group with missed detection of colposcopy, 56 had HR-HPV infection and 6 did not have HR-HPV infection. Among 56 cases who had HR-HPV infection, 26 cases had HPV 16/18 infection, 30 cases had non-16/18 HR-HPV infection. (4) Univariate and multivariate analyses of factors associated with missed detection of CINⅡ+ lesions identified HR-HPV infection, transformation zone type, and the location of endocervical lesion as independent influencing factors (all P<0.05). Conclusions: The risk of missed detection of cervical CINⅡ+ lesions in in low-risk group people is extremely low, particularly in HPV negative people. Follow-up observation is recommended for these people, which could reduce unnecessary cervical biopsies. 目的: 通过对子宫颈液基薄层细胞学(TCT)检查异常[≥未明确诊断意义的不典型鳞状上皮细胞(ASCUS)]或高危型人乳头状瘤病毒(HR-HPV)筛查异常但正常阴道镜所见妇女的临床结局分析,探讨正常阴道镜所见妇女的宫颈癌筛查情况、阴道镜诊断效能及随访安全性,并分析正常阴道镜所见妇女中子宫颈高级别上皮内瘤变(CIN)Ⅱ级及以上级别病变的漏检原因,为临床提供指导。 方法: 回顾性收集2019年1月1日至12月31日在北京大学第一医院妇产科行阴道镜检查者,部分阴道镜检查者行阴道镜下子宫颈活检组织病理学检查,对其中正常阴道镜所见且未行活检者进行1年随访,收集TCT、HR-HPV、阴道镜检查结果及子宫颈活检组织病理学结果等进行统计分析,并根据TCT结果将正常阴道镜所见妇女分为两组:TCT低危组与TCT高危组。TCT低危组包括TCT结果为未见上皮内病变或恶性病变(NILM)、ASCUS以及低级别鳞状上皮内病变。TCT高危组包括高级别鳞状上皮内病变、不除外高度病变的不典型鳞状上皮细胞以及非典型腺细胞。通过计算敏感度、特异度、阳性预测值、阴性预测值以及总符合率评估正常阴道镜所见的检查效能,并根据随访结果进一步分析了正常阴道镜所见的入组者CINⅡ+的漏检率以及漏检原因。 结果: 共1 584例正常阴道镜所见妇女纳入本研究,中位年龄为39.0岁,其中TCT低危组1 419例,TCT高危组165例。(1)TCT高危组均行子宫颈活检,CINⅡ+ 漏检率为37.58%(62/165);而TCT低危组133例行子宫颈活检,根据活检组织病理学结果判定即刻漏检CINⅡ+ 14例,未活检者1 068例完成了1年随访,在随访的第6个月,TCT低危组新增检出CINⅡ+ 妇女16例,其中CINⅡ 12例(局灶CINⅡ 1例、多灶性CINⅡ 11例)、CINⅢ 4例。在随访1年时,新增检出CINⅡ+ 妇女6例,其中CINⅡ 4例(局灶性CINⅡ 2例,多灶性CINⅡ 2例)、CINⅢ 2例。(2)TCT低危组CINⅡ+ 即刻漏检率为1.17%(14/1 201),1年累积漏检率为3.00%(36/1 201)。正常阴道镜所见对CINⅡ+ 的识别表现出较高的阴性预测值(92.83%),其中TCT低危组的阴性预测值为97.00%,但特异度仅为74.97%。(3)对正常阴道镜所见者TCT、HR-HPV检测结果和子宫颈病变级别分析发现,TCT低危组漏检CINⅡ+ 病变的36例妇女均为HR-HPV阳性,其中28例为HPV16/18感染,8例为非HPV16/18的其他HR-HPV阳性;TCT检查结果为NILM者20例,TCT为ASCUS和低级别鳞状上皮内病变分别为9例和7例。TCT高危组漏检CINⅡ+ 病变62例;56例为HR-HPV阳性,6例为HR-HPV阴性。56例HR-HPV阳性受检者中26例为HPV16/18感染,30例为非HPV16/18的其他HR-HPV阳性。(4)对漏检CINⅡ+ 病变相关的单因素和多因素分析发现,HR-HPV阳性、转化区类型、子宫颈管病变部位是阴道镜漏检的独立影响因素(P均<0.05)。 结论: TCT低危且正常阴道镜所见者漏诊子宫颈CINⅡ+病变风险极低,尤其是HR-HPV检测阴性的患者,建议随访观察,可减少不必要的子宫颈活检。.
引用
- Zhang J, Zhao J, Cui RR, et al. [Clinical outcomes of people with abnormal cervical cancer screening results but normal colposcopy findings]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2025. PMID: 41456897. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20250423-00166
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。