临床医生对开展产科种族差异相关对话的看法
本研究采用定性方法,于2023年8月至2024年3月在一个学术医疗系统的两家医院中目的性抽样招募14名围产期临床医生,通过半结构化访谈探讨其与患者讨论孕产妇健康种族差异的经验与障碍;临床医生普遍认识到种族主义对美国孕产妇结局的影响,相关对话多在黑人患者表达恐惧或推荐阿司匹林预防子痫前期时发生,障碍包括担心患者反应、时间限制和缺乏明确可操作的回应。
要点
- 临床医生普遍认识到种族主义对美国孕产妇结局的影响。
- 种族差异对话最常发生于黑人患者表达对死亡或偏倚的恐惧时,或推荐阿司匹林预防子痫前期时。
- 黑人临床医生对这些讨论更自在,归因于亲身经历与实践。
核心结论
- 围产期临床医生需要培养建设性讨论种族的能力,实践以关系为中心的照护,并促进黑人患者的心理安全。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,于2023年8月至2024年3月在一个学术医疗系统的两家医院中目的性抽样招募围产期临床医生14名,按自认种族或族裔及角色抽样至主题饱和。
- 采用健康公平实施框架进行半结构化访谈,由两名编码者以内容分析法编码,编码者间信度高(κ>0.8)。
主要发现
- 临床医生普遍认识到种族、特别是种族主义对美国孕产妇结局的影响。
- 关于种族差异的对话最常出现于:黑人患者表达对死亡的恐惧或对诊疗中偏倚的担忧时,或推荐阿司匹林以降低子痫前期风险时。
- 黑人临床医生对这些讨论更自在,归因于亲身经历和实践。
- 多数临床医生认同与患者讨论种族差异重要,但指出障碍包括担心患者反应(尤其种族不一致时)、时间限制和缺乏明确可操作的回应。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,随着对种族差异的认识增长,围产期临床医生必须培养建设性讨论种族的能力,实践以关系为中心的照护,并促进黑人患者的心理安全。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Discussions around racial disparities in obstetrics occur in varied silos including the media, communities, and medical institutions. Yet, whether and how these discussions occur in the context of the patient-clinician relationship is unknown. We sought to explore clinician perspectives on conversations with patients regarding racial disparities in maternal health using a qualitative approach. METHODS: We enrolled perinatal clinicians (N=14) across two hospitals within one academic health system from August 2023 to March 2024, purposively sampled by self-identified race or ethnicity and role until thematic saturation was achieved. Semistructured interviews using the Health Equity Implementation Framework evaluated prior experience with and optimization of disparities counseling, focusing on patient-clinician race concordance, comfort levels, barriers, ideal circumstances, and recommended content for conversations about racial disparities in maternal health. Interviews were coded with a content analysis approach by two coders with high interrater reliability (κ>0.8). RESULTS: Clinicians universally recognized the effect of race, specifically racism, on U.S. maternal outcomes. Conversations about racial disparities most frequently arose 1) when Black patients voiced fears of dying or concerns about bias in their care or 2) in the context of recommending aspirin for preeclampsia risk reduction. Black clinicians felt more comfortable with these discussions, attributed to lived experience and practice. Although most clinicians agreed that conversations with patients about racial disparities are important, they identified barriers such as fear of patient reactions (particularly with discordant race), time constraints, and unclear actionable response. CONCLUSION: Our findings, along with ongoing work on the patient perspective, highlight the need for respectful, informed conversations centering patient experiences. As awareness of racial disparities grows, perinatal clinicians must develop capabilities for discussing race constructively, practicing relationship-centered care, and promoting psychologic safety for Black patients.
引用
- Wang-Koehler E, Oshewa O, Srinivas SK, et al. Clinician Perspectives on Navigating Conversations Around Racial Disparities in Obstetrics. Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 41037816. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000006085
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。