文献速递生殖医学

确定卵子捐赠者有效知情同意所需的基本信息:一项国际德尔菲研究

Identifying essential information for a valid informed consent of egg donors: an international Delphi study.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2025-01-01

该改良德尔菲研究通过三轮调查,邀请来自14个国家的35名经验丰富的卵子捐赠者和多学科专业人士,对13个类别共133条具体信息条目(CII)在相关性和道德必要性上进行共识评分。共识标准为条目内容效度指数(I-CVI)≥0.78。结果显示,80%的CII被认为具有相关性,67%被认为具有道德必要性;所有法律方面的条目均被认为相关。

要点

  • 参与者认为80%的具体信息条目具有相关性,67%具有道德必要性。
  • 所有法律方面的信息条目均被认为具有相关性。
  • 卵子捐赠者需了解卵巢刺激和取卵程序、对捐赠卵子的法律权利及撤回同意的法律权利。

核心结论

  • 参与者认为80%的具体信息条目具有相关性(例如所有法律方面),67%具有道德必要性。

研究设计与样本

  • 改良德尔菲研究,采用三轮迭代调查达成共识,邀请于2023年11月发出,最后一轮于2024年11月结束。
  • 35名参与者为来自14个国家的经验丰富的卵子捐赠者和多学科专业人士(社会科学与医学科学、生物伦理学、心理学、生育医学和法律)。
  • 调查包含13个类别和133条具体信息条目(CII),参与者通过4点李克特量表评分相关性,并通过二分法(是/否)评分道德必要性。

主要发现

  • 共识标准为条目内容效度指数(I-CVI)≥0.78,道德必要性共识也采用相同阈值。
  • 133条CII中有27条的I-CVI低于0.78;44条CII的道德必要性百分比低于0.78。
  • 4条CII的I-CVI达到1:所有专家认为候选捐赠者需要了解(i)需要进行卵巢刺激和(ii)取卵程序,以及(iii)取卵程序后对捐赠卵子的法律权利和(iv)撤回同意的法律权利。
  • 撤回同意的法律权利是唯一在道德必要性上获得100%评分的CII。
  • I-CVI最低的CII为「捐赠卵子潜在接受者的家庭类型和特征」(0.32);道德必要性同意百分比最低的CII为「卵子捐赠者的社交圈可能对捐赠给出负面反馈/意见」(36.36%)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共识定义为I-CVI≥0.78,道德必要性共识也采用相同阈值。
  • 133条CII中27条I-CVI低于0.78,44条道德必要性百分比低于0.78。
  • 4条CII的I-CVI为1:需进行卵巢刺激、取卵程序、取卵后对捐赠卵子的法律权利、撤回同意的法律权利。
  • 撤回同意的法律权利是唯一道德必要性评分为100%的CII。
  • I-CVI最低的CII为「捐赠卵子潜在接受者的家庭类型和特征」(0.32);道德必要性同意百分比最低的CII为「卵子捐赠者的社交圈可能对捐赠给出负面反馈/意见」(36.36%)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,结果为生育专业人员提供了基本信息的标准,以确保 prospective egg donors 在决定捐赠时获得充分信息并了解预期情况。
  • 作者认为,结果为研究人员提供了评估生育诊所信息提供质量的潜在标准。

局限性

  • 尽管努力,未能获得注册护士和助产士的输入。
  • 并非所有参与者都参与了所有迭代轮次,这可能削弱研究结果;但轮次间流失率在可接受的20-30%范围内。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: What information does an international group of professionals and egg donors consider relevant and morally necessary for prospective egg donors to provide valid informed consent? SUMMARY ANSWER: Participants considered 80% of all concrete information items (CIIs) to be relevant (e.g. all legal aspects) and 67% to be morally necessary. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Studies indicate that egg donors are not always adequately informed and have expressed a desire for more comprehensive information. This highlights the need for a comprehensive guideline of essential information for prospective egg donors. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This modified Delphi study used a survey in an iterative process of three rounds to reach a consensus on what information items are relevant and morally necessary for a valid informed consent of candidate egg donors. Invitations to participate were sent out in November 2023 and the final round closed in November 2024. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: The 35 participants were experienced egg donors and professionals from a range of disciplines (social and medical sciences, bioethics, psychology, fertility medicine and law) from 14 countries. The survey consisted of 13 categories and 133 CIIs, which participants scored for relevance via a 4-point Likert scale and moral necessity on a dichotomous scale (yes/no). Content Validity Index (CVI) was calculated for measuring relevance and percentage of agreement for moral necessity. A comment section was available. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Consensus was indicated as an I-CVI (CVI per item) of 0.78 or higher. The same cut-off was used to indicate consensus for moral necessity. For 27 out of 133 CIIs, the I-CVI was lower than 0.78. The percentage of moral necessity was below 0.78 for 44 CIIs. Four CIIs reached a I-CVI of 1: all experts thought it was relevant for a candidate donor to know (i) the need to undergo ovarian stimulation and (ii) a retrieval procedure, as well as (iii) her legal rights over the donated eggs after the retrieval procedure and (iv) her legal right to withdraw consent. The latter is the only CII that scored 100% on moral necessity. The CII with the lowest I-CVI is 'The family type and characteristics of the potential recipients of the donor eggs' (0.32). The CII with the lowest percentage of agreement for moral necessity was 'An egg donor's social circle might give negative feedback/opinions on the donation' (36.36%). In several categories (e.g. 'Physical side-effects and risks'), almost all CIIs reached a consensus among experienced egg donors, bioethicists, and humanities and social sciences experts, while hardly any CII reached a consensus among fertility experts, lawyers, and academic medical doctors. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Despite our efforts, we were unable to obtain input from registered nurses and midwives. Not all participants remained engaged through all the iterative rounds, which may weaken the results of the study. However, the dropout rates between rounds in this study were within the acceptable 20-30% range. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Our results give fertility professionals a standard of essential information to make sure that prospective egg donors are adequately informed and know what to expect when they decide to donate. It also gives researchers a potential standard to evaluate the quality of the information provision in fertility clinics. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This study is funded by the Special Research Fund, Bijzonder Onderzoeksfonds of Ghent University (BOFSTG2020000901). The authors declare that they have no competing interests. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jacxsens L, Pennings G, Lentacker L, et al. Identifying essential information for a valid informed consent of egg donors: an international Delphi study. Hum Reprod. 2025. PMID: 40912272. doi:10.1093/humrep/deaf176

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。