人工智能引导的反馈能否提高胚胎学家仅凭形态学选择整倍体胚胎的能力?
研究开发训练工具,让19名胚胎学家(初级、中级和资深)评估胚胎图像倍性,随后提供ERICA对同一胚胎的排名并要求综合两者做最终判断,每人完成20至150个模拟IVF周期。胚胎学家和ERICA识别非整倍体的能力均优于随机选择(均P < 0.001),ERICA首次尝试选择整倍体胚胎优于胚胎学家(P = 0.002),但胚胎学家分组间无显著差异,参考ERICA后改变判断也未带来显著改善或恶化。
要点
- 胚胎学家和ERICA识别非整倍体的能力均显著优于随机选择(均P < 0.001)。
- ERICA首次尝试选择整倍体胚胎优于胚胎学家(P = 0.002)。
- 结合人工与AI判断并不总是优于单独使用任一方法。
核心结论
- ERICA等AI工具可通过减少主观性和偏倚提高胚胎选择的可靠性,但人工与AI判断的结合并不总是优于单独使用任一方法。
- 研究强调需更好理解AI对IVF环境中人类决策及对自动化过程信任的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 开发训练工具,19名胚胎学家(含初级、中级和资深从业者)评估胚胎图像倍性状态。
- 随后提供ERICA对同一胚胎的排名,要求胚胎学家结合两者信息做最终判断。
- 每名胚胎学家完成20至150个模拟IVF周期以评估识别整倍体胚胎的表现。
主要发现
- 胚胎学家和ERICA识别非整倍体的能力均显著优于随机选择(均P < 0.001)。
- ERICA首次尝试选择整倍体胚胎优于胚胎学家(P = 0.002)。
- 胚胎学家各组间在选择更好或更差胚胎方面无显著差异。
- 参考ERICA输出后,尽管大量胚胎学家改变判断,但改变未带来显著改善或恶化。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: Can embryologists reliably differentiate euploid from aneuploid embryos based on morphology alone, and can artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted selection, specifically using ERICA (Embryo Ranking Intelligent Classification Algorithm), improve embryo selection outcomes compared with embryologists alone? DESIGN: A training tool was developed and used in which 19 embryologists (comprising junior, intermediate and experienced practitioners) evaluated the ploidy status of embryo images. They were subsequently provided with rankings generated by ERICA for the same embryos and asked to make a final judgment combining both sources of information. Each embryologist conducted this process on between 20 to 150 simulated IVF cycles to assess performance in identifying euploid embryos. RESULTS: Both embryologists and ERICA demonstrated a statistically significant ability to identify aneuploidy better than random selection (both P < 0.001). ERICA outperformed embryologists in selecting euploid embryos on the first attempt (P = 0.002). No significant difference was observed between groups of embryologists in picking a better or worse embryo and, given the opportunity to change their mind in the light of the ERICA output, there was no significant change for the better or worse, despite a large number changing their minds. CONCLUSION: The study highlights that AI tools like ERICA can enhance the reliability of embryo selection by reducing subjectivity and bias; however, the combination of human and AI judgment does not always provide a clear advantage over using either method independently. These findings emphasize the need to better understand the influence of AI on human decision-making and the trust placed in automated processes in IVF settings.
引用
- Palmer GA, Chavez-Badiola A, Valencia-Murillo R, et al. Can artificial intelligence guided feedback improve embryologists' selection of euploid embryos based on morphology alone? Reprod Biomed Online. 2025. PMID: 40834664. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2025.104990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。