果蝇与人类精子发生的比较——雄性配子产生的保守过程
本综述比较了哺乳动物与果蝇在精子发生中的保守机制,重点关注人类。通过PubMed检索相关文献,发现早期生殖细胞分裂及每个精原干细胞产生单倍体生殖细胞的比例在人类与果蝇间高度保守,减数分裂中等保守(果蝇无交叉互换),精子尾部附属结构保守性差。作者提出果蝇应主要用于预筛选和选择强候选基因,再在哺乳动物中验证。
要点
- 人类与果蝇在早期生殖细胞分裂和单倍体生殖细胞产出比例上高度保守。
- 减数分裂中等保守,但果蝇缺乏交叉互换。
- 精子尾部附属结构保守性差,果蝇不适合作为研究人类该结构的模型。
核心结论
- 果蝇是研究包括男性不育在内的遗传性人类疾病的有用模型生物,但应主要用于预筛选和选择强候选基因,再在哺乳动物物种中进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 本综述通过PubMed检索相关文献,关键词涉及人类、哺乳动物和果蝇精子发生及雄性生育力,未设时间或物种限制。
主要发现
- 人类与果蝇间高度保守的关键阶段包括早期生殖细胞分裂和每个精原干细胞产生的单倍体生殖细胞比例。
- 减数分裂在哺乳动物与果蝇间中等保守,但果蝇显著缺乏交叉互换。
- 精子尾部附属结构在物种间分化,果蝇不太可能作为研究人类或哺乳动物该结构的合适模型。
- 人类和果蝇均有一对睾丸,主要功能是产生精子;果蝇睾丸中形成囊包使生殖细胞持续增殖并保持同步成熟。
- 哺乳动物精子在附睾中储存并经历睾丸后修饰,而果蝇精子储存在精囊中,在该附睾样结构中未见明显的睾丸后修饰。
临床怎么用
- 作者提出果蝇应主要用于预筛选和选择强候选基因,以便在哺乳动物物种中进一步研究人类生育力的转化路径。
- 作者指出突变体无表型并不能确定该基因对人类生育力是非必需的。
局限性
- 雄性生育力及精子发生受显著进化压力,所有物种间其过程存在一定程度变异。
- 突变体无表型不能确定该基因对人类生育力是非必需的。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Spermatogenesis is a dynamic process that involves the co-ordinated development of millions of cells, from stem cells to highly polarized sperm capable of motility and fertility. It is, therefore, not surprising that many thousand genes are required for male fertility. Mutant mouse models are routinely employed to test the function of these genes as well as to validate genetic variants that may be causing human male infertility. The use of mice and other animal models has led to significant knowledge gain regarding the genetic regulation of mammalian male fertility. However, due to the sheer number of genes and genetic variants to be tested these approaches are expensive and time-consuming. We and others have investigated the use of alternate model organisms to expedite validation approaches, including the utility of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: This review explores the conserved mechanisms of sperm production between mammals and flies, with a focus on the human setting where possible. SEARCH METHODS: Studies were identified via PubMed using searches including keywords related to the focus of this review, including human, mammalian, and fly or Drosophila spermatogenesis and male fertility. Follow-up searches including using search terms for specific structures and processes for comparison between species included, but were not limited to, male reproductive tract, spermatogenesis, spermatogonia and stem cell niche, meiosis, spermiogenesis and its sub-processes, and sperm/spermatozoa. No time frame or species restrictions were placed on searches. OUTCOMES: We identify key phases of spermatogenesis that are highly conserved between humans and flies, including the early germ cell divisions and the ratio of haploid germ cells generated for each spermatogonial stem cell, allowing their use as a model organism to explore such processes. Some processes are moderately well conserved between mammals and flies, including meiosis with the notable absence of 'crossing over' in flies. We also identify some processes that are poorly conserved, such as a divergence in sperm tail accessory structures, for which flies are not likely a suitable model organism to decipher human biology or for mammals broadly. Examples of where the fly has been or could be useful to study mammalian gene function in male fertility have also been described. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: Drosophila melanogaster is undoubtedly a useful model organism for studying a wide range of human diseases with genetic origins, including male infertility. Both humans and flies possess a pair of testes with the primary role of generating sperm. The formation of cysts in Drosophila testes allows germ cells to constantly proliferate and stay synchronized at the respective maturation phase, as is the case for humans. While both organisms use a method of sperm storage, mammalian sperm undergo post-testicular modifications and are stored in the epididymis. In Drosophila, sperm are stored in the seminal vesicle, and do not appear to undergo any overt post-testicular modifications in this epididymis-like structure. The seminal vesicle is a separate organ in mammals that is responsible for generation of the seminal fluid. It is important to note that male fertility and thus spermatogenesis are subject to significant evolutionary pressure, and there is a degree of variation in its processes between all species. As such, the absence of a phenotype in mutants would not determine that the gene is dispensable for fertility in humans. While flies are useful for genetic studies to confirm human disease causality, we propose they should be used primarily to pre-screen and select strong candidates for further interrogation in mammalian species for translational pathways in the context of human fertility. REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.
引用
- Houston BJ, Cauchi LM, Dunleavy JEM, et al. A comparison of spermatogenesis between flies and men-conserved processes of male gamete production. Hum Reprod Update. 2025. PMID: 40802929. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmaf018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。