经腹与经阴道宫颈环扎术对宫颈功能不全患者早产及新生儿结局的影响
在美国一家四级医疗中心开展的队列研究纳入188例有宫颈功能不全史的成人单胎妊娠,比较经腹宫颈环扎术(87例,99%为腹腔镜)与经阴道宫颈环扎术(101例)对34周前早产的影响。调整混杂后,经腹组34周前早产调整风险为5.5%,经阴道组为18.7%,风险差为-13.1%(95%CI,-26.6%,-0.5%),风险比为0.30(95%CI,0.10,0.94)。
要点
- 经腹宫颈环扎术组34周前早产调整风险为5.5%,经阴道环扎术组为18.7%,风险比为0.30。
- 在无经阴道环扎失败史的患者中,风险差为-12.6%(95%CI,-21.6%,-4.1%)。
- 两组置环及分娩并发症风险相当,但经腹组出现少数严重子宫并发症。
核心结论
- 在有至少1次28周前早产或34周前经阴道环扎失败史的女性中,与经阴道宫颈环扎术相比,经腹宫颈环扎术降低了34周前早产风险,与Multicentre Abdominal vs Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage试验的发现一致。
- 关于无经阴道环扎失败史患者疗效的结论受小样本量限制。
- 需要进一步研究以了解经腹宫颈环扎术在患者亚组中的获益是否超过腹部手术和剖宫产的风险。
研究设计与样本
- 在美国一家四级医疗中心识别接受病史指征宫颈环扎术的成人单胎妊娠队列。
- 队列由有至少1次28周前自然分娩(出生或胎死)史的患者和有经阴道环扎失败史的患者组成,后者定义为至少1次34周前自然早产且宫颈环扎在位。
- 所有符合条件的接受经腹宫颈环扎术的患者与符合条件的接受经阴道宫颈环扎术的样本进行比较。
- 采用逆概率加权生存分析调整潜在偏倚来源,效应估计为风险差、风险比和95%置信区间。
- 在无经阴道环扎失败史的患者中进行亚组分析。
主要发现
- 共纳入188例患者,其中87例接受经腹宫颈环扎术(99%为腹腔镜),101例接受经阴道宫颈环扎术。
- 经腹宫颈环扎术组26例(30%)无经阴道环扎失败史,其中多数有额外临床原因而提供经腹宫颈环扎术。
- 调整混杂后,经腹组34周前早产调整风险为5.5%(95%CI,2.0%,9.4%),经阴道组为18.7%(95%CI,6.8%,31.4%),风险差为-13.1%(95%CI,-26.6%,-0.5%),风险比为0.30(95%CI,0.10,0.94)。
- 在无经阴道环扎失败史的患者中(共104例,经腹组26例),风险差为-12.6%(95%CI,-21.6%,-4.1%)。
- 两组置环和分娩并发症风险相当,但经腹宫颈环扎术组包括少数严重子宫并发症;新生儿重症监护病房入住率在经腹组和经阴道组分别为35%和23%。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 关于无经阴道环扎失败史患者疗效的结论受小样本量限制。
- 需要进一步研究以了解经腹宫颈环扎术在患者亚组中的获益是否超过腹部手术和剖宫产的风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The 2020 Multicentre Abdominal vs Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage trial found that transabdominal cerclage placed via open laparotomy reduces the risk of spontaneous preterm birth before 32 weeks relative to transvaginal cerclage in a very high-risk obstetric population. It is not known whether the results of the trial generalize to obstetric populations with fewer risk factors, on average, for recurrent spontaneous preterm birth, or to patients without history of failed transvaginal cerclage (an inclusion criterium in the trial). OBJECTIVE: 1) To estimate the effect of transabdominal cerclage vs transvaginal cerclage on early preterm delivery (<34 weeks) among patients with history of cervical insufficiency at a quaternary care center; 2) to estimate the effect within a subgroup of patients without history of failed transvaginal cerclage; and 3) to describe associated complications of placement and delivery and neonatal outcomes. STUDY DESIGN: We identified a cohort of adult singleton pregnancies who received history-indicated cerclage at a quaternary care center in the United States. The cohort consisted of patients with a history of ≥1 spontaneous deliveries (birth or fetal loss) <28 weeks and patients with a history of failed transvaginal cerclage, defined as ≥1 spontaneous preterm deliveries <34 weeks with cervical cerclage in situ. All eligible patients who received transabdominal cerclage were compared to a sample of eligible patients who received transvaginal cerclage. We performed survival analysis with inverse probability weights to adjust for potential sources of bias. Effects were estimated as risk difference, risk ratio, and 95% confidence intervals. Subgroup analyses were performed among patients without a history of failed transvaginal cerclage. The risks of surgical, delivery, and neonatal outcomes were described. RESULTS: One hundred eighty-eight patients were included, of whom 87 received transabdominal cerclage (99% laparoscopic) and 101 received transvaginal cerclage. Twenty-six patients (30%) with transabdominal cerclage had no history of failed transvaginal cerclage, the majority of whom had additional clinical reasons why transabdominal cerclage was offered. After adjusting for confounding, the adjusted risk of early preterm delivery was 5.5% in the transabdominal group (95% confidence interval, 2.0%, 9.4%) and 18.7% in the transvaginal group (95% confidence interval, 6.8%, 31.4%), risk difference = -13.1% (95% confidence interval, -26.6%, -0.5%), and risk ratio = 0.30 (95% confidence interval, 0.10, 0.94). Among patients without history of failed transvaginal cerclage (N = 104 total, N = 26 in transabdominal group), the risk difference was -12.6% (-21.6%, -4.1%). Risks of placement and delivery complications were comparable across groups but included a few serious uterine complications in the transabdominal cerclage group. Neonatal intensive care unit admission occurred in 35% and 23% of neonates in the transabdominal and transvaginal groups, respectively. CONCLUSION: Among women with history of ≥1 preterm deliveries <28 weeks or failed transvaginal cerclage <34 weeks, transabdominal cerclage reduced the risk of preterm delivery <34 weeks compared to transvaginal cerclage, consistent with the Multicentre Abdominal vs Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage trial findings. Conclusions about efficacy among patients without history of failed transvaginal cerclage are limited by small sample size. Further research is necessary to understand whether the benefits of transabdominal cerclage in subgroups of patients outweigh risks of abdominal surgery and cesarean delivery.
引用
- Messinger CJ, Hernández-Díaz S, Hofman A, et al. Effect of transabdominal versus transvaginal cerclage on preterm birth and neonatal outcomes among patients with a history of cervical insufficiency. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 40645472. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2025.06.049
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。