死产照护核心结局集:一项国际共识研究
该国际共识研究采用改良德尔菲法和共识会议,汇集29个国家542名参与者,最终确定8项适用于所有死产照护研究的核心结局,并针对病因调查、再次妊娠、多胎妊娠死产等特定情境补充11项结局,旨在减少结局报告偏倚并提高Meta分析可比性。
要点
- 所有死产照护研究应测量8项核心结局,涵盖孕产妇严重并发症与死亡、尊重支持性照护体验、悲伤、心理健康与情绪福祉、孤立感、污名、对工作的影响及对直系亲属关系的影响。
- 评估死产病因调查干预的研究应报告死因是否明确及父母对死因的理解。
- 死产后再次妊娠研究应报告母亲孕期并发症、胎儿孕期并发症、胎儿存活、新生儿结局及与胎儿的依恋。
核心结论
- 该死产照护核心结局集可用于未来试验和系统评价,以减少结局报告偏倚、使Meta分析中干预措施具有可比性,并最终减少研究浪费。
研究设计与样本
- 共识制定研究,采用改良德尔菲法和共识会议,纳入来自29个国家的542名参与者,包括381名经历过死产的父母或家庭成员、192名照护专业人员与研究人员(其中31人同时为父母和专业人员)。
- 95.6%的父母和86.5%的专业利益相关者来自高收入国家。
主要发现
- 利益相关者就所有死产照护研究中应测量的8项核心结局达成一致,并额外确定11项用于特定干预或照护的结局。
- 所有死产照护研究的核心结局为:危及生命的并发症和孕产妇死亡、父母获得尊重和支持性照护的体验、悲伤、心理健康和情绪福祉、孤立感、污名、对工作的影响、对直系亲属关系的影响。
- 评估了解死产原因干预(调查)的研究结局为:死因明确和父母对死因的理解。
- 评估死产后再次妊娠的研究结局为:母亲孕期并发症、胎儿孕期并发症、胎儿存活、新生儿结局和与胎儿的依恋。
- 多胎妊娠中发生死产时的结局为:其他胎儿存活、早产、胎儿孕期并发症和新生儿结局。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To develop a core outcome set for stillbirth care. DESIGN: Consensus development study. SETTING: International. POPULATION: 542 participants from 29 countries, including 381 parents or family members who have experienced stillbirth, 192 care professionals and researchers (31 of which identified as both parent and professional). 95.6% of parents and 86.5% of professional stakeholders were from in high-income countries. METHODS: Modified Delphi method and consensus meetings. RESULTS: Stakeholders agreed upon 8 core outcomes to measure in all stillbirth care studies; an additional 11 outcomes for specific interventions or care were also decided. Core outcomes for all stillbirth care studies were life-threatening complications and maternal death, parents' experience of respectful and supportive care, grief, mental health and emotional wellbeing, isolation, stigma, impact on work, impact on relationship with immediate family. Outcomes for studies assessing interventions to understand the cause of stillbirth (investigations): cause of death identified and parents' understanding of the cause of death. Outcomes in studies assessing subsequent pregnancy after stillbirth: antenatal complications for mother, antenatal complications for baby, survival of baby, neonatal outcomes and attachment to baby. Outcomes for when a stillbirth occurs in a multiple pregnancy: survival of other baby/ies, preterm birth, pregnancy complications for baby/ies and neonatal outcomes. CONCLUSION: This core outcome set for stillbirth care can be used in future trials and systematic reviews to minimise outcome-reporting bias, allow comparability of interventions in meta-analyses and ultimately reduce research wastage.
引用
- Bakhbakhi D, Davies A, Siassakos D, et al. A Core Outcome Set for Stillbirth Care: An International Consensus Study. BJOG. 2025. PMID: 40620109. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.18265
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。