辅助生殖技术中人工见证的专家建议:意大利视角
基于意大利胚胎学、生殖与研究学会(SIERR)六位专家访谈设计匿名调查,于2023年10月23日至11月14日在线发放给491名成员,262人完成(应答率53.4%)。结果显示88.9%偏好口头确认,82.8%认为见证者须为受训医护人员,建议结构化流程、标准化文档和按操作轮班。
要点
- 88.9%受访者认为口头确认(朗读)是最有效的人工见证策略。
- 82.8%受访者同意见证者必须是受过操作培训的医护人员。
- 53.8%受访者偏好按操作轮班以避免因轮班过多导致注意力下降。
核心结论
- 有效的人工见证包括强调口头确认、标准化文档和监测高风险阶段的结构化流程,见证任务需受训医护人员,按操作轮班可增强注意力并减少疲劳。
研究设计与样本
- 基于意大利胚胎学、生殖与研究学会(SIERR)科学委员会六位专家访谈设计匿名调查,含22个问题(李克特量表、封闭式和排序题),于2023年10月23日至11月14日在线发放给491名SIERR成员。
主要发现
- 共262人完成调查(应答率53.4%),71%的参与者有超过5年辅助生殖技术实验室经验并在中等至高等工作量中心工作。
- 88.9%的受访者偏好口头确认(朗读)作为最有效的见证策略。
- 76.7%的受访者强调在流程所有关键阶段参考文档以支持准确核查,63.4%强调所有步骤均关键并优先高风险阶段。
- 53.8%的受访者偏好按操作轮班见证,以避免因轮班过多导致注意力下降。
- 混乱环境、见证时注意力不集中和人员短缺被确定为重要错误来源,82.8%的受访者同意见证者必须是受过操作培训的医护人员。
关键数值与推荐
- 88.9%的受访者偏好口头确认(朗读)作为最有效的见证策略。
- 76.7%的受访者强调在流程所有关键阶段参考文档以支持准确核查。
- 63.4%的受访者强调所有步骤均关键并优先高风险阶段。
- 53.8%的受访者偏好按操作轮班见证。
- 82.8%的受访者同意见证者必须是受过操作培训的医护人员。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为有效的人工见证应涉及强调口头确认、标准化文档和监测高风险阶段的结构化流程。
- 作者认为见证任务需要受训的医护人员,按操作轮班组织可增强注意力并减少疲劳。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What are the most effective strategies for human witnessing in assisted reproductive technology (ART) laboratories? DESIGN: An anonymous survey was conducted to investigate current human witnessing practices in ART laboratories. The survey was developed based on interviews with six experts from the Scientific Committee of the Italian Society of Embryology, Reproduction and Research (SIERR), selected for their diverse backgrounds. The survey included 22 questions (Likert-scale, closed-ended and ranking) and was disseminated online to 491 SIERR members between 23 October and 14 November 2023. RESULTS: A total of 262 respondents completed the survey (53.4% response rate). Most participants (71%) had over 5 years of experience in ART laboratories and worked in medium- to high-volume centres. Key findings revealed that 88.9% preferred verbal confirmation (reading aloud) as the most effective witnessing strategy. Additionally, 76.7% emphasized the necessity of referring to documentation at all critical stages of the process to support accurate verification, while 63.4% emphasized all steps as critical, prioritizing high-risk phases. A preference for per-procedure witnessing shifts (53.8%) was noted to avoid decreased attentiveness due to excessive shifts. Chaotic environments, lack of attention during witnessing and staff shortages were identified as significant sources of error. Importantly, 82.8% agreed that witnesses must be healthcare professionals trained in the procedures. CONCLUSIONS: Effective human witnessing in ART laboratories involves structured protocols emphasizing verbal confirmation, standardized documentation and monitoring of high-risk phases. Witnessing tasks require trained healthcare professionals, and per-procedure shift organization enhances attentiveness and reduces fatigue. These findings provide a framework for optimizing human witnessing practices, supporting procedural accuracy and maintaining high patient safety standards in ART laboratories.
引用
- Alteri A, Borghi L, Fava S, et al. Expert-based recommendations for human witnessing in assisted reproductive technology: an Italian perspective. Reprod Biomed Online. 2025. PMID: 40617159. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2025.104981
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。