「我帮助创造了一个孩子,但我不是它的母亲」:西班牙匿名卵子捐赠者对与捐赠所生子女接触的态度
本研究于2016至2019年在西班牙开展民族志研究,访谈了38名卵子捐赠者。结果识别出三个群体:26.3%在任何情况下都不接受接触且若匿名取消则不会捐赠;26.3%希望接触且即使匿名取消也会捐赠;47.4%无接触意愿但若子女或其家庭主动提出则同意。结论认为取消匿名可能不会显著减少卵子捐赠数量。
要点
- 38名西班牙卵子捐赠者中,26.3%在任何情况下不接受与捐赠所生子女接触,且若匿名取消则不会捐赠。
- 26.3%的捐赠者希望、有兴趣或喜欢此类接触,且即使匿名取消也会捐赠。
- 47.4%的捐赠者无接触意愿,但若子女或其家庭主动提出则同意接触。
核心结论
- 西班牙卵子捐赠者在亲属关系上介于两种解释框架之间:一种优先 genetics,另一种优先经验与社会因素。
- 结果提示取消匿名可能不会导致卵子捐赠数量显著减少。
研究设计与样本
- 民族志研究,于2016年至2019年间开展,访谈了来自西班牙不同地区的38名卵子捐赠者。
主要发现
- 识别出三个群体:26.3%的捐赠者在任何情况下不接受与来自其遗传物质的子女接触,且若匿名取消则不会捐赠。
- 26.3%的捐赠者表达了对此类接触的愿望、兴趣或喜爱,且即使匿名取消也会捐赠。
- 47.4%的捐赠者对此类接触没有愿望或兴趣,但若子女本人和/或其家庭主动提出则同意。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What are the attitudes of anonymous egg donors in Spain towards potential contact with children conceived from their genetic material, should Spanish legislation change to permit this? DESIGN: Ethnographic research was carried out between 2016 and 2019, and included interviews with 38 egg donors from different parts of Spain. RESULTS: THREE DISTINCT GROUPS WERE IDENTIFIED: egg donors who would not accept contact with children conceived from their genetic material under any circumstances, and would not have donated if it were not anonymous (26.3%); egg donors who expressed their desire, interest or fondness for such contact, and would have donated even if it were not anonymous (26.3%); and egg donors who had no desire or interest in such contact, but would agree to it if the initiative came from the children themselves and/or their families (47.4%). CONCLUSIONS: Spanish egg donors fluctuate between two interpretative registers concerning kinship: one prioritizing genetics and the other prioritizing experiential and social factors. The results suggest that lifting anonymity would not lead to a significant reduction in the number of egg donations.
引用
- Jociles Rubio MI, Ayala Rubio A. 'I helped create a child, but I am not its mother': attitudes of Spain's anonymous egg donors towards contact with donor-conceived children. Reprod Biomed Online. 2025. PMID: 40505161. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2025.104871
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。