提高生育治疗研究中非随机干预研究严谨性与影响力的建议
本文为多学科专家共识,提出7条建议以提升辅助生殖技术研究中非随机干预研究的可信度,包括明确估计目标、模拟目标试验、使用有向无环图、预注册方案、分离数据分析与计划、引入阴性对照、采用适宜分析方法处理混杂与选择偏倚。
要点
- 非随机干预研究可补充随机对照试验,反映真实临床实践与多样患者人群。
- 非随机干预研究易受混杂与选择偏倚影响,需严谨设计与先进分析技术。
- 目标试验模拟等新方法可增强非随机干预研究因果推断的有效性。
核心结论
- 整合随机对照试验与高质量非随机干预研究的证据可增强生育治疗研究的临床决策。
- 遵循7条建议可提高非随机干预研究的质量、透明度与影响力,促进循证临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- 多学科专家共识,针对生育治疗研究中非随机干预研究的最佳实践提出框架。
- 研究对象为接受辅助生殖技术操作(如卵巢刺激、实验室技术、胚胎移植)的患者。
- 干预:无。
主要发现
- 随机对照试验是确定生育治疗/辅助生殖技术干预有效性与安全性的金标准,但面临后勤、实践及伦理挑战。
- 非随机干预研究设计严谨时可补充随机对照试验,提供真实临床实践与多样患者人群的见解。
- 非随机干预研究的关键局限包括易受混杂与选择偏倚影响,需细致研究设计与先进分析技术处理。
- 目标试验模拟等新方法增强了基于非随机干预研究的因果推断有效性。
关键数值与推荐
- 建议1:明确研究问题并精确指定估计目标。
- 建议2:将非随机干预研究设计为模拟的目标试验。
- 建议3:使用有向无环图阐明因果假设。
- 建议4:预注册研究方案。
- 建议5:将数据分析与研究计划分离。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To provide a framework for conducting rigorous nonrandomized studies of interventions in fertility treatment research, addressing their role as complements to randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in evaluating treatment outcomes. DESIGN: Multidisciplinary expert consensus on best practices for nonrandomized studies of interventions, informed by advancements in novel methodologies, including causal inference. SUBJECTS: Patients undergoing assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) procedures, such as ovarian stimulation, laboratory techniques, and embryo transfer. INTERVENTION: None. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Guidance on methodological rigor, transparency, and relevance in nonrandomized studies of interventions study design and analysis. RESULTS: Randomized controlled trials are the gold standard for determining the efficacy and safety of fertility treatment/ART interventions but can face logistical, practical, and sometimes ethical challenges. Nonrandomized studies of interventions, when conducted with high methodological rigor, complement RCTs by offering insights into real-world clinical practices and diverse patient populations. Key limitations of nonrandomized studies of interventions include susceptibility to confounding and selection bias, which require meticulous study design and advanced analytical techniques to address. Recent innovations, such as target trial emulation studies, have enhanced the validity of causal inferences based on nonrandomized studies of interventions. This article outlines 7 recommendations to improve the credibility of nonrandomized studies of interventions in ART research: clearly define research questions with precise estimands; design nonrandomized studies of interventions as emulated trials; use directed acyclic graphs to clarify causal assumptions; preregister study protocols; separate data analysis from study planning; incorporate negative controls to detect biases; and use appropriate analytical methods to account for confounding and selection bias. CONCLUSION: Integrating evidence from RCTs and well-conducted nonrandomized studies of interventions enhances clinical decision making in fertility treatment research. By adhering to these recommendations, researchers can improve the quality, transparency, and impact of nonrandomized studies of interventions, ultimately fostering robust, evidence-based clinical practices in fertility treatment/ART.
引用
- Schwarze JE, Tennant PWG, Barnhart K, et al. Recommendation to improve the rigor and impact of nonrandomized studies of interventions in fertility treatment research. Fertil Steril. 2025. PMID: 40467028. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2025.05.168
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。