文献速递产科

初产足月单胎头位分娩的新围产期质量指标:将剖宫产率、母体与新生儿结局整合为单一母婴二元指标

A new perinatal quality measure in nulliparous term singleton vertex births: integrating cesarean rate, maternal, and neonatal outcomes into a single maternal-newborn dyadic metric.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2025-05-26

该回顾性横断面研究纳入2019年1月至2024年12月7家医院55,841例初产足月单胎头位分娩,发现剖宫产率与新生儿并发症率呈显著负相关(r=-0.79,P=.04),与母体并发症率无相关性(r=-0.08,P=.86)。采用结局优劣排序法构建母婴二元指标后,基于最理想结局「无母体及新生儿并发症的阴道分娩」的医院排名与基于剖宫产率的排名在总体人群、低危组和高危组中均发生显著变化。

要点

  • 剖宫产率与新生儿并发症率呈显著负相关(r=-0.79,P=.04),与母体并发症率无相关性(r=-0.08,P=.86)。
  • 基于「无母体及新生儿并发症的阴道分娩」的新二元指标使2/7(29%)医院总体排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.905,P=.002)。
  • 低危组3/7(43%)医院排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.810,P=.01),高危组5/7(71%)医院排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.714,P=.03)。

核心结论

  • 研究表明需要整合剖宫产率、母体及新生儿并发症率的母婴二元围产期质量指标。
  • 作者认为单独依赖剖宫产率或新生儿并发症率可能不准确地反映围产期照护质量。
  • 作者提出其Northwell复合二元指标「无母体及新生儿并发症的阴道分娩」可全面评估围产期照护质量。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性横断面研究,纳入2019年1月至2024年12月Northwell Health系统7家医院所有初产足月单胎头位分娩。
  • 母体并发症采用联合委员会(Joint Commission)标准的「严重产科并发症」。
  • 新生儿并发症采用联合委员会描述的「足月新生儿意外并发症」。
  • 基于入院时产科共病指数评分(0-3分和≥4分)将数据分层为低危和高危患者。

主要发现

  • 共分析55,841例初产足月单胎头位分娩。
  • 剖宫产率与新生儿并发症率呈显著负相关(r=-0.79,P=.04)。
  • 剖宫产率与母体并发症率无相关性(r=-0.08,P=.86)。
  • 母体并发症率与新生儿并发症率无相关性(r=-0.33,P=.47)。
  • 基于结局优劣排序法形成4组二元结局:a)无母体及新生儿并发症的阴道分娩;b)无母体及新生儿并发症的剖宫产;c)有母体和/或新生儿并发症的阴道分娩;d)有母体和/或新生儿并发症的剖宫产。

关键数值与推荐

  • 总体人群中2/7(29%)医院排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.905,P=.002)。
  • 低危组3/7(43%)医院排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.810,P=.01)。
  • 高危组5/7(71%)医院排名改变(Kendall Tau 0.714,P=.03)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Traditionally, hospital perinatal quality and rankings have been based on cesarean rates among nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex patients, and hospitals have recently added unexpected term newborn complication rates as a separate outcome category. The drawbacks of this methodology are two-fold: first, maternal complications are not considered and second, the maternal-newborn outcomes, which may not be aligned with each other, are reported separately. OBJECTIVE: The objectives were to: 1) evaluate the relationships between cesarean, maternal and neonatal complication rates in nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex patients; 2) develop unified measures incorporating cesarean, maternal, and neonatal complications, utilizing desirability of outcome ranking methodology, to evaluate individual hospital performances; and 3) compare hospital rankings using the most desirable dyadic outcome "vaginal delivery with no maternal and no neonatal complications" to cesarean rate-based rankings for the overall population, as well as for low- and high-risk patients. STUDY DESIGN: This retrospective cross-sectional study included all nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex deliveries at 7 hospitals of the Northwell Health system from January 2019 to December 2024. Maternal complications included "severe obstetric complications" as per the Joint Commission criteria. Neonatal complications included the conditions described by the Joint Commission as "unexpected complications in term newborns." First, statistical analyses were performed to evaluate correlations among cesarean, maternal, and neonatal complication rates in the 7 hospitals. Second, we employed dyadic maternal-newborn outcomes using a desirability of outcome ranking integrating cesarean, maternal, and neonatal complication rates for each hospital. Third, we used the most desirable outcome, "vaginal delivery with no maternal and no neonatal complications" to derive a new seven-hospital ranking which was then compared to the cesarean rate-based ranking. The same comparisons of rankings were also performed after stratification of the data to low- and high-risk patients based on the obstetric comorbidity index score on admission (0-3 and ≥4, respectively). RESULTS: A total of 55,841 nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex deliveries during the years 2019 to 2024 were analyzed. There was a significant negative correlation between cesarean and neonatal complication rates (r=-0.79, P=.04), and no correlations between cesarean vs maternal complication rates (r=-0.08, P=.86) or maternal complication vs neonatal complication rates (r=-0.33, P=.47) indicating the need for a combined metric. Based on the desirability of outcome ranking methodology, 4 groups of dyadic outcomes were formed: a) vaginal delivery with no maternal and no neonatal complications; b) cesarean with no maternal and no neonatal complications; c) vaginal delivery with maternal and/or neonatal complications; and d) cesarean with maternal and/or neonatal complications. The rates of dyadic outcomes were recorded for each hospital and the best possible dyadic outcome (vaginal delivery with no maternal and no neonatal complications) was used to create a new hospital ranking which was then compared with the (referent) cesarean rate-based ranking. There were significant changes in the overall ranking based on the new maternal-newborn dyadic measure: 2/7 (29%) hospitals changed ranking in the overall population (Kendall Tau 0.905, P=.002); 3/7 (43%) in the low-risk group (Kendall Tau 0.810, P=.01); and 5/7 (71%) in the high-risk group (Kendall Tau 0.714, P=.03). CONCLUSION: The study demonstrates the need for a dyadic maternal-newborn perinatal quality measures that incorporates cesarean rates, maternal and neonatal complication rates. Our findings suggest that separate reliance on cesarean or neonatal complication rates may provide an inaccurate representation of perinatal care quality. We propose that our Northwell composite dyadic measure "vaginal delivery with no maternal and no neonatal complications" allows for a comprehensive assessment of quality of perinatal care.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jackson FI, Vintzileos AM, Abelman SH, et al. A new perinatal quality measure in nulliparous term singleton vertex births: integrating cesarean rate, maternal, and neonatal outcomes into a single maternal-newborn dyadic metric. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 40436310. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2025.05.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。