有意义的临床结局:自发性早产临产后发生自发性早产的初级照护者的观点
本研究采用混合方法,通过文献回顾和对美国24名有自发性早产临产后自发性早产单胎活产经历的初级照护者进行半结构化电话访谈,识别其认为最重要的临床结局。照护者认为从早产临产开始延迟分娩是最重要的结局,通常1至2天被视为有意义的延迟阈值,且不认为新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点的各组成部分同等相关或同等重要。
要点
- 从早产临产开始延迟分娩是照护者认为最重要的临床结局。
- 通常1至2天被视为定义有意义延迟分娩的阈值。
- 照护者不认为新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点各组分同等相关或同等重要。
核心结论
- 照护者认为从自发性早产临产开始延迟分娩(通常至少1或2天)是最重要的临床结局。
- 研究结果确认了此类干预措施的未满足需求,为定义患者感知的有临床意义的分娩时间提供了基准,并从照护者角度确立了传统新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点的不足。
- 需要进一步研究以纳入对与照护者经历最相关的新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点组分进行加权,并确定从自发性早产临产开始至分娩的时间这一替代终点是否及在多大程度上反映新生儿临床结局。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,包括针对性文献回顾以获取初步见解,并据此设计半结构化、定性、概念引出电话访谈。
- 访谈对象为美国24名初级照护者,其孩子在23至36周胎龄因自发性早产临产发生单胎活产自发性早产。
- 初级照护者定义为自我认同为早产分娩的父母、自出生起承担主要照护和养育责任、并了解孩子自出生以来健康相关需求者。
- 对访谈转录文本进行主题分析。
主要发现
- 共访谈24名初级照护者。
- 从自发性早产临产开始延迟分娩是与成功干预最相关的临床结局,并因预期的胎儿、新生儿和母体获益(这些也被视为干预的独立获益)而被照护者认为最重要。
- 通常1至2天被视为定义从自发性早产临产开始的有意义分娩延迟的阈值。
- 照护者不认为新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点(历史上用于测量自发性早产干预试验的临床获益)的各个组成部分与其孩子的经历同等相关,也不因其感知的严重程度和导致进一步健康并发症的可能性差异而认为同等重要。
关键数值与推荐
- 从自发性早产临产开始延迟分娩通常至少1或2天被照护者视为有意义的临床结局阈值。
- 照护者不认为新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点的各组分同等相关或同等重要。
临床怎么用
- 研究结果从照护者角度为定义患者感知的有临床意义的分娩时间提供了基准。
- 研究结果从照护者角度确立了传统新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点的不足。
- 这些见解对于推动母婴健康治疗格局的演变以及为监管决策中选择终点以证明有意义的、以患者为中心的临床获益提供信息至关重要。
局限性
- 需要进一步研究以纳入对与照护者经历最相关的新生儿发病率与死亡率复合终点组分进行加权。
- 需要进一步研究以确定从自发性早产临产开始至分娩的时间这一替代终点是否及在多大程度上反映新生儿临床结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Patient-centered research is foundational to informing the measurement of clinical benefit in interventional studies. Understanding caregivers' lived experience of spontaneous preterm birth (sPTB) resulting from spontaneous preterm labor (sPTL) and characterizing their perspectives on the clinical outcomes of greatest importance and relevance are essential for advancing the development of interventions for the delay or prevention of sPTB. OBJECTIVE: This mixed methods study aimed to identify which clinical outcomes deriving from a (hypothetical) successful sPTL intervention are most important and relevant from the caregiver perspective to advance the therapeutic landscape for sPTB resulting from sPTL. STUDY DESIGN: A targeted literature review was conducted to obtain preliminary insights, which informed the content of semi-structured, qualitative, concept elicitation telephone interviews with primary caregivers in the United States who had a live, singleton sPTB between 23 and 36 weeks' gestational age resulting from sPTL. Primary caregivers were those who self-identified as the parent who gave birth to the child preterm, had assumed the primary caring and parenting responsibility since birth, and understood the child's health-related needs since birth. Interview transcripts were thematically analyzed. RESULTS: Twenty-four primary caregivers were interviewed. Delaying delivery from sPTL onset was the clinical outcome most associated with a successful intervention for sPTL and considered most important by caregivers due to anticipated subsequent fetal, neonatal, and maternal benefits (which were also perceived as distinct benefits of an intervention). One to 2 days was typically considered the threshold defining a meaningful delay to delivery from sPTL onset. Additionally, caregivers did not view the individual components of the neonatal morbidity and mortality composite endpoint (historically used to measure clinical benefit in trials of sPTB interventions) as equally relevant to their children's experiences, or as equally important due to perceived differences in their severity and potential for causing further health complications. CONCLUSIONS: This study centralizes the primary caregiver's voice regarding which clinical outcomes are most important and appropriate to measure for the demonstration of meaningful clinical benefit in interventional studies assessing the delay or prevention of sPTB. Specifically, caregivers perceived delaying delivery from sPTL onset, typically by a minimum of 1 or 2 days, as the most important clinical outcome. The findings confirm an unmet need for such interventions, provide a benchmark for defining a patient-perceived clinically meaningful time to delivery from sPTL onset, and establish the inadequacy of the traditional neonatal morbidity and mortality composite endpoint from the caregiver perspective. Specifically, caregivers perceived delaying delivery from sPTL onset, typically by a minimum of 1 or 2 days, as the most important clinical outcome. These insights are critical to evolving the therapeutic landscape for maternal and neonatal health, and informing regulatory decision-making on the selection of endpoints to demonstrate meaningful, patient-centered clinical benefit. Further research is necessary to incorporate weighting of the components of the neonatal morbidity and mortality composite endpoint that are most relevant to caregivers' experiences and to establish if, and to what extent, the surrogate endpoint of time to delivery from sPTL onset is reflective of neonatal clinical outcome.
引用
- Gargon E, Sharp R, Grant L, et al. Meaningful clinical outcomes: perspectives of primary caregivers with lived experience of spontaneous preterm birth following spontaneous preterm labor. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2025. PMID: 40383514. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2025.101701
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。