文献速递产科母胎医学

重新审视Hadlock 1991年胎儿估计体重人群参考标准

Revisiting the Hadlock 1991 population reference for estimated fetal weight.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2025-03-27

该研究重新计算Hadlock 1991年公式并与原表比较,回顾性应用于本机构2015年以来176,060次单胎生长超声(78,660名患者),发现使用表格较公式会漏诊5.1%的胎儿生长受限,既往文献方法不一致可能源于此差异。

要点

  • Hadlock 1991年公式与原文表格给出的胎儿估计体重关键点值不一致。
  • 使用表格较公式会漏诊5.1%(4009/78,660)的胎儿生长受限。
  • 若希望提高胎儿生长受限检出,应避免插值表格而优先使用公式。

核心结论

  • Hadlock 1991年回归公式与原文表格不一致,表格会漏诊胎儿生长受限并可能影响临床干预。
  • 既往关于Hadlock 1991检测胎儿生长受限的研究不一致可能归因于这些差异。
  • 若希望增加胎儿生长受限检出,应避免对Hadlock 1991表格进行插值,优先使用公式。
  • 需要对这些发现进行额外验证以确定临床意义。

研究设计与样本

  • 从Hadlock 1991原文正文公式重新计算胎儿体重标准表,并与原表比较。
  • 回顾性应用于本机构2015年以来所有单胎生长超声队列,共176,060次超声检查(78,660名患者)。
  • 收集引用Hadlock 1991的文献样本,以确定既往报告方法是否不同。

主要发现

  • Hadlock 1991公式产生的胎儿估计体重关键点值与原文表格不一致。
  • 在176,060次超声(78,660名患者)中,使用表格较公式会漏诊5.1%(4009/78,660)患者的胎儿生长受限。
  • 比较Hadlock 1991与其他生长标准的文献中,使用公式时倾向于支持Hadlock 1991,使用表格时则不支持。

关键数值与推荐

  • Hadlock 1991公式与原文表格给出的胎儿估计体重关键点值不一致。
  • 使用表格较公式会漏诊5.1%(4009/78,660)患者的胎儿生长受限。

临床怎么用

  • 若希望增加胎儿生长受限检出,应避免对Hadlock 1991表格进行插值,优先使用公式。
  • 需要额外验证这些发现以确定临床意义。

局限性

  • 需要对这些发现进行额外验证以确定临床意义。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: The most widely used population reference standard for fetal growth assessment in the United States is the Hadlock 1991 population reference. However, we detected discrepancies in the Hadlock 1991 publication between its stated methodology and its presentation of critical point values. This study investigates these discrepancies and their potential effects on clinical practice and research. STUDY DESIGN: The Hadlock 1991 table describing a fetal weight standard was recalculated from the Hadlock 1991 formula as printed in the body of the text. A difference was observed between the equation results and the table as published in the 1991 manuscript. These 2 methods for assessing estimated fetal weight percentiles were retrospectively applied to a cohort of all singleton growth ultrasounds performed at our institution since 2015. We also collected a sample of manuscripts in the literature that reference Hadlock 1991 to determine if methodology varied among previously published reports. RESULTS: The Hadlock 1991 equation does not produce the same critical point values for estimated fetal weight as the table presented in the manuscript. In our database of 176,060 ultrasound encounters for growth in singleton fetuses (78,660 patients), the Hadlock table, as compared to the Hadlock equation, would have resulted in underdiagnosis of fetal growth restriction in 5.1% (4009/78,660) of patients. Manuscripts that compared Hadlock 1991 to other growth standards tended to favor Hadlock 1991 if the equation was used, and disfavor it if the table was used. CONCLUSION: The Hadlock 1991 regression equation presented in the manuscript and the table are not the same. The table underdiagnoses fetal growth restriction and, potentially, impacts clinical intervention for fetuses at risk for growth abnormality. Inconsistencies in previous studies on the detection of fetal growth restriction using Hadlock 1991 may be attributed to these discrepancies. If increased detection of fetal growth restriction is desired, then Interpolation of the Hadlock 1991 table should be avoided and the equation preferred instead. Additional validation of these findings is required to ascertain clinical significance.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Roberts AW, Maroufy V, Salazar A, et al. Revisiting the Hadlock 1991 population reference for estimated fetal weight. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 40157521. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2025.03.032

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。