标准化中孕期超声方案的可行性:一项全国多中心研究
这项全国多中心前瞻性观察性FLASH研究评估了中孕期标准化超声方案的可行性及质量,共纳入440例中孕期超声扫描、9849张图像。结果显示21个推荐标准切面的可行性为88.5%至100%,64/73(88%)的符合性标准在超过90%的病例中满足,专家评估与操作者自评之间70/73(96%)标准的Gwet AC1相关系数大于0.80。
要点
- 基于共识的质量评估评分系统包含73条符合性标准,由28位专家通过3轮德尔菲法建立。
- 中孕期扫描21个推荐标准切面的可行性范围为88.5%至100%。
- 64/73(88%)的符合性标准在超过90%的病例中满足。
核心结论
- 这项为期2个月的大规模FLASH观察性研究显示,使用基于共识的质量评估评分系统的全国标准化中孕期超声方案具有可行性且质量良好。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心前瞻性观察性FLASH研究,共纳入440例中孕期超声扫描。
- 由28位专家通过3轮德尔菲法建立包含73条符合性标准的基于共识的质量评估评分系统。
- 要求操作者连续记录5例常规中孕期扫描,图像由超声医师本人及合格专家按评分系统分析。
主要发现
- 基于9849张图像,21个推荐标准切面的可行性范围为88.5%至100%。
- 64/73(88%)的符合性标准在超过90%的病例中满足。
- 专家评估与参与者评估之间的Gwet AC1相关系数在70/73(96%)的标准中大于0.80。
关键数值与推荐
- 标准化方案包含24个切面,其中21个为推荐切面、3个为附加切面。
- 可行性评估基于21个推荐标准切面,范围88.5%至100%。
- 符合性标准共73条,其中64条(88%)在超过90%的病例中满足。
- 自评与同行评估的Gwet AC1相关系数在70/73(96%)标准中大于0.80。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Evaluate the feasibility and quality of a national standardised mid-trimester ultrasound protocol using a consensus-based quality assessment (QA) scoring system. DESIGN: Multicenter prospective observational 'FLASH' study. SETTING: (i) Assessing the feasibility of a standardised protocol of 24 views at the mid-trimester scan, with 21 recommended and 3 additional views, in routine practice. (ii) Assessing the quality of these images by evaluating the presence of conformity criteria. (iii) Analysing the reliability between self-assessment and peer-assessment of the images. POPULATION: A total of 440 mid-trimester scans. METHODS: A consensus-based QA scoring system comprising 73 conformity criteria was established with 28 experts using a 3-round Delphi method. Secondly, we asked operators to record 5 consecutive routine mid-trimester scans. Images were analysed by the sonographer themselves and by a qualified expert according to the scoring system. The frequency of recorded images was calculated for each of the views. Factors associated with missing images per scan were evaluated. The robustness of conformity criteria was assessed by reliability between self-evaluation and peer-evaluation. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Based on 9849 images, we observed feasibility of the 21 recommended standardised views for mid-trimester scan ranging from 88.5% to 100%. RESULTS: Most conformity criteria (64/73, 88%) were met in over 90% of cases. Gwet's AC1 correlation between expert evaluation (peer-evaluation) and participant evaluation (self-evaluation) was greater than 0.80 for 70/73 (96%) criteria. CONCLUSION: This large-scale 2-month 'flash' observational study demonstrates the feasibility and quality of a national standardised mid-trimester ultrasound protocol using a consensus-based QA scoring system.
引用
- Bultez T, Salomon LJ, Mahallati H, et al. Feasibility of a Standardised Mid-Trimester Ultrasound Protocol: A National Multicenter Study. BJOG. 2025. PMID: 39949187. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.18102
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。