文献速递产科母胎医学

计算机化产前胎心监护的性能评估:足月时Dawes-Redman算法

Performance evaluation of computerized antepartum fetal heart rate monitoring: Dawes-Redman algorithm at term.
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol · 2025-01-01

基于1991至2024年牛津大学医院数据库的足月单胎妊娠产前胎心监护曲线,评估Dawes-Redman算法识别胎儿健康状态的效果。经倾向性评分匹配获得3316条曲线,算法特异度高(90.7%),但敏感度低(18.2%);阴性预测值随人群不良妊娠结局患病率升高而下降。结论认为该算法识别胎儿健康状态有效,但识别不良结局风险胎儿的能力有限。

要点

  • Dawes-Redman算法识别胎儿健康状态的特异度为90.7%(95% CI 89.2-92.0%)。
  • 算法敏感度为18.2%(95% CI 16.3-20.0%),识别不良结局风险胎儿能力有限。
  • 阴性预测值随不良妊娠结局患病率升高而下降:1%患病率时为99.1%,30%患病率时为72.1%。

核心结论

  • Dawes-Redman算法识别胎儿健康状态有效,证据为高特异度。
  • 算法敏感度低,提示其识别不良妊娠结局风险胎儿的能力有限。
  • 算法预测准确性显著受人群健康妊娠患病率影响。
  • 不符合10条Dawes-Redman标准的胎心监护曲线需进一步专家临床评估。
  • 开发针对高危妊娠场景优化的算法仍是未来研究关注领域。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析1991至2024年牛津大学医院数据库的足月单胎妊娠产前胎心监护曲线,孕周37+0至41+6周。
  • 排除信号信息缺失超过30%或Dawes-Redman分析不完整的曲线,仅纳入分娩前48小时内进行的监护。
  • 建立正常妊娠结局(NPO)队列和不良妊娠结局(APO)队列,APO定义为新生儿分娩后发生七种不良结局中至少一种。
  • 采用倾向性评分匹配(PSM)平衡NPO与APO队列,匹配因素为胎心监护时孕周、胎儿性别、就诊时母体体重指数、分娩时母体年龄、产次及胎心监护至分娩时间间隔。
  • 匹配后获得3316条产前胎心监护曲线的平衡数据集,标准化均数差<0.10。

主要发现

  • Dawes-Redman算法排除APO的特异度为90.7%(95% CI 89.2-92.0%),敏感度为18.2%(95% CI 16.3-20.0%)。
  • 阴性预测值(NPV)在APO患病率1%时为99.1%(95% CI 98.9-99.3%),在APO患病率30%时为72.1%(95% CI 67.7-76.1%)。
  • 分娩前0-24小时与24-48小时评估的特异度相似:0-24小时为90.8%(95% CI 88.8-92.7%),24-48小时为90.3%(95% CI 88.2-92.3%),P=0.898。
  • APO队列中不同不良结局间算法表现一致,特异度范围为87.7%至94.7%,NPV范围为95.4%至96.0%。

关键数值与推荐

  • Dawes-Redman算法将胎心监护曲线分类为「符合标准」(提示胎儿健康)或「不符合标准」(提示需进一步评估)。
  • 不符合10条Dawes-Redman标准的胎心监护曲线需进一步专家临床评估。

临床怎么用

  • Dawes-Redman算法可用于识别胎儿健康状态,高特异度支持其排除不良妊娠结局的用途。
  • 临床解读不符合10条Dawes-Redman标准的胎心监护曲线时,需进一步专家临床评估。
  • 算法预测准确性随人群健康妊娠患病率变化,低风险人群中NPV高,高风险人群中NPV下降。

局限性

  • 算法敏感度低(18.2%),提示其识别不良妊娠结局风险胎儿的能力有限。
  • 算法预测准确性显著受人群健康妊娠患病率影响。
  • 开发针对高危妊娠场景优化的算法仍是未来研究关注领域。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: To assess the effectiveness of the Dawes-Redman algorithm in identifying fetal wellbeing at term by analyzing 30 years of retrospective clinical data, comparing normal and adverse pregnancy outcomes, evaluating key metrics and testing its performance when used 0-48 h before delivery. METHODS: Antepartum fetal heart rate (FHR) traces from term singleton pregnancies at 37 + 0 to 41 + 6 weeks' gestation obtained between 1991 and 2024 were extracted from the Oxford University Hospitals database. Traces with > 30% of their signal information missing or with incomplete Dawes-Redman analyses were excluded. Only traces performed within 48 h prior to delivery were considered. A cohort of pregnancies with subsequent normal pregnancy outcome (NPO) was established using rigorous inclusion and exclusion criteria. Another cohort of pregnancies with adverse pregnancy outcome (APO) was developed if the neonate experienced at least one of seven APOs after delivery. Propensity score matching (PSM) facilitated a balanced comparison between NPO and APO cohorts using six factors: gestational age at FHR monitoring, fetal sex, maternal body mass index at presentation, maternal age at delivery, parity and time interval between FHR trace and delivery. FHR traces were categorized as either 'criteria met' (indicating fetal wellbeing) or 'criteria not met' (indicating a need for further evaluation) according to the Dawes-Redman algorithm, which informed the evaluation of predictive performance metrics. Performance was assessed using accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value (NPV) adjusted for various population risk prevalences of APO. RESULTS: A balanced dataset of 3316 antepartum FHR traces was developed with PSM (standardized mean difference < 0.10). The Dawes-Redman algorithm showed a high specificity of 90.7% (95% CI, 89.2-92.0%) for ruling out APO. Sensitivity was 18.2% (95% CI, 16.3-20.0%). The NPV varied with the population prevalence of APO and was high in very-low-risk settings (NPV, 99.1% (95% CI, 98.9-99.3%) at 1% APO prevalence) and decreased with increasing risk of APO (NPV, 72.1% (95% CI, 67.7-76.1%) at 30% APO prevalence). Temporal proximity of FHR assessment to delivery indicated robust specificity, which was similar for assessments performed at 0-24 h and 24-48 h prior to delivery (specificity at 0-24 h, 90.8% (95% CI, 88.8-92.7%); specificity at 24-48 h, 90.3% (95% CI, 88.2-92.3%); P = 0.898). Across the different adverse outcomes comprising the APO cohort, the performance of the Dawes-Redman algorithm remained consistent, with high specificity (ranging from 87.7% to 94.7%) and NPVs (ranging from 95.4% to 96.0%), confirming its utility in identifying fetal wellbeing. CONCLUSION: These findings indicate that the Dawes-Redman algorithm is effective for its intended purpose: identifying a state of fetal wellbeing. This is evidenced by its high specificity. However, its low sensitivity suggests limitations in its ability to identify fetuses at risk of APO. The predictive accuracy of the algorithm is affected significantly by the prevalence of healthy pregnancies within the population. Clinical interpretation of FHR traces that do not satisfy the 10 Dawes-Redman criteria warrant further expert clinical evaluation. While the algorithm proves reliable for its primary objective, the development of an algorithm optimized for high-risk pregnancy scenarios remains an area of interest for future study. © 2025 The Author(s). Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

来源:Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Davis Jones G, Albert B, Cooke W, et al. Performance evaluation of computerized antepartum fetal heart rate monitoring: Dawes-Redman algorithm at term. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 39894929. doi:10.1002/uog.29167

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。