宫内输血关键操作步骤:国际专家德尔菲调查
通过两轮德尔菲调查49名来自24个国家的胎儿干预专家,对32个宫内输血操作步骤进行评分,确定20个关键步骤和12个非关键步骤,并给出培训与维持能力所需例数及操作变异较大的环节。
要点
- 32个步骤中20个被评为关键,12个非关键被排除。
- 培训期间应完成中位20例(范围10-50)宫内输血以达到胜任。
- 每年需中位10例(范围5-20)以维持胜任能力。
核心结论
- 该国际德尔菲调查结果可用于标准化宫内输血的操作方法。
- 应由有经验的胎儿干预医师实施操作,在宫内输血实施不频繁的中心可考虑转诊至更有经验的中心。
- 在操作开始前计算具体输血量以及达到可存活孕周阈值后持续胎心监护分别在术中与术后阶段排名最高。
研究设计与样本
- 两轮德尔菲调查,对象为国际胎儿干预专家,第一轮提出32个潜在关键步骤,采用1分(不重要)至5分(绝对必要)的Likert量表评分,计算均分及95%CI;关键步骤定义为95%CI下限≥3.0,排除标准为95%CI上限≤3.5。
主要发现
- 共49名来自24个国家(六大洲)的专家参与了两轮调查,胎儿医学经验中位21年(范围4-38年),每年施行宫内输血例数中位20例(范围2-80例)。
- 32个步骤中20个被确定为关键,12个非关键步骤被排除。
- 受访者认为培训期间应施行中位20例(范围10-50例)宫内输血以达到胜任,每年需中位10例(范围5-20例)以维持胜任。
- 受访者在以下关键步骤上操作存在明显差异:供血者血液准备、术前用药、母体麻醉、脐带穿刺部位选择、胎儿麻痹使用、胎儿血细胞比容测定方法、术后护理及决定安排后续宫内输血。
关键数值与推荐
- 关键步骤判定标准:95%CI下限≥3.0;排除标准:95%CI上限≤3.5。
- 培训胜任所需例数中位20例(范围10-50例);维持胜任每年中位10例(范围5-20例)。
临床怎么用
- 应由有经验的胎儿干预医师实施宫内输血。
- 在宫内输血实施不频繁的中心,可考虑转诊至更有经验的中心。
- 在操作开始前计算具体输血量,并在达到可存活孕周阈值后持续胎心监护。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine consensus, using Delphi methodology, on the critical procedural steps for intravascular intrauterine transfusion (IUT) for the treatment of fetal anemia. METHODS: We conducted a two-part Delphi survey of international experts in fetal intervention. The first round of the survey proposed 32 potentially critical steps for the IUT procedure. Participants were asked to rate all steps on a Likert scale ranging from 1 (not important) to 5 (absolutely essential). We calculated the mean Likert score and 95% CI for all steps. Procedural steps were determined to be critical if the lower bound of the 95% CI was ≥ 3.0 and were excluded if the upper bound of the 95% CI was ≤ 3.5. In the second round of the survey, participants were asked specific questions regarding parameters associated with the procedural steps determined to be critical in the first round. RESULTS: Overall, 49 individuals from 24 different countries (six continents) participated in both rounds of the Delphi survey. The median length of experience in fetal medicine was 21 (range, 4-38) years. The median number of IUT procedures performed annually per respondent was 20 (range, 2-80). Of the 32 proposed procedural steps, 20 were determined to be critical and 12 non-critical procedural steps were excluded. Respondents indicated that an individual should perform a median of 20 (range, 10-50) IUT procedures during training to attain competency, and that the median number of IUT procedures required annually to maintain competency was 10 (range, 5-20). There was marked variation between respondents in how they performed the following critical IUT procedural steps: preparation of donor blood, preoperative medication, maternal anesthesia, site chosen for cordocentesis, use of fetal paralysis, method for determining fetal hematocrit, postoperative care and decision to schedule a subsequent IUT. CONCLUSIONS: The findings of this international Delphi survey can be used to standardize the approach to performing IUT. An experienced fetal interventionist should perform the procedure, and in centers in which IUT is performed infrequently, referral to a more experienced center should be considered. Calculating the specific volume of blood to transfuse at the start of the procedure and undertaking continuous fetal heart-rate monitoring once the gestational-age threshold for viability is reached were ranked highest in the intra- and postoperative phases of the procedure, respectively. © 2024 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Moise E, Moise KJ, Nwokocha M, et al. Critical procedural steps in intrauterine transfusion: Delphi survey of international experts. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2025. PMID: 39743652. doi:10.1002/uog.29151
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。