女性对计划性剖宫产手术同意过程及其手术风险体验的定性研究
该研究在伦敦市中心NHS教学医院对18名计划性剖宫产女性手术前后进行半结构化访谈,12人术后再次访谈,主题分析发现风险告知时机不当且内容不完整,女性因恐惧风险或被拒绝手术而情绪过载,限制了其对风险的理解,同意过程不符合知情同意的法律与专业标准。
要点
- 风险讨论在产前过于表浅,手术当日才全面披露,时机不当。
- 女性在决定手术前对产后出血、子宫切除、器官损伤及未来胎盘异常等特定风险不知情。
- 对风险的恐惧及担心剖宫产被拒绝的情绪反应限制了女性对已披露风险的理解。
核心结论
- 计划性剖宫产的同意过程缺乏适当且完整的风险披露。
- 风险披露时机不当或不足,未能促进女性对风险的理解,不符合知情同意的法律与专业标准。
研究设计与样本
- 探索性定性访谈研究,在伦敦市中心NHS教学医院开展。
- 纳入18岁以上、英语流利、计划性剖宫产女性,术前访谈18人,术后访谈其中12人。
- 采用半结构化访谈,录音转写后进行主题分析。
主要发现
- 识别出两大主题及四个亚主题:风险信息提供不及时和情绪过载。
- 风险信息提供不及时包括产前风险讨论表浅、手术当日才全面披露,以及决定手术前风险披露缺失或稀疏,女性对特定风险不知情。
- 情绪过载包括对风险的恐惧和担心剖宫产被拒绝,女性的认知反应尤其是情绪反应限制了对已披露风险的理解。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To explore how women appreciated the risks discussed within the consent process for planned caesarean section (CS). DESIGN: Exploratory qualitative interview study. SETTING: NHS Teaching Hospital in Central London. POPULATION: Women over the age of 18, English speaking, scheduled for a planned CS. METHODS: Semi-structured interviews were conducted before and after a woman's CS. Eighteen women were recruited and interviewed prior to undergoing CS and 12 of these were interviewed following CS. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed and thematically analysed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Themes generated from analysis of interviews exploring the experiences of women consenting to CS and specifically their awareness of postpartum haemorrhage (PPH), hysterectomy, organ damage and risk of placental abnormalities in future pregnancies. RESULTS: Two broad themes and four subthemes were identified (1) Untimely provision of risk information: (a) superficial risk discussions during the antenatal period and full risk disclosure on the day of surgery and (b) incompleteness absent or sparse risk disclosure prior to making the decision to undergo the CS, where women were unaware of specific risks and (2) Emotional overload: (a) fear of risks and (b) fear that a CS will be denied to them-women's cognitive response and notably their emotional response to their situation limited their understanding of risks disclosed. CONCLUSION: The consent process for planned CS was found to lack appropriate and full risk disclosure. Risk disclosure was ill-timed or deficient in facilitating women's understanding of risks reflecting a consent process which does not meet legal and professional standards of informed consent.
引用
- Nithiyananthan M, Nicholls J, Whitten M, et al. Women's Experience of the Consent Process to Planned Caesarean Section and Its Surgical Risk: A Qualitative Study. BJOG. 2024. PMID: 39722444. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.18049
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。