嵌合型非整倍体人类胚胎显示早期发育延迟:一项多中心形态动力学分析
该回顾性多中心研究分析了2016至2021年间三个欧洲体外受精中心的7027枚胚胎,比较整倍体、整条染色体非整倍体和嵌合型非整倍体胚胎的形态动力学模式。结果显示嵌合型非整倍体胚胎在最初三个细胞周期中分裂显著慢于其整倍体同胞,且到达囊胚阶段延迟。基于形态动力学的预测模型在多中心数据上预测性能 modest(训练集AUROC=0.58,测试集AUROC=0.57),单中心模型在同中心测试集上有所改善但跨中心应用时下降。
要点
- 嵌合型非整倍体胚胎在最初三个细胞周期中分裂显著慢于整倍体同胞。
- 嵌合型非整倍体胚胎到达囊胚阶段的时间也显著延迟。
- 基于形态动力学的预测模型在多中心数据上预测性能 modest。
核心结论
- 所开发的预测框架可能有助于改善胚胎植入前非整倍体遗传学检测周期的决策,帮助评估显示嵌合型非整倍体的胚胎并区分哪些胚胎更可能不携带致死性均匀非整倍体以供移植。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心研究,纳入2016至2021年间三个欧洲体外受精中心培养的共7027枚胚胎,分析仅包括不超过四个染色体改变的胚胎,得到3040枚整倍体、2818枚整条染色体非整倍体和697枚嵌合型非整倍体,数据集包含3742对不同的整倍体-嵌合型同胞对。
主要发现
- 嵌合型非整倍体胚胎在最初三个细胞周期中分裂显著慢于其整倍体同胞,到达囊胚阶段延迟,且在这些早期细胞周期中也显著慢于其非整倍体同胞。
- 基于多中心形态动力学数据并与非整倍体类型回归的逻辑模型在独立测试集上显示 modest 预测性能(训练集AUROC=0.58;测试集AUROC=0.57)。
- 基于单中心数据的预测性能有所改善,在同中心独立测试集上显示 adequate 预测性能(训练集AUROC=0.74;测试集AUROC=0.64),但在其他中心数据上测试时预测价值下降(AUROC=0.52-0.55)。
- 卵裂期出现多核和卵裂球排除与嵌合型非整倍体相关,将形态动力学特征与这些离散胚胎形态学特征结合到逻辑回归模型(训练集AUROC=0.71)可改善对嵌合型非整倍体的预测。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为所开发的预测框架可能有助于改善胚胎植入前非整倍体遗传学检测周期的决策,帮助评估显示嵌合型非整倍体的胚胎并区分哪些胚胎更可能不携带致死性均匀非整倍体以供移植。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To assess whether segmental aneuploid embryos display unique morphokinetic patterns. DESIGN: Retrospective multicenter study including a total of 7,027 embryos cultured between 2016 and 2021 in three European in vitro fertilization centers. Analysis was performed on aggregated multicenter data and separately for data from each center. Embryos with no more than four chromosomal alterations were considered in the analysis, resulting in 3,040 euploids and 2,818 whole-chromosome and 697 segmental aneuploids. Overall, the data set contained 3,742 distinct euploid-segmental sibling pairs. SUBJECTS: Standard morphokinetic features were annotated using various time-lapse systems. Blastocysts were subjected to comprehensive chromosomal screening via preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy. EXPOSURE: Morphokinetic patterns were compared among euploid, whole-chromosome aneuploid, and segmental aneuploid embryos. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Morphokinetic timings across groups were compared using statistical analysis, and associations with cleavage features were assessed. Multicenter and center-specific multivariate logistic regression models were calibrated, and their predictive performance was evaluated on independent test set data using area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) metrics. RESULTS: Segmental aneuploid embryos cleaved significantly slower than their euploid siblings across the first three cell cycles, with a delay reaching the blastocyst-stage of development. Specifically during these early cell cycles, segmental aneuploid embryos were also shown to be significantly slower than their aneuploid siblings. A logistic model on the basis of morphokinetic data from the multicenter data set and regressed against type of aneuploidy displayed modest predictive performance on an independent test set (train-AUROC = 0.58; test-AUROC = 0.57). Predictive performance improved on the basis of data from a single center displaying adequate predictive performance on an independent test set from the same center (train-AUROC = 0.74; test-AUROC = 0.64). However, the predictive value diminished when tested on data from other centers (AUROC = 0.52-0.55). Finally, the presence of multinucleation and blastomere exclusion at the cleavage stage were associated with segmental aneuploidies. The combination of morphokinetic features and these discrete embryo morphological features into the logistic regression model (train-AUROC = 0.71) provided an improved prediction of segmental aneuploidy, supporting future investigations using more comprehensive annotation systems. CONCLUSION: The developed predictive framework may help improve decision-making in preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy cycles, helping in the evaluation of embryos showing segmental aneuploidy and distinguishing which embryos are more likely to not have lethal uniform aneuploidies for transfer.
引用
- Figliuzzi M, Bori L, Ottolini CS, et al. Human embryos with segmental aneuploidies display delayed early development: a multicenter morphokinetic analysis. Fertil Steril. 2024. PMID: 39510239. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2024.10.042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。