患者对腹腔镜子宫内膜异位症病灶切除与消融的感知与体验:基于众包的症状与生活质量结局比较评估
该研究通过社交媒体对232例有腹腔镜消融和切除史的子宫内膜异位症患者进行在线问卷调查,比较两种术式在5个领域63项指标上的结局。消融仅对痛经(改善11.3%)和月经过多(改善8.5%)有改善,切除对所有症状改善28%至46%。在序贯接受消融后切除的113例患者中结果相似,切除在广泛症状和生活质量指标上优于消融。
要点
- 消融仅对痛经(改善11.3%)和月经过多(改善8.5%)有改善,其他躯体症状无显著改善。
- 切除对所有症状改善28%至46%,在功能、心理情绪、社会性及经济教育领域多数指标显著改善。
- 消融后23/24项心理情绪指标恶化,所有社会性指标恶化;切除后22/24项心理情绪指标改善,所有社会性指标改善。
核心结论
- 在有腹腔镜消融后接受切除史的子宫内膜异位症患者队列中,切除在广泛症状和生活质量指标上显示出比消融更大的有益效应。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究、方法比较问卷研究,在子宫内膜异位症主题社交媒体网站进行。
- 纳入232例有腹腔镜消融和切除史(无同期或间期子宫切除)的子宫内膜异位症患者。
- 在线问卷涵盖5个领域63项指标:躯体症状、功能影响、心理情绪影响、社会/性影响、经济/教育影响。
- 其中113例有消融后序贯切除手术史的患者用于更聚焦的比较。
主要发现
- 消融仅识别出痛经改善11.3%、月经过多改善8.5%,其他躯体症状指标无显著改善。
- 切除在所有症状上均有改善,范围为28%至46%。
- 功能影响方面,消融为无显著改善或状态恶化;切除在多数功能影响指标上显著改善。
- 心理情绪影响方面,消融后24项指标中23项生活质量状态恶化;切除后24项中22项改善。
- 社会-性影响方面,消融后所有指标恶化;切除后所有指标改善,其中多数显著。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To compare laparoscopic Ablation and Excision in terms of symptom and Quality of Life outcomes as perceived by endometriosis patients. DESIGN: A Cohort, Method comparison Questionnaire-based study. SETTING: Endometriosis-focused Social Media site. PATIENTS: Endometriosis patients with history of Laparoscopic Ablation and Excision. INTERVENTIONS: On-line questionnaire focused on pre and post procedure (ablation and excision) outcomes across 63 measures in 5 realms: Physical Symptoms, Functional Impact, Psycho-emotional Impact, Social/Sexual Impact, Economic/Educational Impact. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Two hundred and thirty-two respondents with surgical history that included laparoscopic ablation and excision (without concomitant or interposed hysterectomy) identified for ablation only physical symptom improvement of 11.3% and 8.5% for dysmenorrhea and menorrhagia respectively. Ablation provided no significant improvement in any other physical symptom measure. Excision was identified as providing improvements across all symptoms, ranging from 28% to 46%. In terms of functional Impact, ablation provided non-significant improvements or worsening of status. Excision demonstrated significant improvement for patients across most measures of Functional Impact. In terms of Psycho-emotional Impact, a worsening of quality of life status is identified in 23 of 24 measures following ablation. Excision demonstrated improvement in 22 of 24 measures. For Social-Sexual Impact, ablation resulted in worsened status across all measures, with excision demonstrating improvements in all measures, significantly so in most. For Economic/Educational Impact, significant worsening of measures or insignificant improvements were demonstrated following ablation. Excision demonstrated significant improvement in most measures. In all realms, pre-Excision status was worse than pre-Ablation. Allowing for a more focused comparison of ablation and excision, 113 respondents with a surgical history of ablation sequentially followed by excision demonstrated outcomes similar to the larger group: overall worsening of status resulting from ablation and overall improvement in status following excision with pre-Excision morbidity higher than pre-Ablation. CONCLUSION: In this cohort of patients undergoing laparoscopic endometriosis excision after having undergone endometriosis ablation, the former demonstrated greater beneficial effects over a broad spectrum of symptoms and quality of life measures.
引用
- Isaac A, Kapetanakis T, Thibeault E, et al. Patient Perception and Experience of Laparoscopic Excision Versus Ablation of Endometriosis: A Crowd-Sourced Comparative Evaluation of Symptom and Quality of Life Outcomes. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2024. PMID: 39490891. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2024.10.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。