将妊娠视为重复事件还是独立事件:对选定围产结局常用方法的实证比较
本研究利用生命记录与产妇出院记录链接的 singleton 出生数据,构建了四种队列(所有出生、随机选择一次出生、首次观察出生、初产出生),比较严重孕产妇病率(SMM)和子痫前期/子痫的患病率及其与种族/民族和系统性红斑狼疮的关联。结果显示不同队列间结局患病率和风险比存在差异,初产出生队列差异最明显;在 all-births 队列中,聚类稳健推断对置信区间影响很小,而调整产次会使 SMM 估计趋向无效、使子痫前期/子痫估计远离无效。作者建议研究者应考虑方法、抽样策略与研究问题的一致性,并在产次为效应修饰因子时呈现分层结果。
要点
- 不同队列选择方法下,SMM 患病率在初产出生队列为 18.9/1000 出生,在所有出生队列为 16.6/1000 出生。
- 按产次分层后,两种结局的患病率均在产次 2 的出生中最低、在产次 1 的出生中最高。
- 在 all-births 队列中,聚类稳健推断较标准推断对置信区间影响很小,调整产次使 SMM 估计趋向无效、子痫前期/子痫估计远离无效。
核心结论
- 研究者应考虑所用方法、抽样策略与研究问题之间的一致性,可包括调整研究问题以更好匹配可用数据所能支持的推断、考虑替代数据来源、恰当注明数据局限及由此产生的偏倚和发现的可推广性。
- 若产次是已确定的效应修饰因子,应呈现分层结果。
研究设计与样本
- 利用生命记录与产妇出院记录链接的 singleton 出生数据,构建四种队列:所有出生(N=2736,693)、随机选择每名个体一次出生(N=2284,660)、每名个体首次观察出生(N=2284,660)、初产出生(产次 1,N=1054,684)。
- 出生抽样不以聚类为条件,即并非按给定母亲抽取其所有出生,而是抽取单次出生。
- 研究结局为严重孕产妇病率(SMM)和子痫前期/子痫,自变量为自我报告的种族/民族(作为社会因素)和系统性红斑狼疮。
- 比较四种队列中母亲特征的分布、结局患病率(总体及按产次分层)以及结局与自变量关联的风险比(RR)。
- 在 all-births 中比较三种分析策略的 RR:假设同一母亲所生出生独立抽样的标准推断、聚类稳健推断、调整产次。
主要发现
- all-births、随机选择出生和首次观察出生队列之间人群特征差异较小,而这些队列与初产出生队列之间差异更明显。
- 结局患病率在所有出生中始终最低、在初产出生中最高,例如 SMM 在初产出生中为 18.9/1000 出生,在所有出生中为 16.6/1000 出生。
- 按产次分层时,两种结局的患病率始终在产次 2 的出生中最低、在产次 1 的出生中最高。
- 四种队列中研究结局的 RR 不同,初产出生队列与其他队列之间差异最明显。
- 在 all-births 中,与标准推断相比,聚类稳健推断对估计的置信界影响很小,例如狼疮-SMM 关联的粗估计为 4.01(95%CI 3.54-4.55) vs 4.01(95%CI 3.53-4.56)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In population-based research, pregnancy may be a repeated event. Despite published guidance on how to address repeated pregnancies to the same individual, a variety of approaches are observed in perinatal epidemiological studies. While some of these approaches are supported by the chosen research question, others are consequences of constraints inherent to a given dataset (eg, missing parity information). These decisions determine how appropriately a given research question can be answered and overall generalizability. OBJECTIVE: To compare common cohort selection and analytic approaches used for perinatal epidemiological research by assessing the prevalence of two perinatal outcomes and their association with a clinical and a social independent variable. STUDY DESIGN: Using vital records linked to maternal hospital discharge records for singleton births, we created four cohorts: (1) all-births (2) randomly selected one birth per individual (3) first-observed birth per individual (4) primiparous-births (parity 1). Sampling of births was not conditional on cluster (ie, we did not sample all births by a given mother, but rather sampled individual births). Study outcomes were severe maternal morbidity (SMM) and preeclampsia/eclampsia, and the independent variables were self-reported race/ethnicity (as a social factor) and systemic lupus erythematosus. Comparing the four cohorts, we assessed the distribution of maternal characteristics, the prevalence of outcomes, overall and stratified by parity, and risk ratios (RR) for the associations of outcomes with independent variables. Among all-births, we then compared RR from three analytic strategies: with standard inference that assumes independently sampled births to the same mother in the model, with cluster-robust inference, and adjusting for parity. RESULTS: We observed minor differences in the population characteristics between the all-birth (N=2736,693), random-selection, and first-observed birth cohorts (both N=2284,660), with more substantial differences between these cohorts and the primiparous-births cohort (N=1054,684). Outcome prevalence was consistently lowest among all-births and highest among primiparous-births (eg, SMM 18.9 per 1000 births among primiparous-births vs 16.6 per 1000 births among all-births). When stratified by parity, outcome prevalence was always the lowest in births of parity 2 and highest among births of parity 1 for both outcomes. RR differed for study outcomes across all four cohorts, with the most pronounced differences between the primiparous-birth cohort and other cohorts. Among all-births, robust inference minimally impacted the confidence bounds of estimates, compared to the standard inference, that is, crude estimates (eg, lupus-SMM association: 4.01, 95% confidence intervals [CI] 3.54-4.55 vs 4.01, 95% CI 3.53-4.56 for crude estimate), while adjusting for parity slightly shifted estimates, toward the null for SMM and away from the null for preeclampsia/eclampsia. CONCLUSION: Researchers should consider the alignment between the methods they use, their sampling strategy, and their research question. This could include refining the research question to better match inference possible for available data, considering alternative data sources, and appropriately noting data limitations and resulting bias, as well as the generalizability of findings. If parity is an established effect modifier, stratified results should be presented.
引用
- Bane S, Carmichael SL, Mathur MB, et al. Considering pregnancies as repeated vs independent events: an empirical comparison of common approaches across selected perinatal outcomes. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2024. PMID: 38996915. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2024.101434
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。