双胎输血综合征激光手术随机对照试验:序贯试验
这项单中心、开放标签、随机对照试验纳入642例双胎输血综合征患者,比较序贯法与选择性激光手术对供血儿存活的影响。结果显示两组供血儿出生时存活率无显著差异(85.6% vs 84.2%),序贯组术后大脑中动脉收缩期峰值流速更低;事后分析提示供血儿存活可能根据高危因素与激光技术选择相关,需进一步研究。
要点
- 序贯法与选择性激光手术的供血儿出生时存活率无显著差异(85.6% vs 84.2%)。
- 存在浅表吻合支者供血儿存活率低于仅动脉-静脉吻合者(70.6% vs 90.3%)。
- 序贯组术后大脑中动脉收缩期峰值流速低于选择性组(1.00±0.30 vs 1.06±0.30 MoM)。
核心结论
- 序贯法与选择性激光技术的供血儿存活率无差异,浅表吻合支先消融或后消融的供血儿存活率也无差异。
- 序贯法较选择性法改善了供血儿术后大脑中动脉收缩期峰值流速。
- 事后分析提示供血儿存活可能根据高危因素与激光技术选择相关,需进一步研究以确定按这些分类指导手术技术选择能否改善结局。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、开放标签、随机对照试验,将双胎输血综合征患者随机分配至序贯法或选择性激光手术。
- 试验内嵌套第二项试验,将存在浅表吻合支(动脉-动脉和静脉-静脉)的患者随机分配至先消融这些连接(在消融动脉-静脉吻合前)或最后消融。
- 共642例患者被随机分组。
- 主要结局指标为供血儿出生时存活。
主要发现
- 总体供血儿存活率两组相似:序贯组274/320(85.6%)vs 选择性组271/322(84.2%);比值比1.12(95%置信区间0.73-1.73);P=0.605。
- 浅表吻合支见于642例中的177例(27.6%)。
- 浅表吻合支组供血儿存活率低于仅有动脉-静脉吻合组:125/177(70.6%)vs 420/465(90.3%);校正比值比0.33(95%置信区间0.20-0.54);P<0.001。
- 在存在浅表吻合支的病例中,供血儿存活与消融时机或手术技术无关。
- 术后平均大脑中动脉收缩期峰值流速序贯组低于选择性组:1.00±0.30 vs 1.06±0.30中位数倍数;P=0.003。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 需进一步研究以确定使用这些分类指导手术技术选择是否能改善结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Intraoperative blood transfer between twins during laser surgery for twin-twin transfusion syndrome can vary by surgical technique and has been proposed to explain differences in donor twin survival. OBJECTIVE: This trial compared donor twin survival with 2 laser techniques: the sequential technique, in which the arteriovenous communications from the volume-depleted donor to the volume-overloaded recipient are laser-occluded before those from recipient to donor, and the selective technique, in which the occlusion of the vascular communications is performed in no particular order. STUDY DESIGN: A single-center, open-label, randomized controlled trial was conducted in which twin-twin transfusion syndrome patients were randomized to sequential vs selective laser surgery. Nested within the trial, a second trial randomized patients with superficial anastomoses (arterioarterial and venovenous) to ablation of these connections first (before ablating the arteriovenous anastomoses) vs last. The primary outcome measure was donor twin survival at birth. RESULTS: A total of 642 patients were randomized. Overall donor twin survival was similar between the 2 groups (274 of 320 [85.6%] vs 271 of 322 [84.2%]; odds ratio, 1.12 [95% confidence interval, 0.73-1.73]; P=.605). Superficial anastomoses occurred in 177 of 642 cases (27.6%). Donor survival was lower in the superficial anastomosis group vs those with only arteriovenous communications (125 of 177 [70.6%] vs 420 of 465 [90.3%]; adjusted odds ratio, 0.33 [95% confidence interval, 0.20-0.54]; P<.001). In cases with superficial anastomoses, donor survival was independent of the timing of ablation or surgical technique. The postoperative mean middle cerebral artery peak systolic velocity was lower in the sequential vs selective group (1.00±0.30 vs 1.06±0.30 multiples of the median; P=.003). Post hoc analyses showed 2 factors that were associated with poor overall donor twin survival: the presence or absence of donor twin preoperative critical abnormal Doppler parameters and the presence or absence of arterioarterial anastomoses. Depending on these factors, 4 categories of patients resulted: (1) Category 1 (347 of 642 [54%]), no donor twin critical abnormal Doppler + no arterioarterial anastomoses: donor twin survival was 91.2% in the sequential and 93.8% in the selective groups; (2) Category 2 (143 of 642 [22%]), critical abnormal Doppler present + no arterioarterial anastomoses: donor survival was 89.9% vs 75.7%; (3) Category 3 (73 of 642 [11%]), no critical abnormal Doppler + arterioarterial anastomoses present: donor survival was 94.7% vs 74.3%; and (4) Category 4 (79 of 642 [12%]), critical abnormal Doppler present + arterioarterial anastomoses present: donor survival was 47.6% vs 64.9%. CONCLUSION: Donor twin survival did not differ between the sequential vs selective laser techniques and did not differ if superficial anastomoses were ablated first vs last. The donor twin's postoperative middle cerebral artery peak systolic velocity was improved with the sequential vs the selective approach. Post hoc analyses suggest that donor twin survival may be associated with the choice of laser technique according to high-risk factors. Further study is needed to determine whether using these categories to guide the choice of surgical technique will improve outcomes.
引用
- Chmait RH, Korst LM, Llanes AS, et al. Randomized controlled trial of twin-twin transfusion syndrome laser surgery: the sequential trial. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2024. PMID: 38897340. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2024.06.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。