非男性因素不孕夫妇中经卵胞浆内单精子注射与常规体外受精出生儿童的发育结局
本前瞻性队列研究对既往随机对照试验(NCT03428919)中非男性因素不孕夫妇经卵胞浆内单精子注射(ICSI)或常规体外受精(cIVF)出生的12月龄以上儿童进行随访,采用ASQ-3和Red Flags问卷评估发育结局。ICSI组与cIVF组儿童任何ASQ-3异常评分比例无显著差异(16.9% vs 13.1%,P=0.34),Red Flag征象比例亦相当(6.2% vs 9.2%,P=0.36)。作者认为初步研究显示两者对12月龄后发育结局影响似乎相当。
要点
- 非男性因素不孕夫妇中,ICSI与cIVF出生儿童12月龄后ASQ-3异常评分比例无显著差异(16.9% vs 13.1%,P=0.34)。
- 两组Red Flag征象比例相当(6.2% vs 9.2%,P=0.36)。
- 本研究为初步研究,问卷筛查可能影响统计效能,需更广泛和长期随访才能得出明确结论。
核心结论
- 在这项初步研究中,ICSI与cIVF对非男性因素不孕夫妇出生儿童12月龄后的发育结局似乎具有相当的影响。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性队列研究,随访既往随机对照试验(NCT03428919)中经ICSI或cIVF妊娠出生的所有12月龄及以上儿童。
- 原随机对照试验随机分配1064名女性至ICSI组或cIVF组(每组532名女性)。
- 随访纳入ICSI组155对夫妇(195名儿童)和cIVF组141对夫妇(185名儿童)。
- ICSI组141名女性(90.1%)(177名儿童)和cIVF组113名女性(80.1%)(145名儿童)返回完整填写的问卷。
- 使用越南版年龄与阶段第三版问卷(ASQ-3)和发育危险信号(Red Flags)问卷进行评估。
主要发现
- 随访时ICSI组儿童平均年龄19.5±5.0个月,cIVF组19.3±5.5个月。
- 两组儿童平均身高和体重相似。
- 任何ASQ-3异常评分的总体比例在ICSI组与cIVF组间无显著差异(16.9% vs 13.1%,P=0.34)。
- 有Red Flag征象的儿童比例在两组间相当(6.2% vs 9.2%,P=0.36,分别为ICSI组与cIVF组)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为当前发现为现有证据提供补充,支持ICSI与cIVF在早期儿童发育方面的比较安全性。
- 作者指出需要对这些儿童进行更广泛和更长期的随访数据才能得出明确结论。
局限性
- 尽管随访应答率相当高,但存在潜在抽样偏倚,且总体发育异常儿童数量非常少。
- 研究仅依赖问卷作为筛查工具,未纳入额外行为观察或身体发育测试,可能影响统计效能和组间比较的显著性。
- 需要更广泛和更长期的随访数据才能得出明确结论。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: In non-male factor infertile couples, are there any differences in the developmental outcomes between children born through ICSI and conventional IVF (cIVF)? SUMMARY ANSWER: In this preliminary study, ICSI and cIVF seem to have a comparable effect on developmental outcomes after 12 months in children born to non-male factor infertile couples. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: ICSI, an invasive technique, has raised concerns about potential developmental abnormalities in children. Limited data are available regarding the developmental outcomes of ICSI-conceived infants born to non-male factor infertile couples. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: This prospective cohort study involved a follow-up of all children aged 12 months or older who were born from pregnancies resulting from either ICSI or cIVF as part of a previous randomized controlled trial (RCT) (NCT03428919). PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: In the original RCT, 1064 women were randomly assigned to the ICSI or cIVF groups (532 women for each group). Follow-up was conducted with 155 couples (195 children) in the ICSI group and 141 couples (185 children) in the cIVF group. The Vietnamese version of the Ages & Stages Third Edition Questionnaires (ASQ-3) and the Development Red Flags questionnaires were completed by the participants. A total of 141 (90.1%) women (177 children) in the ICSI group and 113 (80.1%) women (145 children) in the cIVF group returned fully completed questionnaires. The primary outcomes were the developmental outcomes based on responses to the ASQ-3 and the Red Flags questionnaire. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The mean age of children at follow-up was 19.5 ± 5.0 months in the ICSI group and 19.3 ± 5.5 months in the cIVF group. The mean height and weight of children in both groups were similar. The overall proportion of children with any abnormal ASQ-3 score did not differ significantly between the ICSI and cIVF groups (16.9% vs 13.1%, P = 0.34). The proportion of children with Red Flag signs was also comparable between the two groups (6.2% vs 9.2%, P = 0.36, ICSI vs cIVF, respectively). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Despite a reasonably high follow-up response rate, there is a potential risk of sampling bias, and overall, the number of children with developmental abnormalities was very small. The study relied solely on questionnaires as screening tools, rather than incorporating additional behavioral observations or physical developmental tests; this may have affected the statistical power and the significance of between-group comparisons. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: The current findings contribute to the existing evidence and support the comparative safety of ICSI and cIVF regarding early childhood development. However, more extensive and prolonged follow-up data for these children are needed to draw definitive conclusions. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No external funding was received for this study, and no authors reported conflicting interests. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT04866524 (clinicaltrials.gov).
引用
- Nguyen NA, Nguyen NT, Tran VTT, et al. Developmental outcomes of children born through ICSI versus conventional IVF (cIVF) in couples with non-male factor infertility. Hum Reprod. 2024. PMID: 38840410. doi:10.1093/humrep/deae120
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。