是时候停止使用碱缺失评估胎儿健康状况了吗?
该文指出,脐动脉血碱缺失虽已用于临床50余年,但其算法基于成人酸碱参数(pH 7.40、二氧化碳分压40 mm Hg),忽略胎儿宫内正常酸碱状态(pH 7.27、二氧化碳分压54 mm Hg)及缺氧时二氧化碳分压可升至130至150 mm Hg的特点,可能高估代谢性酸中毒并误导胎儿健康状况评估。作者认为应考虑替代碱缺失的指标,并提出与新生儿酸碱生理相关的指标——新生儿等碳酸pH校正。
要点
- 碱缺失算法基于成人酸碱参数,忽略胎儿宫内正常pH 7.27和二氧化碳分压54 mm Hg。
- 胎儿缺氧时二氧化碳分压可升至130至150 mm Hg,成人代谢性酸中毒因过度通气无此现象。
- 作者认为碱缺失的局限可能高估代谢性酸中毒,建议考虑替代指标。
核心结论
- 作者认为,基于现有论据,在分娩管理中就胎儿健康状况得出结论时,审慎考虑碱缺失的替代指标是合理的。
- 作者提出一个与新生儿酸碱生理相关的指标——新生儿等碳酸pH校正,可加入动脉脐血气分析,并描述了如何将其解读为新生儿代谢性酸中毒的指标。
研究设计与样本
- 原文为专家观点文章,未报告系统检索范围或样本量。
主要发现
- 碱缺失分为全血和细胞外液两大家族,均依赖使用正常成人酸碱特征(pH 7.40、二氧化碳分压40 mm Hg)的方程,忽略胎儿宫内正常酸碱状态(pH 7.27、二氧化碳分压54 mm Hg)。
- 胎儿缺氧时依赖胎盘循环清除二氧化碳,二氧化碳分压可极高(达130至150 mm Hg),而成人急性代谢性酸中毒可通过过度通气避免此现象。
- 关于碳酸氢盐估算中是否纳入高二氧化碳分压校正的争议(如Great Trans-Atlantic Debates所呈现)仍未解决。
- 当前碱缺失算法中为成人酸碱生理计算的关键常数未考虑高二氧化碳分压影响或胎儿缓冲能力特征(如体液含量组成、血浆蛋白和血红蛋白特性的差异),可能高估代谢性酸中毒,尤其在缺氧反应早期处于高碳酸血症的新生儿中。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Authors have expressed reservations regarding the use of base deficit measured in umbilical artery blood samples to assess fetal well-being during the course of labor and to predict neonatal neurologic morbidity. Despite its integration into clinical practice for more than 50 years, obstetricians and maternal-fetal medicine specialists may not realize that this marker has significant limitations in accurately identifying neonatal metabolic acidosis as a proxy for fetal well-being. In brief, there are 2 large families of base deficit, namely whole blood and extracellular fluid. Both rely on equations that use normal adult acid-base characteristics (pH 7.40 and partial CO2 pressure of 40 mm Hg) that overlook the specificity of the normal in utero acid-base status of pH 7.27 and partial CO2 pressure of 54 mm Hg. In addition, it ignores the unique characteristic of the in utero fetal response to acute hypoxia. The dependence on placental circulation for CO2 elimination may lead to extremely high values (up to 130 to 150 mm Hg) during hypoxic events, a phenomenon that is absent in adults with acute metabolic acidosis who can hyperventilate. The dispute over if to include a correction for high partial CO2 pressure in the bicarbonate estimation, as presented in the Great Trans-Atlantic Debates, remains unresolved. The key constants computed for adult acid-base physiology in the current base deficit algorithms, without accounting for the impact of high partial CO2 pressure or other fetal characteristics of buffering capacity (eg, differences in body water content composition, plasma protein, and hemoglobin attributes), may lead to an overestimation of metabolic acidosis, especially in newborns who are experiencing hypercarbia during the early stages of the hypoxic response. These unrecognized limitations impact the base deficit results and may mislead clinicians on fetal well-being assessments when discussing the management of fetal heart rate monitoring and neonatal outcomes. Based on our arguments, we believe that it is prudent to consider an alternative to base deficit for drawing conclusions regarding fetal well-being during the course of birth management. We propose a marker specifically related to the newborn acid-base physiology--the neonatal eucapnic pH correction. This marker can be added to arterial cord blood gas analysis, and we have described how to interpret it as a marker of neonatal metabolic acidosis.
引用
- Daboval T, Ouellet P, Racinet C, et al. Is it time to end the use of base deficit for fetal well-being assessment? Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2024. PMID: 38432420. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2024.01.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。