量化精子DNA碎片率与辅助生殖技术结局的关联:一项伞状综述
本伞状综述综合了22篇系统综述(其中15篇为Meta分析),评估精子DNA碎片率(SDF)与辅助生殖技术(ART)结局的关联。重新估计的Meta分析显示,SDF与活产、妊娠、流产、着床、囊胚形成和受精的关联均为弱或无统计学意义,未发现令人信服或提示性的证据。
要点
- SDF与ART结局的关联在多数Meta分析中为弱或无统计学意义。
- 纳入的22篇综述质量经AMSTAR 2评估多为极低(18篇)或低(4篇),ROBIS均评为高偏倚风险。
- 作者结论:未发现令人信服或提示性证据,对SDF相关声明、政策或推荐应谨慎。
核心结论
- 本伞状综述未发现SDF与ART结局之间存在令人信服或提示性的证据。
- 对SDF做出任何声明、政策或推荐时应谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 伞状综述,预先注册后检索PubMed、Scopus、Cochrane Library、Web of Science和Embase数据库,无语言或发表时间限制。
- 最终纳入22篇系统综述(其中15篇为Meta分析),评估SDF与ART结局的关联。
- 采用AMSTAR 2和ROBIS评估纳入综述质量,计算校正覆盖面积(CCA)评估原始研究重叠度。
- 对活产、妊娠、流产、着床、囊胚形成和受精的关联,在随机效应Meta分析中重新估计比值比(eOR)及95%置信区间(95%CI)和95%预测区间(95%PI)。
主要发现
- 22篇综述的原始研究总体n=428,含180项独特研究,校正CCA为9.2%(中度重叠)。
- 15篇Meta分析的原始研究总体n=274,含118项独特研究,校正CCA为13.6%(高度重叠)。
- AMSTAR 2将18篇综述的证据质量评为极低,4篇评为低;ROBIS将所有综述评为高偏倚风险。
- 重新估计结果显示,SDF与活产的关联在1篇Meta分析中为弱,在4篇中无统计学意义。
- SDF与妊娠、流产、着床、囊胚形成和受精的关联亦为弱或无统计学意义;高SDF与不同ART结局(IVF、ICSI、IUI)及不同检测的关联也为弱或无统计学意义。
关键数值与推荐
- 证据强度分类依据重新估计的Meta分析P值、总样本量、异质性I²统计量、小研究效应、过度显著性偏倚及最大研究显著性,分为令人信服、高度提示、提示、弱或无统计学意义。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses are instrumental in shaping clinical practice. However, their findings can sometimes be marred by discrepancies and potential biases, thereby diluting the strength of the evidence presented. Umbrella reviews serve to comprehensively assess and synthesise these reviews, offering a clearer insight into the quality of the evidence presented. In the context of the relationship between sperm DNA fragmentation (SDF) and assisted conception outcomes, there is a divergence in the literature. Some reviews suggest a clear cause-and-effect linkage, whereas others present conflicting or inconclusive results. OBJECTIVES: In this umbrella review we aimed to synthesise the evidence collated in systematic reviews and meta-analyses summarising the association of SDF with assisted reproductive technology (ART) outcomes. SEARCH STRATEGY: After preregistration (https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/6JHDP), we performed a comprehensive search of the PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane Library, Web of Science and Embase databases. We conducted a search for systematic reviews on the association between SDF and ART without any restrictions on language or publication date. SELECTION CRITERIA: Systematic reviews and meta-analyses assessing the association between SDF and ART outcomes were eligible. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: We assessed the quality of the included reviews using AMSTAR 2 and ROBIS, and determined the degree of overlap of primary studies between reviews estimating the corrected covered area (CCA), adjusted for structural missingness. We evaluated the most recent reviews assessing the association of SDF with live birth, pregnancy, miscarriage, implantation, blastulation and fertilisation. The synthesis of evidence was harmonised across all included quantitative syntheses, re-estimating the odds ratio (eOR) in random-effects meta-analyses with 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) and 95% prediction intervals (95% PIs). We categorised the evidence strength into convincing, highly suggestive, suggestive, weak or nonsignificant, according to the meta-analysis re-estimated P-value, total sample size, I2 statistic for heterogeneity, small study effect, excess significance bias and the largest study significance. MAIN RESULTS: We initially captured and screened 49 332 records. After excluding duplicate and ineligible articles, 22 systematic reviews, 15 of which were meta-analyses, were selected. The 22 reviews showed a moderate degree of overlap (adjusted CCA 9.2%) in their included studies (overall n = 428, with 180 unique studies). The 15 meta-analyses exhibited a high degree of overlap (adjusted CCA = 13.6%) in their included studies (overall n = 274, with 118 unique studies). AMSTAR 2 categorised the quality of evidence in 18 reviews as critically low and the quality of evidence in four reviews as low. ROBIS categorised all the reviews as having a high risk of bias. The re-estimated results showed that the association of SDF with live birth was weak in one and nonsignificant in four meta-analyses. Similarly, the association of SDF with pregnancy, miscarriage, implantation, blastulation and fertilisation was also weak or nonsignificant. The association of high SDF with different ART outcomes was also weak or nonsignificant for different interventions (IVF, ICSI and IUI) and tests. CONCLUSIONS: This umbrella review did not find convincing or suggestive evidence linking SDF with ART outcomes. Caution should be exercised in making any claims, policies or recommendations concerning SDF.
引用
- Maghraby H, Elsuity MA, Adel N, et al. Quantifying the association of sperm DNA fragmentation with assisted reproductive technology outcomes: An umbrella review. BJOG. 2024. PMID: 38450853. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.17796
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。