应用气泡图分析第二产程剖宫产率
该研究回顾了2009年至2018年间8家产科单位共353434例单胎足月头位分娩数据,比较各单位的第二产程剖宫产率、第二产程前剖宫产率及阴道助产率,并用气泡图展示三者关系。结果显示初产妇第二产程前剖宫产率低于经产妇,但第二产程剖宫产率和阴道助产率更高;气泡图可将8个单位聚类为5个区域,区分不同的产科实践模式。作者认为第二产程剖宫产率需结合另两种分娩方式率来评估。
要点
- 初产妇第二产程前剖宫产率18.58%低于经产妇21.26%(P<.001)。
- 初产妇第二产程剖宫产率0.79%高于经产妇0.22%(P<.001)。
- 气泡图可区分第二产程剖宫产率相似但产科实践不同的单位。
核心结论
- 第二产程剖宫产率必须结合第二产程前剖宫产率和阴道助产率来评估。
- 气泡图是分析这三种分娩方式率之间关系的有用方法,可区分不同单位的产科实践。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析2009年至2018年间8家公立产科单位(标记为A至H)的全地区分娩数据。
- 纳入标准为单胎头位、足月(≥37周妊娠)分娩,共353434例,其中初产妇180496例(51.1%)。
- 第二产程前剖宫产率定义为所有择期剖宫产及未达宫颈完全扩张前的急诊剖宫产占全部分娩的比例。
- 第二产程剖宫产率和阴道助产率分别按相应分娩方式占达到宫颈完全扩张病例数的比例计算。
- 使用气泡图,以各单位第二产程剖宫产率为y轴、第二产程前剖宫产率为x轴绘制气泡,气泡大小代表第二产程剖宫产与阴道助产的比值。
主要发现
- 初产妇组第二产程前剖宫产率为18.58%,经产妇组为21.26%(P<.001)。
- 初产妇组第二产程剖宫产率为0.79%,经产妇组为0.22%(P<.001)。
- 初产妇组阴道助产率为17.61%,经产妇组为3.58%(P<.001)。
- 以平均气泡为参考,8个单位的气泡聚类为5个区域:单位B和H接近中心平均值;单位A和F位于右上角,第二产程前剖宫产率和第二产程剖宫产率均较高;单位D和E位于对侧端;单位C位于左上角,第二产程前剖宫产率低但第二产程剖宫产率高;单位G位于对侧端。
- 单位C和G的第二产程剖宫产与阴道助产比值分别为0.09和0.01,处于两个极端。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The incidence of second stage cesarean delivery has been rising globally because of the failure or the anticipated difficulty of performing instrumental delivery. Yet, the best way to interpret the figure and its optimal rate remain to be determined. This is because it is strongly influenced by the practice of other 2 modes of birth, namely cesarean delivery performed before reaching the second stage and assisted vaginal birth during the second stage. In this regard, a bubble chart that can display 3-dimensional data through its x-axis, y-axis, and the size of each plot (presented as a bubble) may be a suitable method to evaluate the relationship between the rates of these 3 modes of births. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to conduct an epidemiologic study on the incidence of second stage cesarean deliveries rates among >300,000 singleton term births in 10 years from 8 obstetrical units and to compare their second stage cesarean delivery rates in relation to their pre-second stage cesarean delivery rates and assisted vaginal birth rates using a bubble chart. STUDY DESIGN: The territory-wide birth data collected between 2009 and 2018 from all 8 public obstetrical units (labelled as A to H) were reviewed. The inclusion criteria were all singleton pregnancies with cephalic presentation that were delivered at term (≥37 weeks' gestation). Pre-second stage cesarean delivery rate was defined as all elective cesarean deliveries and those emergency cesarean deliveries that occurred before full cervical dilatation was achieved as a proportion of the total number of births. The second stage cesarean delivery rate and assisted vaginal birth rate were calculated according to the respective mode of delivery as a proportion of the number of cases that reached full cervical dilatation. The rates of these 3 modes of births were compared among the parity groups and among the 8 units. Using a bubble chart, each unit's second stage cesarean delivery rate (y-axis) was plotted against its pre-second stage cesarean delivery rate (x-axis) as a bubble. Each unit's second stage cesarean delivery to assisted vaginal birth ratio was represented by the size of the bubble. RESULTS: During the study period, a total of 353,434 singleton cephalic presenting term pregnancies were delivered in the 8 units, and 180,496 (51.1%) were from nulliparous mothers. When compared with the multiparous group, the nulliparous group had a significantly lower pre-second stage cesarean delivery rate (18.58% vs 21.26%; P<.001) but a higher second stage cesarean delivery rate (0.79% vs 0.22%; P<.001) and a higher assisted vaginal birth rate (17.61% vs 3.58%; P<.001). Using the bubble of their averages as a reference point in the bubble chart, the 8 units' bubbles were clustered into 5 regions indicating their differences in practice: unit B and unit H were close to the average in the center. Unit A and unit F were at the upper right corner with a higher pre-second stage cesarean delivery rate and second stage cesarean delivery rate. Unit D and unit E were at the opposite end. Unit C was at the upper left corner with a low pre-second stage cesarean delivery rate but a high second stage cesarean delivery rate, whereas unit G was at the opposite end. Unit C and unit G were also in the extremes in terms of pre-second stage cesarean delivery to assisted vaginal birth ratio (0.09 and 0.01, respectively). Although some units seemed to have very similar second stage cesarean delivery rates, their obstetrical practices were differentiated by the bubble chart. CONCLUSION: The second stage cesarean delivery rate must be evaluated in the context of the rates of pre-second stage cesarean delivery and assisted vaginal birth. A bubble chart is a useful method for analyzing the relationship among these 3 variables to differentiate the obstetrical practice between different units.
引用
- Hung MWC, Lee LTL, Chiu CPH, et al. The use of bubble charts in analyzing second stage cesarean delivery rates. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2024. PMID: 38408623. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2024.02.283
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。