比较吸湿性宫颈扩张器与宫颈成熟球囊用于门诊宫颈成熟的随机对照试验
该随机对照等效性试验比较合成吸湿性扩张器与30 mL硅胶单球囊导管用于门诊宫颈成熟,主要结局为入院至分娩时间,预设等效界值3小时。2019年3月1日至2021年5月31日筛查1605例,174例完成研究,扩张器组平均入院至分娩时间18.01小时 vs 球囊组17.55小时(P=.04),两组疼痛评分和患者满意度相似,球囊组早期入院和设备脱出率显著更高。
要点
- 扩张器组与球囊组入院至分娩时间等效:18.01小时 vs 17.55小时(P=.04)。
- 初产妇剖宫产率相似:扩张器组28.1% vs 球囊组29.7%。
- 球囊组早期入院和设备脱出率显著高于扩张器组。
核心结论
- 尽管未达到入组目标,本研究提示合成吸湿性扩张器和单球囊导管用于门诊宫颈成熟均有效,入院至分娩时间、疼痛评分和患者满意度相似。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照等效性试验,比较合成吸湿性扩张器与30 mL硅胶单球囊导管用于初产妇和经产妇的引产。
- 主要结局为入院至分娩时间,预设等效界值为3小时;次要目标为患者结局和观点。
- 2019年3月1日至2021年5月31日筛查1605例患者,174例完成研究。
主要发现
- 扩张器组平均入院至分娩时间为18.01小时,球囊组为17.55小时(P=.04)。
- 初产妇剖宫产率扩张器组为28.1%,球囊组为29.7%。
- 两组置入时和入院时宫颈扩张程度及疼痛评分中位数相似。
- 总体患者满意度高,扩张器组为92.8%,球囊组为96.2%。
- 球囊组早期入院率和设备脱出率显著高于扩张器组。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为合成吸湿性扩张器和单球囊导管用于门诊宫颈成熟均有效,入院至分娩时间、疼痛评分和患者满意度相似。
局限性
- 未达到入组目标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Outpatient term preinduction cervical ripening with mechanical agents has been associated with reduced length of stay, decreased cesarean delivery rates, low maternal and neonatal complications, and increased incidence of vaginal delivery within 24 hours. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to demonstrate equivalent efficacy between synthetic hygroscopic dilators and the single-balloon catheter for outpatient cervical ripening. STUDY DESIGN: This randomized control equivalence trial compared synthetic hygroscopic dilators with the 30-mL silicone single-balloon catheter in primiparous and multiparous patients undergoing labor induction. The primary outcome was time from admission to delivery, with a prespecified 3-hour margin of equivalence. The secondary objectives were patient outcomes and perspectives. RESULTS: Between March 1, 2019, and May 31, 2021, 1605 patients met the screening criteria, and 174 patients completed the study. The mean admission-to-delivery time was equivalent at 18.01 hours for the dilator group vs 17.55 hours for the balloon group (P=.04). The cesarean delivery rate of primiparous patients was similar at 28.1% with dilators vs 29.7% with the balloon. The groups had similar median cervical dilation and pain scores on insertion and admission. Overall patient satisfaction was high, 92.8% with dilators vs 96.2% with the balloon. The balloon group had significantly higher rates of early admission and device expulsion. CONCLUSION: Although the enrollment goal was not met, our study suggests that synthetic hygroscopic dilators and the single-balloon catheter for outpatient cervical ripening are both efficacious with similar time from admission to delivery, pain scores, and patient satisfaction with the procedure.
引用
- Lu AMR, Lin B, Shahani D, et al. Randomized control trial comparing hygroscopic cervical dilators to cervical ripening balloon for outpatient cervical ripening. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2024. PMID: 38417552. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2024.101318
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。