根治性子宫切除术手术解剖分类的国际专家共识
该研究联合国际妇科肿瘤专家,通过尸体解剖图像和改良德尔菲法(3轮)就2017版Querleu-Morrow根治性子宫切除术分类达成共识,29名专家完成全部13个问题,除1题(86%)外共识率均超90%。
要点
- 2017版Querleu-Morrow分类是定义和描述根治性子宫切除术范围的有力工具,国际专家共识度高。
- A型和B2型根治性子宫切除术定义的共识率相对较低,这两型是2017更新版的主要创新点。
- B1型和C型定义的共识率最高,这两型是最常实施的根治性子宫切除术。
核心结论
- 2017版Querleu-Morrow分类被证明是定义和描述根治性子宫切除术范围的有力工具,在国际妇科肿瘤专家中达成高度共识。
- 在临床实践和临床研究中,掌握并实施子宫切除术根治程度的准确定义至关重要。
研究设计与样本
- 与妇科肿瘤国际专家合作,通过尸体解剖时拍摄的13张图像记录A、B、C型根治性子宫切除术的解剖模板。
- 在国际根治性子宫切除术专家中发放关于命名及定义或描述的在线调查,采用3步改良德尔菲法建立共识。
- 共识定义为对特定图像相关问题回答“是”;回答“否”者可评论并提供理由。
- 根据专家回复修订图像说明并作为第二轮调查的一部分重新分发,最终汇编图像和说明以解剖学方式阐释并定义或描述宫颈周围组织的侧方、腹侧和背侧切除。
- 共29名专家完成全部13个问题的整个流程。
主要发现
- 最终共识除1个问题(86%)外,所有问题均超过90%。
- 共识率相对较低的问题涉及A型和B2型根治性子宫切除术的定义,这两型是2017更新版(2008版Querleu-Morrow分类)的主要创新。
- 共识率最高的问题涉及B1型和C型的定义,这两型是最常实施的根治性子宫切除术。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The anatomic descriptions and extents of radical hysterectomy often vary across the literature and operative reports worldwide. The same nomenclature is often used to describe varying procedures, and different nomenclature is often used to describe the same procedure despite the availability of guideline and classification systems. This makes it difficult to interpret retrospective surgical reports, analyze surgical databases, understand technique descriptions, and interpret the findings of surgical studies. OBJECTIVE: In collaboration with international experts in gynecologic oncology, the purpose of this study was to establish a consensus in defining and interpreting the 2017 updated Querleu-Morrow classification of radical hysterectomies. STUDY DESIGN: The anatomic templates of type A, B, and C radical hysterectomy were documented through a set of 13 images taken at the time of cadaver dissection. An online survey related to radical hysterectomy nomenclature and definitions or descriptions of the associated procedures was circulated among international experts in radical hysterectomy. A 3-step modified Delphi method was used to establish consensus. Image legends were amended according to the experts' responses and then redistributed as part of a second round of the survey. Consensus was defined by a yes response to a question concerning a specific image. Anyone who responded no to a question was welcome to comment and provide justification. A final set of images and legends were compiled to anatomically illustrate and define or describe a lateral, ventral, and dorsal excision of the tissues surrounding the cervix. RESULTS: In total, there were 13 questions to review, and 29 experts completed the whole process. Final consensus exceeded 90% for all questions except 1 (86%). Questions with relatively lower consensus rates concerned the definitions of types A and B2 radical hysterectomy, which were the main innovations of the 2017 updated version of the 2008 Querleu-Morrow classification. Questions with the highest consensus rates concerned the definitions of types B1 and C, which are the most frequently performed radical hysterectomies. CONCLUSION: The 2017 version of the Querleu-Morrow classification proved to be a robust tool for defining and describing the extent of radical hysterectomies with a high level of consensus among international experts in gynecologic oncology. Knowledge and implementation of the exact definitions of hysterectomy radicality are imperative in clinical practice and clinical research.
引用
- Querleu D, Cibula D, Abu-Rustum NR, et al. International expert consensus on the surgical anatomic classification of radical hysterectomies. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37788719. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.09.099
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。