文献速递妇科

开放与微创子宫切除术围手术期患者报告结局的纵向比较

Longitudinal perioperative patient-reported outcomes in open compared with minimally invasive hysterectomy.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2023-10-11

本研究在加速康复外科路径下前瞻性比较646例子宫切除术患者(开放254例、微创392例)的围手术期患者报告症状负担与功能干扰,使用MD Anderson症状量表评估至术后8周。开放组出院时症状严重度和多项症状干扰显著更高,恢复至无或轻度症状的时间更长,但两组均在数天至数周内改善且差异并非均有临床意义。

要点

  • 开放子宫切除术后出院时整体疼痛、疲劳、食欲差、腹胀、便秘评分显著高于微创组。
  • 开放组恢复至无或轻度整体疼痛(14 vs 4天)、疲劳(8 vs 4天)、睡眠紊乱(2 vs 2天)、食欲(1.5 vs 1天)的时间显著更长。
  • 微创组恢复至无或轻度腹痛(42 vs 28天)和腹胀(42 vs 8天)的时间显著更长。

核心结论

  • 开放子宫切除术与术后即刻症状负担增加及恢复至无或轻度症状负担和身体功能干扰的时间更长相关。
  • 但开放与微创手术后患者报告指标均在数天至数周内改善,且差异并非均有临床意义。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性比较646例子宫切除术患者,其中开放手术254例、微创手术392例,适应症包括良性和恶性,均在加速康复外科方案下。
  • 使用经验证的MD Anderson症状量表在围手术期至术后8周进行测量。
  • 采用Fisher精确检验、卡方检验、校正纵向广义线性混合模型和Kaplan-Meier曲线分析。

主要发现

  • 开放组术前身体功能干扰显著更差(P=.001)。
  • 出院时开放组整体症状严重度均分及整体疼痛(P<.001)、腹痛(P<.001)、疲劳(P=.001)、食欲差(P<.001)、腹胀(P=.041)、便秘(P<.001)的中重度评分显著高于微创组。
  • 出院时开放组身体功能干扰评分显著高于微创组(5.0 vs 2.7;P<.001),两组情感干扰无差异。
  • 术后1至8周开放组除排尿疼痛外所有评估症状和干扰指标均分更差,但两组评分均提示轻度症状负担和干扰。
  • 恢复至无或轻度症状的中位时间开放组更长:整体疼痛(14 vs 4天;P<.001)、疲劳(8 vs 4天;P<.001)、睡眠紊乱(2 vs 2天;P<.001)、食欲(1.5 vs 1天;P<.001);微创组更长:腹痛(42 vs 28天;P<.001)、腹胀(42 vs 8天;P<.001);身体功能干扰开放组更长(36 vs 32天;P<.001),复合情感功能无差异(5 vs 5天;P=.07)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: There are few prospective studies in the gynecologic surgical literature that compared patient-reported outcomes between open and minimally invasive hysterectomies within enhanced recovery after surgery pathways. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare prospectively collected perioperative patient-reported symptom burden and interference measures in open compared with minimally invasive hysterectomy cohorts within enhanced recovery after surgery pathways. STUDY DESIGN: We compared patient-reported symptom burden and functional interference in 646 patients who underwent a hysterectomy (254 underwent open surgery and 392 underwent minimally invasive surgery) for benign and malignant indications under enhanced recovery after surgery protocols. Outcomes were prospectively measured using the validated MD Anderson Symptom Inventory, which was administered perioperatively up to 8 weeks after surgery. Cohorts were compared using Fisher exact and chi-squared tests, adjusted longitudinal generalized linear mixed modeling, and Kaplan Meier curves to model return to no or mild symptoms. RESULTS: The open cohort had significantly worse preoperative physical functional interference (P=.001). At the time of hospital discharge postoperatively, the open cohort reported significantly higher mean symptom severity scores and more moderate or severe scores for overall (P<.001) and abdominal pain (P<.001), fatigue (P=.001), lack of appetite (P<.001), bloating (P=.041), and constipation (P<.001) when compared with the minimally invasive cohort. The open cohort also had significantly higher interference in physical functioning (score 5.0 vs 2.7; P<.001) than the minimally invasive cohort at the time of discharge with no differences in affective interference between the 2 groups. In mixed modeling analysis of the first 7 postoperative days, both cohorts reported improved symptom burden and functional interference over time with generally slower recovery in the open cohort. From 1 to 8 postoperative weeks, the open cohort had worse mean scores for all evaluated symptoms and interference measures except for pain with urination, although scores indicated mild symptomatic burden and interference in both cohorts. The time to return to no or mild symptoms was significantly longer in the open cohort for overall pain (14 vs 4 days; P<.001), fatigue (8 vs 4 days; P<.001), disturbed sleep (2 vs 2 days; P<.001), and appetite (1.5 vs 1 days; P<.001) but was significantly longer in the minimally invasive cohort for abdominal pain (42 vs 28 days; P<.001) and bloating (42 vs 8 days; P<.001). The median time to return to no or mild functional interference was longer in the open than in the minimally invasive hysterectomy cohort for physical functioning (36 vs 32 days; P<.001) with no difference in compositive affective functioning (5 vs 5 days; P=.07) between the groups. CONCLUSION: Open hysterectomy was associated with increased symptom burden in the immediate postoperative period and longer time to return to no or mild symptom burden and interference with physical functioning. However, all patient-reported measures improved within days to weeks of both open and minimally invasive surgery and differences were not always clinically significant.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Huepenbecker SP, Iniesta MD, Wang XS, et al. Longitudinal perioperative patient-reported outcomes in open compared with minimally invasive hysterectomy. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37827271. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.10.012

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。