生殖内分泌与不孕症专科培训推荐信中是否存在性别差异?
该队列研究分析了某中西部学术机构单年度生殖内分泌与不孕症专科培训申请者的推荐信,共纳入269封进行语言学和定性编码分析。结果显示男性申请者的推荐信平均字数更多(537 vs 474,P=.04),且更多使用风险词(P=.01);定性分析发现男性申请者信中出现领导力、利他、强推荐等主题更频繁,女性申请者信中出现质疑性表述和个人生活披露更频繁。
要点
- 男性申请者推荐信平均字数537 vs 女性474(P=.04)。
- 描述男性申请者时使用风险词更多(P=.01)。
- 女性申请者信更常见质疑性表述和个人生活披露。
核心结论
- 推荐信写作者和申请者之间均存在性别差异。
- 女性申请者更可能被质疑性表述和个人生活披露描述,男性更可能被利他主义和强推荐描述。
- 提高偏见意识并实施缓解策略将改善推荐信中的性别公平。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,某中西部学术机构单年度生殖内分泌与不孕症专科培训申请者的推荐信。
- 共272封信来自72名申请者,其中女性54名(76%),男性17名(24%);1名申请者因未注明性别被排除,269封信纳入定量语言学和定性编码分析。
主要发现
- 为男性撰写的推荐信平均字数高于为女性撰写的推荐信(537 vs 474,P=.04)。
- 语言学探究与字数分析显示,描述男性申请者时使用风险词更多(P=.01)。
- 按写信者性别比较词类,女性写信者更频繁使用社群、情感和家庭词类,男性写信者更频繁使用归属相关词。
- 定性分析显示,男性申请者的信更频繁描述领导力、利他主义、与患者的融洽关系及强推荐,女性申请者的信更常提及质疑性表述和个人生活披露。
- 女性申请者的信更常将候选人描述为不制造戏剧性、不易被「激怒」、不抱怨,且更频繁披露父母身份。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE(S): To determine if gender differences exist in letters of recommendation (LORs) for reproductive endocrinology and infertility fellowship. DESIGN: Cohort study. SETTING: Academic medical center. PATIENTS: A cohort of applicants to a reproductive endocrinology and infertility fellowship program at a single Midwestern academic institution in a single year. INTERVENTIONS: None. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Quantitative measures included linguistics inquiry and word count analysis, with 4 summary variables and 25 word categories, to quantify tone and themes present by gender. Performing qualitative analysis in parallel to linguistic analysis allowed for the exploration of themes not conveyed in quantitative methods alone. Qualitative measures included the frequency of code themes in LOR by applicant gender. RESULTS: There were 272 letters from 72 applicants, 54 (76%) of which were women and 17 (24%) were men. One applicant was excluded because gender information was not specified; 269 letters were included in the quantitative linguistics and qualitative coding analysis. One hundred 10 letters (41%) were written by women and 159 (59%) by men. LOR written for men had a higher mean word count than those written for women (537 vs. 474, P=.04). Linguistics Inquiry and Word Count analysis exhibited more risk words used to describe men applicants (P=.01). When comparing word categories by letter writer gender, women letter writers more frequently used communal, affect, and home word categories whereas men writers more frequently used affiliation-related words. Qualitative analysis revealed that letters for men applicants described leadership, altruism, rapport with patients, and strong endorsements more frequently, whereas women applicants' letters more often mentioned doubt raisers and disclosures of personal life. In addition, letters for women applicants more often described candidates as drama free, not easy to "fluster," and not complainers. Furthermore, letters for women more frequently disclosed parenthood status. CONCLUSIONS: Gender differences exist among both letter writers and applicants. Qualitative analysis revealed that women applicants were more likely to be described with doubt raisers and personal life disclosures, whereas men were more likely to be described by their altruism and with a strong endorsement. Increasing bias awareness and implementing mitigation strategies would improve gender equity in LOR.
引用
- Bolten KM, Brown O, Komorowski AS, et al. Do gender differences exist in letters of recommendation for reproductive endocrinology and infertility fellowship? Fertil Steril. 2023. PMID: 37777108. doi:10.1016/j.fertnstert.2023.09.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。